Skip to content

Smart Charge by RiDERgy · Season 2, Episode 9

flexibility, grid congestion, the cost of public charging and V2G

Jaap Burger

independent expert on EV grid integration

13 October 2026 · 1 hr 24 min · English · Host: Claudio Geyken

Chapters (15)

Key takeaways

  • Netherlands grid map almost entirely red for new connections; flexibility makes it matter less.

  • Main lever: move consumption to follow renewable generation shaped by weather; not all peaks are equal, a charging peak with a solar peak helps the grid.

  • Show and tell: quantify shiftable volumes, time spans, load-shape quality; DSOs need evidence.

Smart Charge Leader · 13 October 2026

The industry argues for flexibility; grid operators wait for proof

The Netherlands' grid map is almost entirely red for new connections. Yet distributed flexibility from single EVs reaches the market this autumn. Jaap Burger, 15 years in EV-grid integration, says the gap is not technical, it is evidentiary.

By RiDERgy editorial

Jaap Burger travelled from Utrecht to Berlin by electric coach, charging once at a truck hub near Hanover. Long-distance electric coach travel is no longer a story about the future. The grid map of the Netherlands is nearly all red for new connections: fixed capacity cannot be allocated at most locations. Yet flexibility, meaning the ability to shift when and how much an EV charges, makes that red map matter less. Burger started at the City of Amsterdam on the first public on-street charge points in 2011, when roaming meant operators emailing spreadsheets of charge data records. Since 2015 he has worked on linking connected-car APIs to utility trading desks, and now translates between innovators and regulators at European level. His call to the industry: show and tell. Quantify how much volume you can shift and how well you can shape it, because DSOs need evidence before they treat flexibility as a resource they can rely on.

What this episode makes clear: expensive public charging is a cost problem before it is a pricing problem. Flexibility at multiple levels, including non-firm capacity agreements, local flexibility markets, and time-varying network tariffs, brings down the CPO cost base, which lowers the price for the user, which grows the market.

The cost loop is structural. Soft costs for permitting, planning, grid connections, hardware and software drive public charging prices up, which lowers utilisation, which lowers revenue and bankability, which slows rollout. Burger acknowledges the loop but reframes it as a cost problem first. Staying within the grid connection you already have saves considerable grid cost; consuming on-site PV avoids levies. The main lever is moving consumption to follow renewable generation, which is shaped by weather rather than demand. The other lever is avoiding grid peaks, but not all peaks are equal: a charging peak coinciding with local solar production helps the grid, while early demand charges inside network tariffs can flatten one peak only to create a bigger, later one. The Netherlands now demonstrates the alternative: a new mechanism opening autumn 2026 lets distributed flexibility from single EVs, delivered via mobility service providers and aggregators, participate in congestion management at low voltage level. It took CPOs, an MSP platform, and DSOs demonstrating it at scale. Denmark aggregates EV charging to deliver real-time services to the transmission system operator. Germany has 800 distribution grid operators with different tariff structures; the Durchleitungsmodell, or pass-through model, offloads balancing from CPOs to MSPs, but MSPs must evolve from invoicers into stacked service providers offering best time, best location, price nudging and route planning. Real-time CPO-to-MSP price endpoints, standard in the Netherlands and utopian in Germany, and enforcement of the non-discriminatory pricing requirement in the European Alternative Fuels Infrastructure Regulation are prerequisites.

5 min read

Show notes

The grid map of the Netherlands is almost entirely red for new connections, and that matters far less if you are flexible. Jaap Burger, who has worked on electric vehicle grid integration for over fifteen years, argues that flexibility is what decides whether electrification is affordable, and that the industry keeps arguing for it instead of demonstrating it.

Jaap started at the city of Amsterdam on its first public on-street charge points, at a time when the roles of charge point operator and mobility service provider were not yet clearly separated and roaming meant operators emailing each other spreadsheets of identifiers and charge data records. He has been freelance for eleven years, and since 2015, when he helped build smart charging on a connected car API linked to a utility's trading desk, his work has moved steadily towards grid integration and European policy. He describes his role as translating for policymakers what innovators can already do, and translating back to the market what regulation could actually do for them. He arrived for this conversation from Utrecht by electric coach, with a single charging stop at a truck charging hub near Hanover.

The conversation gets specific. Jaap argues that expensive public charging is a cost problem before it is a pricing problem: permitting, planning, grid connections, hardware and software set the price an operator must ask, which shapes utilisation, revenue and bankability, and therefore how fast that operator can scale at all. He makes the case that not every peak is equally bad, that a charging peak coinciding with local solar production can help the grid, and that some early demand charges inside network tariffs flatten one peak only to create a bigger one later. On the Netherlands, he explains how a grid map that is almost entirely red for new connections coexists with distributed flexibility from single vehicles reaching the flexibility market, with a new mechanism opening this autumn at low voltage level, and what it took to get there: operators, an MSP platform and grid operators demonstrating it at scale. He is measured on vehicle to grid, which works today in captive fleets with one carmaker, one operator and one source of data, and warns that the excitement around it obscures the larger near term value of unidirectional smart charging. He also covers the German pass through model, real time price endpoints from operators to mobility service providers, the non discriminatory pricing requirement in the European alternative fuels infrastructure regulation, and the fragmentation of roughly 800 distribution grid operators in Germany.

An episode about the gap between what flexibility can already do and what the rules currently reward, and about what fleets and operators need from each other to close it.

Resources mentioned

The guest's company

  • Watture

    Jaap Burger's independent consultancy, through which he has worked as a freelancer since 2015 on EV grid integration, smart charging and policy.

Regulation and standards

  • AFIR: Regulation (EU) 2023/1804

    The EU Alternative Fuels Infrastructure Regulation Jaap cites as already requiring non-discriminatory pricing between payment methods for public charging.

  • ISO 15118-20 (vehicle to grid communication interface)

    The 2nd-generation V2G communication standard Jaap says is still being amended (Amendment 1) to clearly define AC bidirectional charging, explaining why early V2G-ready chargers became stranded investments.

Companies and tools

  • intercharge network conference (icnc)

    The Hubject-organized Berlin e-mobility event (icnc) Jaap and Claudio just attended, whose 2026 theme on smart charging at scale frames the episode's opening discussion.

  • AMPECO

    Orlin Radev, AMPECO's CEO, gave the icnc keynote 'Get Big, Get Niche or Get Out' that Claudio references when discussing market specialization.

  • TandemDrive

    The Dutch CPO/MSP software company that organized the electric coach Jaap and other e-mobility professionals rode from Utrecht to Berlin for the conference.

  • Milence

    Operator of the heavy-duty truck charging hub near Hanover where Jaap's electric coach stopped to recharge en route to Berlin.

  • FlixBus

    The long-distance coach operator Claudio mentions following for its views on how far electrification of coach routes can realistically go.

  • OCPI (Open Charge Point Interface)

    The open roaming protocol, maintained by the EVRoaming Foundation, that Jaap references when describing how EV roaming between CPOs and MSPs became standardized after the early spreadsheet-based era.

  • Hubject

    The roaming hub Claudio and Jaap discuss as a later development that professionalized EV roaming beyond the manual spreadsheet-sharing Jaap experienced in Amsterdam around 2011.

  • smartEn (Smart Energy Europe)

    The Brussels-based flexibility industry association whose reports Claudio and Jaap credit for tracking and quantifying demand-side flexibility levers across European countries.

