Skip to content

Smart Charge by RiDERgy · Episode 6

smart charging enthusiast from Deftpower, energy transition, EV stakeholders, smart charging, projects, outlooks

Michael Johanns

13 March 2025 · 1 hr 43 min · English · Host: Claudio Geyken

Chapters (13)

Show notes

Michael Johanns brings a long experience in the energy transition and E-Mobility world. Now, he’s responsible for smart charging at a leading E-Mobility startup called Deftpower.

Key discussions focused on his background, the energy and mobility transition, smart charging innovations, market dynamics, and fraud prevention within the electric vehicle sector.

The session began with an in-depth conversation with Michael regarding smart charging, offering insights from a leading OEM on the industry's operational landscape. We analyzed the charging market's complexity, discussed key players like CPOs and MSPs, and examined the potential of bi-directional charging across different regions.

Concerns surrounding fraud were addressed, highlighting prevalent tactics and prevention strategies in an industry characterized by a constant 'cat and mouse game.'

The meeting concluded with an optimistic outlook, emphasizing the positive impact of reduced pollution on climate change and the ongoing transition toward more affordable mobility solutions, reinforcing that significant advancements are still anticipated.

Cite this episode

Geyken, C. (host), Johanns, M. (guest). "smart charging enthusiast from Deftpower, energy transition, EV stakeholders, smart charging, projects, outlooks." Smart Charge by RiDERgy, Episode 6, 13 March 2025. www.ridergy.com/podcast/ep-6-michael-johanns-smart-charging-enthusiast-from-deftpower-energy-transition-

Transcript

16,866 words · machine transcript

  • Claudio Geyken, host
  • Michael Johanns, guest

Cleaned up from a machine transcript. Translations are machine-generated and may contain errors.

Michael Johanns’ background

Claudio Geyken

Welcome to the Smart Charge by ridergy.com podcast. This is Claudio Gaikin, founder and CEO of ridergy.com. This is your show to learn about all things energy management and smart charging, innovation for electric vehicles and fleets. So hey Michael, how are you today? Nice that you're here.

Michael Johanns

Hey Claudio, thanks for the invitation. Yeah, I'm doing quite well here in Berlin. Nice weather, blue sky, finally the summer is coming back. So it's always for me, yeah, the moment where my joy also gets up.

Claudio Geyken

Cool.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah.

Claudio Geyken

And before we dive into more specific topics, maybe you can introduce yourself to the listeners. What's your background? You can go far as you wish, what you think is relevant and then to where you are today and what you're up to today.

Michael Johanns

Yeah, perfect.

Michael Johanns

Please stop me. Interrupt me when it's too long. So Michel Johans originally I'm a German speaking Belgian. I always say this because it's quite one of. Few. Yeah, one of the few. We are only 77,000 and it quite defines a lot where I come from. So really from the Belgium Eifel from a little village, but still you have more borders and surface. So everywhere you have like different languages, different cultures around.

Claudio Geyken

The.

Michael Johanns

So Belgium speaking the French speakers, the Luxembourgish, the Germans. So it's quite interesting region and therefore in my heart, yeah, a deep European, let's say. Yeah, exactly. So I studied in French, I studied in Liege in Belgium, engineer, finished my master in energy management, worked then a few years what is now total energy. What was back then Lampiris, one of the first bigger energy suppliers in Belgium.

Claudio Geyken

Same.

Michael Johanns

After the liberalization we're number three on the market where I worked a lot with portfolio management, pricing forecasts. So got really this 15 minutes rhythm in my blood because I had nothing to do with energy markets before I was all wanted always to work in renewables and energy transition. But it was completely new for me to get it from a market side of.

Claudio Geyken

Which year was that more or.

Michael Johanns

Less?

Michael Johanns

That was in 2015. And yeah, since then it's 10 years ago. There were quite some years, quite some company hopping as well. I was perhaps not the most loyal person.