  • decarbon1ze

    The German company, co-founded by Knut Hechtfischer, behind the controversial 'Durchleitungsmodell' (pass-through model) Jaap and Claudio discuss for separating charge point operation from energy supply responsibility.

  • Deftpower

    The Dutch MSP platform ('Devpower' in the transcript) Jaap cites repeatedly as the company demonstrating distributed EV flexibility at scale in the Netherlands, and whose smart charging service he personally uses to reduce his own public charging bill.

  • Bundesnetzagentur (Federal Network Agency)

    The German national regulator Claudio names as one of the bodies the flexibility industry needs to engage to change how grid tariffs are structured.

Cite this episode

Geyken, C. (host), Burger, J. (guest). "flexibility, grid congestion, the cost of public charging and V2G." Smart Charge by RiDERgy, Season 2, Episode 9, 13 October 2026. www.ridergy.com/podcast/s2-ep-9-jaap-burger-independent-expert-on-ev-grid-integration-flexibility-grid-c

Transcript

11,211 words · machine transcript

  • Claudio Geyken, host
  • Jaap Burger, guest

Cleaned up from a machine transcript. Translations are machine-generated and may contain errors.

Claudio Geyken

Welcome to the Smart Charge by RiDERgy podcast. This is Claudio Gaikin, founder and CEO of RiDERgy. This is your show to learn about all things energy management and smart charging innovation for electric vehicles and fleets. Jaap Burger traveled from Utrecht to Berlin for this episode by Electric Coach with exactly one charging stop at a truck charging hub near Hannover. Long distance electric coach travel is no longer a story about the future.

Jaap has worked in e Mobility for 15 years. He started at the city of Amsterdam on the first public on street charge points, back when roaming meant operators emailing each other, spreadsheets of identifiers and charge data records.

Today he works independently with grid operators, chargepoint operators and policy makers, and technologists increasingly at the European level, translating for regulators, working what innovators can already do in translating back to the market, what regulation could do for them.

We talk about why the grid map of the Netherlands is almost entirely red for new connections and why that matters far less if you're flexible about the new Dutch mechanism opening this autumn to distributed flexibility at low voltage and about the cost loop that keeps public charging expensive. Enjoy the conversation with one real smart charging expert. Hey Jaap, how are you today?

ICNC and E-Mobility Landscape

Jaap Burger

Hi.

Jaap Burger

Doing well.

Jaap Burger

Still a little bit tired from the festival that is icnc.

Claudio Geyken

Yes.

Claudio Geyken

We just had it the last three days. Right,.

Jaap Burger

Right, right.

Jaap Burger

So that's lots of talks. Talks, talks, meetings, listening, chatting.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah.

Claudio Geyken

And maybe to give the listeners before we of course, learn more about your background. Let's just discuss it quickly. So what's your main takeaways or do you have any thoughts that were particularly in your mind after the event?

Jaap Burger

Well, the event grows every year, so I'm always impressed how much more people are in the E mobility ecosystem. And come here. What I found fascinating, especially this year, the theme was about smart charging at scale, but I found it fascinating how many actors, companies are active and specializing on specific aspects of that, whether it comes from software operations, analysis or even financing of flexibility.

It's fascinating to see how that grows. And I think looking back even just maybe five years ago, you would have sort of the single company trying to do it all and sort of bring it all into one system. And now you see there really is a need for and there's really a growth market for those that are able to specialize and really deliver upon the promise of unlocking flexibility, which is something I believe is really, really needed.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah, no, totally. And maybe just to also already, as we will probably do some jargon, use some jargon, we can already,. For that, start discussing Some things and making sure we have a framework.

Jaap Burger

Sorry.

Claudio Geyken

So like I also agree, flexibility or call it energy management or call it smart charging, sometimes being used interchangeably are definitely growing as concepts and as different, I think nuances and niches in the market, different players coming along and I think that's important. It's right.

I agree also with Orlin who was having a keynote as the main sponsor of the event and the founder of peco, where his keynote's title was Get Big, Get Niche or Get Out. And I liked it because I think there's something to it that you really need to break down this complexity of the topics we'll dive deep into. You need to have specialists really understanding that and owning it.

Jaap Burger

Yeah, fully agree.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah.

Claudio Geyken

So I also attended obviously, as you can hear it out and yeah, also just a few thoughts beyond that. I think it's incredible how it grew. I think Hubject, who is the organizer is doing a great job there. I'm not sure if there's much larger conferences around this particular topic than that one in the world. So then that is all impressive to be at an airport as well, organizing it in the middle of Berlin.

Jaap Burger

What I find impressive how much it's also a networking event plus a high quality conference and sometimes it's quite hard, I mean because the networking obviously is so important that you sometimes just miss some of the conference parts. I'm also happy that all of those are being recorded and you can watch them later to catch up on those.

Claudio Geyken

Right.

Claudio Geyken

I also watch them on YouTube and also probably not for the very newbies in the, in the EV industry, but even them I think you can do some hand holding and introduce and it's a very open networking environment where you can see people just talking and exchanging knowledge and updates and others spending time watching to the speakers live as well.

I think it's sometimes also good to grasp the person live, but of course it's great that you can watch them all on YouTube.

Jaap Burger

Yep.

Jaap Burger

Yeah.

Jaap Burger

And what I found especially useful, I mean there's a main stage, there's an innovation stage, a tech stage. Some of the sponsors also have their own stages. So there's a whole range of topics being discussed. So depending on what your interest is, whether it's really the technical details of communication or whether it's about financing or. Or whether it's about actual use cases, there is something for everyone in the program.

Claudio Geyken

Totally.

Claudio Geyken

This year for me, what I found super interesting was also the African session. There was a few very important stakeholders from Africa that attended and was interesting to get really a very closed view and discussion. Then after their presentation and the podium discussion how Kenya is basically using a lot of electric buses for their operations.

And I talked with the one in charge and they were agreeing when I was asking if it's the right moment now that developing countries are leapfrogging now finally ICE vehicles with E mobility like they did with previous technologies. And they were saying, yeah, it's the right moment. TCOS costs alone, we don't really need regulation. It's a beautiful time as well to experience that.

Jaap Burger

Right?

Jaap Burger

Yeah.

Jaap Burger

That's fascinating to see and yeah, and that's some of those learnings that you probably. You need to be in the room and see the people discussing it to really understand and feel how important that change is.

Claudio Geyken

And buses are a good segue. Maybe we can close with that anecdote as well. So we don't spend too much time on the ICNC now as we want to hear about your background and talk really about smart charging in more detail. But you live in the Netherlands, right. And you came by bus, but not any bus. Tell us.

Electric Coach Travel

Jaap Burger

No.

Jaap Burger

So this was an electric coach organized by Tandem Drive, a Dutch company that does a lot of. Is basically a software layer for CPOs and MSPs in the EV space. And they gathered a group of E mobility people from the Netherlands. So we traveled from Utrecht to Berlin. Electric codes we had to charge one time in between because it has a practical range of around 600km which is just short of the distance Utrecht, Berlin.

So we stopped at a heavy duty vehicle charging hub from Miland close to Hanover, which was fascinating to see also how much it is also already in use by electric trucks. And obviously the. The coach being able to travel by electric coach long distance, it's no longer something for the distant future. It's something that can be done already today.

So I would expect maybe some of those operating commercial long distance bus lines could start to use electric coaches. To be honest, I think in the first phase it would make most sense doing things on a single charge. So all those trips that are within sort of the battery range of the vehicle.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah.

Jaap Burger

But as we see continuous development of the charging infrastructure, the charging speed, but also charging locations because you would need different amenities that this can change rapidly as well. Because as you already mentioned for the case for Kenya and other African countries, that applies in Europe as well. Obviously the economics just makes sense of electrifying.

Jaap’s E-Mobility Background

Claudio Geyken

Yeah, very cool. Yeah. I'm also following FLIX actively and their opinions on electrification rate that is possible. So Cool that you experienced it firsthand. So yeah, let's dive a bit about and learn more about you. Can you tell us what's your background? You can also go a little bit back just so that we understand how you arrived to be the smart charging expert, as I used to say a few times these days.

Jaap Burger

So my first work in E Mobility started over 15 years already, so it feels like a long time now saying that. So I worked for the City of Amsterdam at that time and they were deploying the first public on street EV charging points. And I helped them shape the processes, the interaction with the user, but also the interaction with the relevant stakeholders, notably the grid operator. I became project leader together with the whole team.

Obviously we tendered for public charting network. We did a second tender and for that I had to learn and understand some of the technical standards, the concepts, the roles. But also many of these roles were still undefined at that time. So together obviously with others we had to sort of find and define some of the interactions in that system.

Claudio Geyken

So just maybe there to also as we will probably discuss these roles. So just CPO, CPMs, MSP, all these jargon, it was not defined back in 2011 then. Well,.

Jaap Burger

There were different names, but so for instance that you really had a clear division in those roles. CPO MSP wasn't as clearly defined. So most of the examples that were available also from other countries like the US were single systems networks built on the idea that all of it would be within one system. So both the CPMs managing the charging stations, but also the user management and the billing.

But we in Amsterdam wanted to have a system where you could have multiple charge point operators, but the user could have a single access token at that time still the RFID cards that are still being used, but to enable users to use that single access mechanism to unlock charging at different operators, whether it was a public charging operator in City A or public charging operator in City B, but also including the private charting.

So we had to shape a system where you had these roles more clearly defined. So who is operating the charging point and what do they do? So what does that until authentication, measuring billing, but who to send the bill to. And then obviously that recipient would be the MSP.

So they would take on information from various CPOs, ensure that it gets bundled into a single invoice for the driver, which also involved basically defining the concept of roaming, EV roaming and from there on obviously all things professionalized and there became dedicated roles also within roaming protocols for that.

Claudio Geyken

Because Hubject was not created in 2011. I don't remember. We had a few episodes about Hubject with founders, but I can't recall was it. Did you use them already back then? No,.

Jaap Burger

No, no.

Jaap Burger

So all of this predates hubject and predates other roaming hubs or protocols at the time. So at the very early stage, roaming meant that there was a white list in a spreadsheet that was shared between operators, and that was the basis for sending other spreadsheets with chart data records. So knowing which identifier charts at which charging station,.

Claudio Geyken

Really talking spreadsheets, CSV files, Excel that were sent by email around. Yeah, right,.

Jaap Burger

Right, right.

Jaap Burger

Really, really basic. And I'm glad that system has since then obviously evolved and has become much more professional, secure, much more efficient and standardized. Yeah.

Claudio Geyken

Yes, interesting.

Claudio Geyken

And so then from this experience, you went to do what?

Jaap Burger

Right, so I went to work with various companies. I also became a freelancer now, 11 years ago, working in this space. So VR is my company and I work for different organizations in the public space, private space, but more and more focusing on the EV grid integration topic, looking at it from the user perspective. So how is the user being incentivized to provide flexibility in their charting session needs? How are they being informed?

What are their benefits? Also obviously financial benefits. What does that need in terms of interaction between the different actors? Obviously the user, msp, cpo, but then more also on the technical level, you get to the charging station, the charging station might need to interact with other charging stations on the same site. There might be an energy management system on site that you want to use.

There might be inputs, forecasts of energy production, energy prices that you might want to incorporate in that. And especially the past five years I've been looking at that also from a more regulatory and policy perspective at the European level. So how is EU legislation helping shape that market? How are European states deploying that at scale? And what is the market doing? What are innovators doing?

Basically pushing also the boundaries maybe of existing frameworks. So I also sometimes try to describe it as I try to translate to policymakers what the innovators already can do and the barriers they face, because they are at the, maybe at the edge of what is possible. So they are the first ones running into barriers. So they can identify maybe what needs to be changed in regulation or in policy to advance this topic. And also the other way around.

I mean, there are many companies in this space that sometimes struggle to understand what policy and regulation can do for them. Not necessarily as a burden, as it's often perceived, but also Sometimes shape opportunities.

Claudio Geyken

And just to understand from this Amsterdam experience, how did you get to do this? I saw some of these experiences, but maybe you can elaborate already on what were the key milestones that led you then to do this.

Jaap Burger

Right.

Jaap Burger

So for instance, one of the first things I did as a freelancer was for an energy supplier in the Netherlands that had a basic idea how to do EV smart charging using the Connected Car API. So that was back in 2015, having electric vehicles on the road, more like a computer where you have a API which is a programming interface. I don't know how much we need to explain all those acronyms, but.

Claudio Geyken

Not too many. It's okay.

Jaap Burger

So at that time it was something novel. That car became much more than something for mobility, but also just like any Internet connected device becomes something you can exchange information with, send commands to it. And that enabled this company to start and stop charging remotely on the vehicle and by linking that to the trading desk of that utility.

Early Smart-Charging Model

Jaap Burger

So being able to tap into short term needs maybe to start charging and thereby absorb some of the surplus or maybe to pause charging to prevent being on the wrong side of the energy balance obviously had a value for that utility, but a value large enough to carve out a piece of debt to both obviously finance the company, but also get the user on board.

So they were receiving bonus payments for providing that flexibility and they would see their energy bills reduced through the concept of smart charting.

Claudio Geyken

Very cool.

Claudio Geyken

And this is already in 2015. And just to be precise, as I like us to then also get to that level of detail. So did they use it for maybe also just explain to you to the listeners because we rarely discuss these type of topics. So there is an imbalance. I think that's what you are hinting to.

Jaap Burger

Yes.

Claudio Geyken

Yes, imbalance mechanism for utilities to basically keep the grids always stable at 50 Hz and also in trades with intraday market, we have a balance that needs to be held in the overall system. And so each participant, both producers and consumers, they have an interest in forecasting or actually are mandated to forecast, forecast their total amount of energy that they will produce or consume in a particular 15 minute slot.

And if they miss this forecast and they caused this imbalance, then they have to pay a fine. And this is quite hefty. I don't know what's the latest and how it actually this fine then translate in 2015 and how it is evolving. But at least there is an incentive as far as I know still today. Right. And it's not. It's really. It's rarely seen as one of the smart charging levers.

It's mostly we discuss other topics like peak shaving, so reducing grid fees or participating in energy markets. Just trading, so to say, in the. Yes, so. So maybe I can elaborate what was happening there and would you. What's your view on imbalancing markets?

Jaap Burger

Right, so it was already one of the, let's call it one of the more advanced energy markets being able to almost in real time adjust that energy balance. And there are multiple time spans, so there are multiple moments where you trade electricity, maybe not as user, but your energy supplier and their balanced responsible party. They forecast basically your energy need and not only yours, but from all their consumers, but also from the producers.

And obviously we also have prosumers that are both. And the more accurate that forecast is, the better they can source energy, the better they can trade. And all of that has a certain value and some of that is not always as visible. So it could be directly in prices, but sometimes it's avoiding fines, as you say, or it could be because it enables you to sell a certain volume that you already bought in advance and sell that at a later time.