So I went from there, I came to Berlin, I did an MBA at the TU Energy Management Focus as well, met my wife, stayed in Berlin, worked a year at Elia 50 Hz in the system of the future team where we really thought or it was like a think tank where we were thinking about the big changes and how they influenced the business of tso. I went in the COVID times to a smaller startup, Auxilar and worked there in solar solar business for apartment buildings.

So complete change again. But.

Claudio Geyken

From the tso, the so called grid autobahn to the very much local apartment buildings.

Michael Johanns

Yes, it was really apartment buildings. Really we were thinking of a scalable solution of putting kind of balconsolar but on the roofs and split it into the apartments. So really about a handful of watts instead of gigawatts at the tso. And yeah, then I went to Ellie Volkswagen Group charging was there for the last or was not the last but was there as well a bit over two years in the strategy department.

Everything around bi directional charging, smart charging, vehicle grid integration and yeah met the founder of Devpower and was immediately convinced that this is where I want to work and is the topics where I want to work on.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah, very cool. Yeah. Before we dive dive deeper into these type of topics that you're working on. Maybe just staying a little bit in the. In the past. So what are your key takeaways from the jobs that you had? Things that you key learnings that you are still proud and satisfied of having made in these different positions that you had?

Michael Johanns

Oh, that's a good question. So for my personal side I really realized over the years that I'm not a project manager, that I don't like local small solutions but that I really want to work on scalable bigger solutions. Like they're really scalable throughout countries, throughout markets and even globally.

Scaling the energy transition

Michael Johanns

And yeah, most of the times is only possible with software where you still have the user contact but which is fully scalable and me not at all coming from the IT that was really over the years one of the biggest learnings that I want to work in the software area and that this is exactly how I think how I saw as well at all of the companies where the barriers were between my growth minds like growth mindset is wrong to say my mindset of creating growing scalable exponential business and the limitations when you are doing project management, which is you need more people for more projects and you can only it has a limit to really scale this exponentially.

And the other learning is, I mean I said earlier I'm a pure European and this comes here as well. I have seen many different markets, energy markets with different regulations and there I've seen as well and especially in Germany with the landscape of 900 grid operators, little kingdoms, little politicians locally that have to be power of limiting scalability.

That this is on the opposite side of what I see what we need to have solutions throughout Europe that scale into the millions. Because what we need in the energy business in all of its kinds, but especially in mobility is really low unit costs because. And high scalability. And this doesn't work if you need to fill in some PDFs of a local grid operator that is only working in a tiny city.

You need to have regulation, you need to have possibilities to scale your solution throughout all of the markets immediately.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah, no, it definitely resonates with me as well as I'm convinced as well that software is going to play such a crucial role. And most energy experts, I think, haven't, and energy industry professionals haven't really still grasped the complexity that lies in this distribution of energy as we have never experienced it before. The advance of renewables and all these EVs as we will definitely touch up on.

Michael Johanns

Yeah, I mean, the energy transition until now it had its hurdles, but from a principle it was quite easy. Because the first 30% of decarbonization, you put windmills in the existing system, you put solar panels in the existing system, and the system itself can accommodate them more or less in some countries, in some regions a bit better than in others, but it works.

And now we are entering, or we are actually in the second phase where data is all, where the forecasting is more important, where the distribution or even the consumption becomes more important. Because now we decarbonize heating and mobility and that means that, yeah, they should say, should use the energy that comes from the wind and the sun and not when somebody comes home and plugs in the car into the wall.

And this is a complete new mindset of how you. How you need to gather information, how you need to have interoperability. And this is not compatible with distributed systems where we send text files on servers from the 1970s, how the market communication in Germany is working, that just is not compatible. So we need to go into rest APIs.

We need to have centralized servers that gathered information in real time, that makes them accessible throughout the landscape to multiple parties. And we cannot have this old system of, okay, I have here a little Stadtwerk that sends send the text file once a day or only once a week, and then somebody reads the text file and then process it. That's just not scalable enough for what we need for the second phase of the decarbonization.