So you also have a spread between two prices,.

Claudio Geyken

The so called virtual trades. No. Yeah. So then, so maybe because I never fully engage in the, in the virtual trades. And as you bring it up, is it. So how would it work in practice? Let's say you have a vehicle, you have 10 hours or so flexibility in a day. Then instead of buying the electricity in the beginning, as prices develop in these 10 hour window, you're able to sell again the energy and buy it at a later moment.

Jaap Burger

Yes.

Jaap Burger

Yeah,.

Jaap Burger

Right, right.

Jaap Burger

Because it's a layered market. So there are different time spans where you can buy electricity. So some of these are future for future delivery. You can, you can buy electricity and there are different times. So. So for instance, you could buy electricity for a certain moment in time, in, in a year time from now.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah.

Jaap Burger

And obviously having a controllable asset, which are EVs, their batteries, if you can control the charging, means that you can up to real time decide what you want to do with that, whether it's still the best opportunity to keep and stick with the volume of energy that you already procured, let's say a year ahead or maybe a day ahead, or to sell it to someone else in the energy markets because that would give you a higher price, even knowing that you would need to buy electricity for that vehicle at a later point in time.

So that's another type of flexibility Being flexible in when you actually need electricity to be delivered,.

Claudio Geyken

I'm thinking.

Claudio Geyken

So I understand the example. If you bought significant time ahead, then indeed you can readjust your planning. But why would you as a day ahead, invest the day ahead, buy an expensive price and then in the intraday buy the low price if you can, from the get go in the day ahead, buy the low price.

Jaap Burger

So it's also partly, partly hatching because obviously in the intraday you don't know all the prices in advance. So most energy traders would have some kind of a combined portfolio. Some of that is a really long term volumes that are being bought, but other parts of that you buy at different timescales. And especially with controllable assets, it becomes interesting, especially at the moment when there's a ramp up.

So at the beginning of the evening peak or when the evening peak starts to fall again, there you get interesting effects. Also partly because most of the dynamics on the wholesale energy price and especially the day ahead energy market as the main market where the most volume is being traded is shaped by weather. So solar obviously has a huge impact on prices. But as we all know, weather also has a certain unpredictable element to it.

So even on the shorter term you might see deviations from that forecast. So there might be more sunshine than expected or there might be just a little bit more clouds. Similarly with wind and even on the consumption side, demand might be a little bit different than expected and all of that rewards basically those that are able to in real time.

Claudio Geyken

Adjust their plan of the day ahead and all other aheads. Makes sense. Now we're already deep diving but let's, let's finish off the background first. Well, so you were stuck in this 2015, was this already you participated in the company that was doing this?

Jaap Burger

Yeah,.

Jaap Burger

Yes, so I helped them develop the product and you know, inform the engineering, worked with carmakers to to onboard them onto this platform to work with energy suppliers to integrate this into their EV charging propositions to users. So not just in the Netherlands, but also in other countries, which was really fascinating and interesting to do. And then it became again sort of a moment.

Public-Charging Affordability

Jaap Burger

And I think that that happens with a lot of startups, especially in the corporate space. So sometimes there's a bit of back and forth being within the big corporate and sometimes being a bit outside. And when it had to move back into the large corporate environment, I stepped out. And I think that's also a bit of the freedom that I like being a freelancer, being able to then move on to a new project that gives New energy.

Claudio Geyken

Makes sense.

Jaap Burger

So, yeah, so started doing other things. I also worked with grid operators, helping them to understand what the value of electrification of transport is for their system, how to interact with it, what their role is, what they should do, what they shouldn't do.

Claudio Geyken

So distribution grid operators.

Jaap Burger

Yes.

Jaap Burger

Yep, yep.

Jaap Burger

And yeah.

Jaap Burger

And since then, helping, you know, multiple actors, whether that's private or public, helping to navigate what needs to be done to use the flexibility as beneficially as possible, basically for everyone involved, whether that's the distribution grid or whether that's the national energy balance, or whether it's a user that wants to see his electricity bill reduced, or whether it's a chargement operator looking to make the rollout of charging infrastructure more efficient and how to increase the utilization rate, for instance.

Claudio Geyken

It's fascinating.

Claudio Geyken

You have a very broad background also from and being an operator really, like trying to set up a charging infrastructure for a city to building a startup and doing smart charging very early in the days. And then you need to think very much in the details of an API being an endpoint and then thinking very broad, what does the government need to do, what does the DSO need to do? And so on. So, yeah, it makes the conversation even more interesting.

Now to understanding this, I think broad, unique background. And so let's take this segue from the background really to what your current projects are. If you want to share a little bit what's on your mind and what is top of mind right now for you, and then we can detail a little bit more the use cases and discuss potential barriers and opportunities.

Jaap Burger

Right.

Jaap Burger

And I always sort of having those different perspectives. It's something I try to use to advance certain topics that might not be in the spotlight as much as they should be.

So one of those topics is the affordability of public charging, which is a topic important to policymakers and obviously is important for a future market, but it's not always perceived as a topic for, let's say, some of the CPOs in their current daily business today, whereas it's a topic that also shapes their market. So I try to nudge them to understand how important it is that they work on the topic as well.

Because it shapes the future market, it grows the future market for them if we are able to create a system in which every user can switch to an electric vehicle, because high cost, high cost of public charging specifically can be a barrier for other user groups. So there's also always like these loops and feedback loops.

So some of the high costs of public charging on the cost side so not meaning the high prices charged by chargepoint operators, but the high costs they have on their end. Its cost, soft costs related to permitting, to planning, but also the cost of grid connections, the cost maybe of hardware and the cost maybe of software systems.

All of that are factors that might lead to obviously a higher price they need to ask users, which might lead to lower utilization, which then leads to lower turnover and lower revenues or also lower bankability. So it might also impact the pace at which these CPOs can scale because they can't access the right financing, for instance, on the right conditions. So it's sort of all connected.

So I, yeah, I try to help them understand sort of what are the buttons. Basically they can press, what can they influence and what do they need to ask policymakers and regulators and grid operators maybe to help shape their costs in a way that benefits obviously the cpo, but it also benefits the society because it would lower for instance the cost of grid build out if you would enable more flexible ways to work with the grid.

Flexibility’s Role

Jaap Burger

So that could be in non firm capacity agreements, it could be in flexibility mechanisms through local flexibility markets, or it could be with time varying network tariffs. So all of that sort of helps the business case of a cpo, but also helps potentially the charting price for the user helps bring that down, which then again sort of enables electrification for new user groups. Therefore grows the market.

So it's higher usage, again, more demand in the public charting market. So the public charting market grows, which makes it more interesting for everyone.

Claudio Geyken

Makes sense to me. Yeah. So what's the role of smart charging? Let's call it smart charging or intelligent energy management Flexible maybe let's agree on just calling it flex. Flex is the easiest. What's the role of flex within this question, broad question that you brought up with affordability of CPOs, is it like the top one issue or do you think there's other levers?

Jaap Burger

Yeah,.

Claudio Geyken

So what's the importance and why are CPO is not willing to spend more time enabling that?

Jaap Burger

So I think the complexity, without sounding too much like going into too many paths at once, but it's always a mix of measures. So flex and then flex at so many different levels is really important to bring down costs. And some of these measures might be 10% might reduce 10% of costs, others might be 5% and others might be 20%.

But it's the combination of all of that that ultimately helps shape affordability and helps also shape the business case and viability of some of the public charging network. So flex is important because it enables users in the basis to access the lower cost energy from renewals that we have in abundance at certain times. So that's the big chunk of value that can be accessed.

The other big chunk of value is in avoiding peaks on the grid, which could also be the other side of the coin of that renewables being ingested into the grid. If we have a mechanism that at the same time that we have solar PV production, also have the same amount of consumption as localized as possible, that also helps avoid some of the peaks on the grid. But there's also the link between public charging and private charging.

So also on site energy management is a key lever to bring down costs of electrification. So if you're able to smartly use the capacity you have on a site. So for instance, if you have a depot and a commercial fleet, staying within certain boundaries can save you considerable amount of grid costs. If you're able to consume the electricity that you produce on site, there are related benefits to that that are significant.

Regulatory and Market Barriers

Jaap Burger

So I would say without the flex, electrification is definitely not as affordable as it could be. I think to make electrification work, flex is the thing that reduces friction.

Claudio Geyken

Right, but so it seems like a no brainer then to engage in it. So what's the. When you say you need to convince CPO so you need to work with regulators, so what's the actual topics then that the hurdles to make it.

Jaap Burger

Happen?

Jaap Burger

Well, it's hugely complex. So even I sometimes struggle to fully understand how a certain mechanism works or how regulation works. And there's also a considerable amount of lag between stated policy goals. So there might be policy change, a law change or change to a regulation, but it might not change, enter into force until several years later.

Or it might actually be a change that then requires, as an example, a DSO to come up with a market based mechanism for procuring flexibility for the local grid. And then it might be that this is a requirement that enters into force January 1, 2027, then the DSO, the local grid operator, starts investigating how that could be. Maybe they have a report, internal report, half a year later, maybe they have a consultation round.

Hopefully they have a consultation round with the relevant parties, but sometimes not. They publish something, the regulator looks at it, then it's being set and then the mechanism maybe goes live again a year later. So it might already be 2028 by that time.

But then it turns out that for some of the actual actors in the market, let's stick with the example of a charge point operator or a depot operator, it's a Mechanism that doesn't fit the way they work or the concept of flexibility is a different concept than what they have in mind with flexibility. Or it requires them to make forecasts on a wholly different time scale than they are used to work with.

Claudio Geyken

Right, yeah.

Claudio Geyken

So many questions, so many topics. Right. One thing that comes to mind is probably have engaged a lot with Smarten and then shout out to their good reports where they try to keep also track on all the different levers and the states also by country. Right. That's a tremendous good work. Right? And are there other sources like that just that you use to keep track of this complexity, to simplify, to structure it somehow to.

Jaap Burger

Yes, yes.

Jaap Burger

So it's really complex. So some of the projects I do are doing this kind of analysis. So trying to find out how does this work, what are the market conditions, trying to bring that together because it's really, really hard and even within countries it's really hard. I mean the example of Germany having 800 DSOs, but there are other countries like Sweden, Sweden also has, I don't know, 150 dsos, maybe even more that have different tariff structures.

So there are and I think that that's a good thing. Again we started this conversation about how there are these niche roles. So companies fulfilling a niche role that are really valuable. So one niche role is for instance being able to provide accurate descriptions of the network tariff in a certain region.

So as a CPO you want to deploy chargers, but how do you know what differences are in the network tariff structure if you have 800 DSOs in Germany? Right. So there are players that are able to help them get that information into their system. And for instance that could, could help shape an investment decision or could help shape the way they configure energy management on a certain site.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah.

Claudio Geyken

Right?

Claudio Geyken

Yeah, no, that's, that's the DSOs. And as we're at it, maybe can you elaborate on the value pools that you think Flex enables both for fleets or CPOs to capture and where you see the largest potential? Maybe so we can deep dive a little bit more on where there is potential instead of losing track. Maybe side topics that will not be so relevant in your view?

EV Flexibility in the Energy System

Jaap Burger

Yeah, so I think the main lever ultimately is being able to move with generation. So we obviously the broader topic of the energy transition is a transition from a system where generation followed demand. So we move away from thermal power plants that are controllable but then are basically demand following. We move to energy sources that are predictable but have a time varying profile. Mostly Shaped by the weather, as I said before.

So we need demand to be following that supply. If you're able to follow that supply, that's where you get to the low cost, the low cost of electrification, the low cost of decarbonation, decarbonization. So being able to follow that is I think ultimately the biggest lever you have. But there's the big but there's the grid. The capacity on the grid is not unlimited.

The capacity at different levels of the grid, especially sort of at the grid connection point where you would connect your, your charger, connect your depot is not unlimited. There's also different value over time. So some of that over time it might be still needed to expand the grid so you can access more of that renewable electricity being transferred across Europe.

Ultimately the whole of Europe would benefit if we have a better build out of across continent. If Spain could be using some of the wind from Denmark, for instance, the interconnectors. So ultimately obviously there's a lot to be done there. But before we reach to the point where we have the interconnectors, we need or on a specific site to have the capacity you might need.

Peak Shaving and Peak Quality

Jaap Burger

There's also the shorter term needs to stay within capacity limits and to be able to adjust the profile. So it's stacking maybe that energy market with local grid connections, local grid conditions, and then so it becomes a multi input optimization already,.

Claudio Geyken

Right?

Claudio Geyken

Yeah, the multi criteria optimization that we think a lot about too. And one thing that I'd love to have your view upon that I find is not so much understood yet in the wider community is everybody talks about peak shaving or managing peaks. But I think what lies under the hood of the peak is not fully understood and especially interesting if you think about it.

There's peak shaving which basically tries to create a base load, and then there's flex, which is trying to create peaks and where you try to actually move to a time window which is favorable in terms of costs or in terms of congested grids.

So how do you think about this apparent contradiction and how fast are we gonna, how are we gonna manage this in the short term and are we gonna finally move away from this rigid grid fee structure which incentivizes peak shaving a lot? As far as I understand is one of the largest, largest cost right now is just this kilowatt peak that is randomly just taking for a year without considering intelligent way the congested amount of the area.

Jaap Burger

Yeah, yeah.

Jaap Burger

And I think that that that's still one of the key challenges and of the phase we're currently in so many understand that not every peak has the same impact. So peaks can be at different times. And sometimes a charging peak demand peak can actually be very beneficial for the grid if it coincides with a supply peak. As I said, for instance, if you have on the same network portion, you might.

Claudio Geyken

Have.

Claudio Geyken

So let's just stick with them more because I find it so well put, as you say, like people are so proudly peak shaving when exactly there's peaks of different. We should talk much more about the quality of the peak. And there's a range of peaks and sometimes there's good to peak shave, but sometimes you just did the stupid thing of peak shaving. You should have created the peak, right?

Jaap Burger

Yes, yes.

Jaap Burger

And I think that's also the struggle we're in because some of the earlier network tariffs or demand charges within a network tariff, they actually have the opposite effect of what they tried to achieve. So it might flatten the peak now, but then you would have a secondary peak at a later time. That actually might be a new problem or a bigger problem. And I think the ones shaping those tariffs, DSOs and regulators still need to see more evidence.

And I think that's maybe also a call from my side many of the market actors that actually are already shaping that flexibility today to show and tell them and demonstrate how unlocking the flexibility of EV charging, to stick to that topic, can really be beneficial for the grid in managing the type of peaks and delivering that quality of peaks that.