Claudio Geyken

Cool.

Claudio Geyken

And before we move into the specifics now of dev power and smart charging, maybe you said your last role was at LE. It's been like one of the leading OEMs trying to. Traditional OEMs trying to take on a big role in the energy scene. How do you see OEMs, vehicle OEMs in the future having a role in energy management and the energy transition as an energy player? We've seen also quite a few announcements in the last few days.

I think the likes of Renault, etc. That try to also take a role in that. What's Your view on OEMs?

Vehicle OEMs and software partnerships

Michael Johanns

Yeah, my views changed quite a lot in a lot of pilot projects. Everybody said oh, we need absolutely an OEM here and in the business as well. I see it a bit differently than a few years ago. I really thought that OEMs have to customer touch point and have this momentum by selling an EV to also get the whole ecosystem around it.

And I don't say that it's impossible, but reality has shown that OEMs don't own the customer and they don't have a touch point with the customer because cars get sold through and Tesla is a bit the exception. But the rest of the OEMs have dealerships, importers. There are often three people, three companies in between the production and the last sales. And this is something that makes it super complex. And also they all work really worldwide.

And energy business is often a local business or at least a continental business. And that makes it for them super hard. And on top it is a software business. And we have seen what the German OEMs, but also in general the European OEMs are capable of doing in software it's not that much, it's just there, it's too expensive. Their innovation cycles are not built for this.

And what I rather see at the moment is the opposite that the OEMs are really focusing back on what they are good in. It's making a four years development cycle and bringing in a new platform and producing it in mass, bringing the costs down and selling hardware in software it's just the opposite. In software you need to iterate often you need to test, you need to. You cannot make seven years plannings for software.

So the whole logics also how the management in these companies work. They're just not the right people at the right places and they are so hierarchical and not able to make distributed solutions like decisions because nobody's trained to make decision or allowed even to make decisions. That makes it then of course super hard to adapt the solution to local market. And I see still the strengths of OEMs is huge because they have this big branding.

But I see it rather in corporations using partners that do software as a service, like Devpower, but also like a lot of other companies on the market and Finding per market, per continent, a really fitting solution and trying then having for example, I come later to it, a good msp, a good charging app, where you have the app that you have under control, where you perhaps buy some snippets or some, some parts of it, but the rest you control at least the design and the user journey.

And then with a good API structure, you partner in local markets with whoever you want. I mean Volkswagen could go to every utility in the world and say, hey, I want to partner with you. I feel a great forecasting algorithm. I have Flex. Can we not do something together? You have the customers, I have the date of the car together. And again, it's a numbers game. I can do this for some cents, I want some Euros. There's a nice business case.

MSPs, CPOs and Deftpower

Michael Johanns

But don't try to get the customers in own energy contracts, in own hardware installation and so on because just the people inside the organizations are not trained to be that fast in wage but also are too expensive on the numbers and what other startups, other companies can do.

Claudio Geyken

Okay, very, very interesting insight. And then as a segue then, yeah, so what draw you to Devpower and Jacob the founder? What was so compelling that you decided then to switch?

Michael Johanns

So I've always in Ellie in Volkswagen already before the reason why I joined Ellie in Volkswagen was really this. Okay, you have this first touch more custom, first customer touchpoint, which is often the MSP business, which is the public charging. Everybody that buys an EV has range anxiety and wants to know where he can charge and how much he pays for it.

So the MSP business is a really crucial provider of this security, that you know where the charger are, that you navigate to them, that you know how much you will pay and that you're sure that you have a contact person to complain or to call when you have a problem somewhere on the street. And the charger doesn't work,.

Claudio Geyken

Which occurs sometimes,.