Claudio Geyken

Yesterday actually just a brilliant. Now that you bring it up, I need to tell it. I was talking with commissioners from California Energy commissioners, and I was sharing the example. I'm a kind of a podcast geek, as you probably guess. So I watched the Lex Friedman interview with Jensen Huang and one thing that really struck me was that for three hours they talked about all things AI that you can imagine.

You're probably also following the AI development a lot. And then Lex Friedman asked a lot of questions. And then eventually he asked like Jensen, is there anything I should have asked you? And he was like, yes, we should have discussed. There's this one thing that is on top of my mind right now is how do we manage peaks at data centers? And I was like, oh. And then he was really talking about what we were just discussing.

This is one of the most critical things for AI development is how energy is being tariffed right now and how data centers can be approved depending on the peaks that they are designed for. Right. And then we have flexibility in the way we manage AI loads. So I find it quite, I found it quite clear. This is exactly what I'm working on all the time. Yeah, so we need to really. So you, you, you. This is a call maybe for all the listeners as well.

Jaap Burger

Yeah, so.

Claudio Geyken

So what, what is the call exactly? We need to talk to DSOs, we need to, to talk to regulators, to Bundesnet Federal Network Agency, more to the association or what is the call section?

Jaap Burger

Yes, yes, no, exactly that show and demonstrate what you're able to do, how much you are able to shift the volume but also the shape of the charting amount that you're able to be able to fold and mold into something that works for the grid. And I think that needs quantity. So it has to be quantified in volumes but also in the terms of quality.

How can you, what time spans are available, how can you deliver even long term, how can you avoid long term grid investment but also on the short term how can you help balance on a really local level? And I think DSOs need to see more of it and be able to rely on it as a reliable resource.

Dutch Grid Congestion

Jaap Burger

And I think some of us, you mentioned Smarten for instance doing a great job in Brussels pointing that out and quantifying that and showing to politics policymakers at the European level.

Yes, flexibility is a resource the whole flexibility industry can deliver and this is what, what it can deliver for improvement and for the energy system in terms of savings in avoided grid cost or in being able to access more of that lower cost generation that we have on the system.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah.

Claudio Geyken

And still it's difficult to deliver proof points on how it supports the grid if the grid structure is just old fashioned and is not yet adapted to the new system.

Jaap Burger

Right, you're right.

Claudio Geyken

I mean there's like. But maybe you can give examples of the Netherlands as the Netherlands is always a country that is on the one hand quite innovative and also leading in what we're discussing and secondly also particularly affected. Just and shout out to Leonard Farahayan who is also very good expert in this topic. He shared yesterday in the ICNC how the card of the Netherlands was.

The map of the Netherlands was just turning red in terms of being fully congested right now. So maybe can you discuss a bit ways that the Netherlands is trying to tackle this topic?

Jaap Burger

Yeah, yeah.

Jaap Burger

So I think what's happening in the Netherlands is really fascinating because you see some of those different approaches. So yes, there is a map of the Netherlands that is fully red to. To get new grid connections and red means that's probably not possible this location to get a fixed capacity allocated. But obviously why do you need 24, 7, 365 days a year the same capacity on a grid connection point?

So if you're able to be flexible, and obviously that's something that we discussed, if you have EVs, you probably are flexible. There are ways around that you don't need. You might not need capacity at all during the evening peak in winter times, for instance. So being more granular in data is something that is really needed, which at the moment is still a bit missing. So you see a map which basically is binary.

It's yes, it's possible or no, it's not possible. There are so many nuances in between. So what if you would have a different demand profile? There might be more options. So that's something that is. There's also. European policymakers actually are trying to explain to national lawmakers. We need a system where this granular grid information is being made available. So having granular visibility. So that means location and time and grid levels.

How congested a grid is or how much capacity is available can help developers from find the locations or find the solutions that they need to work with. Which could also include stationary batteries, maybe to overcome problem, but it could also mean implementing a certain demand profile for charging. So that's one element. The other element is how good is the mechanism to incentivize flexible users for. For those that are already on the grid and.

Claudio Geyken

The operational map.

Jaap Burger

Right.

Jaap Burger

Because this map is only talking about who is waiting in line to get access to the. But the big chunk obviously are those that are already on the grid, mainly so that have already maybe entered that. Yeah. So maybe call it like the scooter ride at a, at a fair. So there are people waiting in line to get in. They can't. And some of them are driving around already there. You need to also work with them to overcome some of those. Yeah.

Claudio Geyken

Grid.

Claudio Geyken

System.

Claudio Geyken

Traffic jams.

Jaap Burger

And there it's about how accessible are the mechanisms that are put in place by DSOs for those that actually deliver that flexibility.

And I've seen youth developments, especially of the past years and months, from something that wasn't available to a flexibility mechanism that mainly targeted really large commercial industrial users, to something that now is arriving at a point where distributed flexibility, so from single EVs being delivered by also by mobility service providers and by aggregators, is something that is enabled to deliver flexibility to the grid.

Claudio Geyken

So this is just to be clear, is it working at scale right now in the Netherlands already?

Jaap Burger

Yes.

Jaap Burger

And it's moving also to a new phase this autumn where there is a new market mechanism specifically allowing distributed energy resources, distributed flexibility connected at the low voltage level, to participate in the flexibility market as well.

Claudio Geyken

Well, so if I'm an EV driver in the Netherlands and I plug in my charger either at home or in a public charger, then I can participate in the congestion management of the dso. And you have a reduced fee at. Yes,.

Jaap Burger

Right?

Jaap Burger

Yes.

Jaap Burger

There are companies that are able to provide you that access and deliver that to you as a driver, but also deliver that flexibility to the grid.

Claudio Geyken

Okay, well that's already good for other countries to take as inspiration. And what did it take for the Netherlands to be able to do that? What were the hurdles that, let's say other countries are facing that the Netherlands managed to surpass already?

Jaap Burger

So I would say also some, some of the, these innovators in the market demonstrating the technical possibilities, but also demonstrating the value of the fleet that they could already tap into that flexibility that they, they could unlock. So some of those early, early players like a shout out to Devpower with some of their customers at Devpower, we.

Claudio Geyken

Had them on the podcast already with Michael Johannes.

Jaap Burger

Yeah.

Jaap Burger

And so they've been really hard in working at scale, demonstrating at scale how this mechanism could work. And by demonstrating that, they basically also convinced the grid operators, yes, this is a mechanism that can really contribute to, to their goals and needs. So I think that that's also a great example of by again showing and telling what you can do and that you also can create a market for yourself.

Well, not just for you, but for everyone in the market.

Claudio Geyken

But that requires, for example, let's take the example of dev power, also CPOs to be willing. So not dev power cannot do it by themselves. They had to be able to demonstrate in the first place, also find willing CPOs and probably also willing DSOs. So it took several stakeholders to do the demonstration. Right,.

Jaap Burger

Right.

Jaap Burger

And sometimes it takes time for them to understand what are the benefits for them. And I think it's slowly emerging, this understanding. Also with CPOs, there is value in flexibility that they alone cannot access because they do not have the direct access, for instance, to the driver. We're in a system where obviously we want to be interoperable, we want to have roaming.

So you want to provide access to every EV driver, but do you really want to interact with every EV driver's needs or driver? Can there be a layer in between that can simplify that communication? So I think it becomes increasingly clear how collaboration also brings a lot of benefits to the whole value chain.

CPO, MSP, and Supply Roles

Claudio Geyken

Yeah, definitely 100% that we need more collaboration at all levels to enable these things. Otherwise the value can also be stuck if one player doesn't play. Play around, play along. Right.

Jaap Burger

And maybe which also is another topic I had several conversations on, which is the sometimes highly controversial dirt lightings model in Germany, the pass through or transit model where the charge point operator is doing the charge point operation, but not necessarily being the one responsible for the energy supply supply, especially not for the balancing of that energy supply.

Claudio Geyken

Right, the German pass through model.

Jaap Burger

Yeah.

Jaap Burger

And I think one of the interesting benefits ultimately also for CPOs there is that it can offload some of those more complex responsibilities from their end, helping them to create a more viable business case, more investable, bankable business case for chargement operations on the energy side, the demand profile and being able to forecast energy needs. Ultimately also maybe shaping that charging demand with smart charging.

Maybe in the future also maybe even bi directional charging within a fleet, an aggregated fleet becomes a task then of maybe the MSP or much more closer to the actual vehicle, which ultimately brings the benefit that you have a much higher predictability and a much more accurate profile setting, much less imbalance. So it helps the cpo, it helps the consumer and ultimately it helps the system.

But it's still complex and it's still something that again needs that show the demonstration for everyone to understand how those benefits would play out.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah, it's a complicated topic and I think few people shout out to Knut and our friends here of decarbonized that are being spearheading. I think this idea can explain it and I think it requires still some education. Maybe we can just elaborate a bit on that. So the problem as the setup is today and I'm breaking it down so that you can then just share more.

So the CPOs are the ones procuring the electricity and selling the electricity then to the MSPs who are on their end again selling a certain electricity to the drivers. And what you're suggesting is that the electricity that is procured by the CPO is completely and sold into the msp. That part goes away and it's completely then the responsibility of the msp. Right so far. Right.

And then the problem with CPO being in charge of as the current model for Flex is that they might not be able to influence as much as the MSP the driver. So and forecast and both demand and then adjust the balancing. Am I getting that right?

Jaap Burger

Right.

Jaap Burger

Especially not because they can mostly only influence it once the session has started. But I think part of it is even more interesting knowing in advance the charging need, the volume, maybe nudging the driver to use a certain location.

Pricing Transparency and MSP Evolution

Jaap Burger

So there are many, many more steps and many more data points ahead of actually plugging into a charging station in the current setup typically for CPO it only starts as soon as someone plugs in and you could do energy management and that's still useful.

But there's also this more advanced layer of knowing in advance which then links to the topic of energy trading and forecasting that we touched upon, which requires much richer information on that specific driver.

Claudio Geyken

Well to play the advocates demo it's been. Anyways, a question I wanted to ask you is there's a bit of an open question on how the development of the MSP role also would be. So we had actually last episode we had Karika Esam here, the founder who enables CPOs to broadcast prices and set the prices and thereby sort of circumventing the msp. And also there is direct payment mandates I think by off year so you don't really need to pay via your MSP app.

Couldn't it also be done in the exact flip side where you see much more responsibility at the cpo and how do you look at that?

Jaap Burger

Well we need both And I think CPOs should be able to broadcast their prices to MSP. So especially coming from the Netherlands I sometimes struggle to understand why that doesn't work. Because in the Netherlands it's much more commonplace place that CPOs have price endpoints so we can dive into the technical details of that but they publish their terrorism prices to MSPs and it can be done in real time.

In the German market it seems sometimes something from, I don't know, utopia to have a system like that in place. So.

Claudio Geyken

Netherlands are utopia for Germany in many ways.

Jaap Burger

In many ways. But it's sort of. It sometimes feels pricing is being treated as something that is being. Well we could use the stereotype of I don't know, it's something that you would sign and lock at the notary and then goes into a vault and then stays fixed but also secretive between the CPO and MSPS for years. I think that doesn't fit today's market and today's need. So yes, we need mechanisms in place.

Also roaming hubs, roaming protocols that are actually able to have real time pricing and also forecasted pricing and historic pricing. So really should expand that from CPOs to MSPs. So yes, that's something we need. Then on the MSP side they need to be able to process that price information. Because also I see a limitation in the market that some players aren't able to process different prices.

They aren't able to process for instance two prices within the same charging network from the cpo. They can only use a single price per cpo.

Claudio Geyken

Like because of software limitation.

Jaap Burger

Right, it's a software limitation. And I'm always, you know, more optimistic maybe of what software can achieve. And then maybe others think, well, in practice it's more and more complex and I think it's. They probably are right at some point. But I do think being able to process different prices, different times, different locations should be.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah, I know as a software producer I think I can can clearly have a statement in the age of AI that shouldn't be a big issue,.

Jaap Burger

It shouldn't be a big piece. So to answer the question, I think that needs to be solved anyhow. And yes, ad hoc pricing, and that's also the European alternative infrastructure regulation already today requires non discriminatory pricing. So not discriminating between different users or between different payment methods.

And that has grown into an issue again, notably in Germany where some of those players have such a huge price difference between what they charge users based on their own app based payment system and those that are either paying ad hoc or use a roaming partner. Anything that shouldn't be there in place. Ultimately I think it's the market that needs to get its act together and sort it out.

And maybe a little bit of legal action here and there might help shape that. And probably also a little bit of policy regulator clarifying maybe some of that, but might be diffuse in the current regulation. So that's one part, but then the second part even there I think sort of like the MSP needs to evolve into a much more stacked services provider.

So not just delivering the invoice at the end of the month, but also providing that added value of telling you when is the best time to charge, what is the best location to charge, how can we help you with route planning? How can we help you access the best prices by nudging them. And that's also what obviously devpwr has been shaping.

Once you're at the charting station, especially those with, with longer parking durations, can we shift some of that charging demand out of the peaks and to the valleys?

Claudio Geyken

Right, yeah, very interesting. And just to stick one moment with the flex example you just gave, is it just DSOs that are influencing then how flex is enabled in these examples in the Netherlands or also intraday prices.

Jaap Burger

Combined?

Jaap Burger

Yes, also intraday and they had prices combined, so it's stacking those. And again, you need a system that is capable of optimizing for multiple inputs that sometimes obviously have conflicting goals and prices. And there again, it helps if you can scale and have an aggregated fleet of users.

Driver Savings and V2G

Jaap Burger

So your charging profile and your charging needs might be different than mine, but having both of us combined into one balancing area can deliver those benefits.

Claudio Geyken

Got it.

Claudio Geyken

And how much. So you drive an ev, right? Yes. So how much money can you save as an EV driver in the Netherlands today if you go to an AC charger for like a night or. I don't know how it works if you can do it daily on specific moments only.

Jaap Burger

Yes.

Jaap Burger

So I happen to use one of Devpower's smart charging solution on the public charging station in my street and it cuts my charging bill. So let's say from the €20 I would pay for the charge I need, it gives me maybe €2 benefits,. Which is really nice to have. So it's not like it turns into something that is then free because there's obviously still cost, but it's significant and especially if you look at it for a full year.

Claudio Geyken

10%,.

Claudio Geyken

Also the beginning. And that was also a good segue to. To V2G or bi directional charging, which makes the whole thing even more complicated, but. Right. But also more interesting. And.

Jaap Burger

The holy grail.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah.

Claudio Geyken

Is there probably you need to retrofit. So that's the one key challenge always. Let's tackle that one first. So the tech challenges, I guess you need to retrofit the chargers if you wanted to do V2G at your home, the same charger you're doing. Yeah, yeah. And then. So that's one key challenge with the retrofitting. And is there even a plan already in the Netherlands, as you're always thinking ahead of doing such a thing or.

Jaap Burger

Well, there is a plan and I would say there were already sort of requirements on certain charting stations, certain tenders to be capable of bidirectional charting, but actually too early. So I would say that's a stranded investment because if you see how the technical standard has evolved so the basis was ISO 15118 20. Well now there's an amendment, one that more clearly defines how AC bidirectional charging would work.

Also under development are European grid codes that show shape the responsibilities between the car, the inverter in the car and the charging station. So if you look at it, some of that was maybe too early because we first need to get to a deployment first deployment And a first market for bi directional charging before we can actually mandate it and scale that the functionality.

Also I do think it's sometimes the prospect of V2G and bi directional charging sometimes obscures the immediate and much larger opportunity we already have with unidirectional smart charging.

Claudio Geyken

Totally.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah.

Claudio Geyken

So you think that there's still so much to be done in the one direction so the we shouldn't think too much ahead of bi directional.

Fleets and Bidirectional Charging

Jaap Burger

It's both because we still need to work on bi directional charting and there are still many hurdles that need to be tackled. Some of that related especially to how to access markets, how to access the value, how to make sure that grid operators can actually utilize that flexibility. Flexibility and rewarded flexibility that contributes to the viability of a V2G business game.

Claudio Geyken

But so how do you then look at this, Utrecht? I think it's one of the world's most advanced also projects in the sense of V2G at scale supposedly. Have you ever also been beneficiary of that or what's the constraint or how to they make it work already today,.

Jaap Burger

Right?

Jaap Burger

Well, they make it work with this car sharing fleet. So it's a captive fleet, which is great because I think that helps makes it much less complex as well.

Claudio Geyken

One type of oem,.

Jaap Burger

It's one type of carmaker. But also there's basically a single operator of that fleet. So from there system you can pull all the data when different vehicles are being needed. So you have a single source of information. It becomes obviously much more complex if you would include private cars. Right. So it's not working for private cars. It works with a captive fleet and there is working and I think that that's also where it's already interesting to do.

Also households again you have the single car, single house, single charger. I think that those are the first use cases for bi directional charging where already today, 2026, 2027, we will see the action and we'll see the benefits.

Claudio Geyken

That's very cool. So they have one make of vehicles and one make of chargers that has all the aforementioned grid codes and and standards that are required. And I guess the DSO also or the utility on site one, there's one player.

Jaap Burger

Later on.

Jaap Burger

Right.

Jaap Burger

So the DSO created for them also this access to a flexibility mechanism. So they are able to trade basically that volume and be rewarded for that flexibility that they have in then moving loads or moving basically discharging to peak times.

Claudio Geyken

Just the same DSO and intraday combination that we discussed earlier, right? Yeah. It's A very interesting example. I mean Utrecht, you need to go there eventually. Also the bike, the largest bike parking of the world, I think.

Jaap Burger

Yeah, yeah,.

Jaap Burger

Right.

Jaap Burger

I mean if people cycle, their car has even more flexibility. If you do your. If you don't need your car, leave.

Claudio Geyken

The car.

Claudio Geyken

Just parked all the time. Use it as a battery storage eventually. Yeah. So next, just one more question on geography. Next to the Netherlands, which country do you see is actually really leading in flex and EV in particular?

Jaap Burger

Well, Denmark is fascinating. How many of the EV charging ecosystem is delivering services to the grid, to the tso? Actually.

Claudio Geyken

We have never talked about the TSO so far.

Jaap Burger

Right.

Jaap Burger

So I find it fascinating how so many of the EVs that are being charged in Denmark, whether that's workplace or residential or even public, are being aggregated and that volume is being used to deliver some of those real time.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah, very cool. Denmark was also very early in doing those type of things as far as I remember. And maybe, I mean there are so many more topics, but I think we will have to do other episodes at this point. So just to keep the, the episode at some length. Just. Are there any. Next to the topic we discussed in the beginning were affordability and CPO pricing.

Jaap Burger

Right.

Claudio Geyken

The interesting topics that you are thinking also for fleets and private charging that you think are worth highlighting, that you are also particularly find exciting that fleets should look into.

Jaap Burger

Right.

Jaap Burger

So I think that two things come to mind. So for fleets, the whole topic of energy management, of grid capacity, of the various energy markets that we discussed, it's something they probably will have never heard of or never interacted of.

So there's a huge gap, not necessarily that they need to become energy experts, but there is a strong need for market roles in helping fleets navigate that space or not only navigate, but actually become an active participant in. So that's I think a market role which is really important. So being the bridge between. Yeah,. Between that complexity and we touched upon a bit the surface of that complexity, but it's even more complex.

Collaborative E-Mobility Ecosystem

Claudio Geyken

Later.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah.

Jaap Burger

But also on the logistics side, I'm not an expert of fleet disposition or sort of route planning, etc. That's another type of complexity where you also see obviously a need for solutions and bringing that together. Is, is what we need and with what we need, I, I mean as a society, because it's, it's just being able to tap into that, that flexibility potential is really bringing down costs for a fleet operator.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah.

Jaap Burger

It's really delivering that TCO improvement promise of electrification. It is enabled by electrification and by Enabling flexibility, but it also brings some costs for everyone in the energy system. Not even talking about all obviously the environmental and health benefits of electrification and if we get rid of diesel. But really being able to use flexibility is something that benefits people, both a fleet operator as well as the society,.

Claudio Geyken

The wider society. So you have. In other words, it's a call to action. Hey, fleet operators, don't worry. Even if we hinted on topics, many topics that sounded too complicated, there are people like us, by the way, that are simplifying stuff for you and there's big potential for you, but also for sustainability if you really dare to now engage in these type of topics. Right,.

Jaap Burger

Right.

Jaap Burger

And I would also say for all the market actors in the E mobility space, also, again highlighting where you started with the quote, they need to define what they want to do themselves or how to enable a connection to others that can deliver that value. Because I think that much of that value can also be delivered, delivered through collaboration.

So we need to get to a much more collaborative system, a system that is able to communicate well and where I mean communicate is more on both on a technical level, but also commercial level.

So we need sort of be able to connect several building blocks and some of those market roles or market players, they need to consider whether they want to do it all themselves, which can have certain benefits, or where they would need specialized players to deliver that.

Claudio Geyken

All right with that, I think also on this collaborative call to action, we are also very much the same believers in collaboration at all levels, tech and business. I just say thank you. Yep. And hopefully let's do more again. Jaap made a point about peaks that deserve much more attention and nuance. Not every peak is equally bad. A charging peak that lines up with a solar peak can actually help the grid.

Jaap Burger

Right.

Claudio Geyken

And some of the early demand charges inside network tariffs simply flatten one peak and create a second bigger one later. His call to the industry is to show and tell, quantify how much volume you can shift and how well you can shape it. Because grid operators need evidence before they treat flexibility as a resource they can rely on. I also liked how tangible the benefit already is.

Jaap uses a smart charging service on the public charger in his own street and it takes around €2 of a €20 charge, small per session, real over a year on vehicle to grid. He was refreshingly sober. It works today in captive fleets like in Utrecht, with one car maker and operator, one source of data.

It does not fully work for private cars yet, and the excitement around it can obscure much bigger prices like we have with one directional smart charging. So if you take one thing from the episode, go and demonstrate what Geoflex can actually do in numbers. Thanks for listening, Sa.

S2 Ep. 9 · Jaap Burger

0:00 / 1:24:39