Michael Johanns

Which occurs less and less, but still which can occur. And then if you have a strong app and you see there, okay, this charger doesn't work. But 100 meters further I have another charger. And your MSP has a good CPO rating engine where you know beforehand already it's only two stars. So you, you're a risk at first person. You go only to the four or five stars where you are 100% sure they will work.

And so therefore, already years ago, Ellie and DCS and others in the market, this MSP business was really crucial for the liftoff of E Mobility. Because even if you have a garage And a home charger from time to time you need to charge on the way and this gives you the security. And by having the security and this app and you like, it can be the OEM app, it can be utility app, it can be whoever claims to be an msp.

You have this possibility to really without any customer acquisition cost to start smart charging with these people. And this was already my vision always at Ellie, to use the msp of the OEMs and then building on top this first customer touch point and saying here, here's actually a menu and we can do some peak of peak, we can save you some money at home, some dynamic terrorists, whatever.

Because the OEM or the MSPs can have the date of the car, can have the state of charge, can ask for a departure time. And this was my vision and yeah, it was not really built upon because it was different business units and different focus areas in oem. And then I met Jacob and that was the business or the idea behind devpar why they founded Dev Power. It was exactly combining MSP and smart charging.

And when I heard this I was like, okay, I need to jump on that horse because it sounds like the story that I'm telling since years. And I changed.

Claudio Geyken

Cool.

Claudio Geyken

Just maybe because there are some listeners that might not be as familiar with all the jargon that we're going to use. Let's make just a quick definition. So msp, maybe you can define that and then we can put it in order of what an MSP needs to communicate with like CPO, CPMSS, etc. Maybe you can also give a bit of a. Yeah,.

Michael Johanns

Yes, it's, it's. Yeah. We are a geek environment, that's for sure. We see it every week when we have new people onboarding and so on. We use a lot of jargon, sorry, to all of the listeners that are not perhaps not used to this.

So the cpo, the charge point operator is the one that mostly owns the charger, installs the charger and operates the charger, puts the prices on these chargers and then on the other side you have the MSP or in German often as emp. It's a mobility service provider. It's the user facing part. Often they are not distinguishable. For example, EMBV is Bose. They have their own chargers and they have their own app.

But in the app they also give access to other charge points that are not owned and operated by them. And these are the two roles where we see the clear, should be a clear cut between both. So the one Operates hardware and has their own business. Case in infrastructure and of course energy as well because they buy and sell energy, but it's all around infrastructure. This infrastructure needs to work.

This new infrastructure needs to be open interpreted with as many solutions on the market. And on the other side you have the MSP that is fully focused on the driver and its car and on the needs of the driver and on the pricing. So it's a bit like the retailers in energy. They have the price authorities. They can say I take the same price as the CPOs, what most of our customers do.

But I can also say this group there, they have subscription with me so they get it 20% cheaper. Or these people, I bill it to their employer because it's employer because it's a fleet. So all of, all of this excess rights price setting for the end customer is business of the msp.

Claudio Geyken

All right.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah.

Claudio Geyken

And then maybe as a compliment as well in my view in the markets, this other big player role, maybe that is good to understand. The CPOs mostly are not charging software. They don't, they don't build their own charging software. Right. Then they buy from cpmss.

Michael Johanns

Yes.

Michael Johanns

So there are two other roles and behind these two major roles, so you have, behind the CPO you have a cpms, so a charge point management system, which is the software to operate the charge point. Some have developed it on their own, some take white label solutions or software service solutions from the market. And the same happens as well on the MSP site. EMBV has developed it themselves, both sides.

But a lot of players take it for example from us or from a lot of other software as a service solutions solution providers. And we have actually not that nice name as you have the CPMs, the software for the CPO. We don't have really a name for it on the MSP site. So it's the software as a service for MSPs. The back end that MSPs use.

Claudio Geyken

Yes,.

Claudio Geyken

And that is also. Yeah, maybe you can share what's the unique angle of dev power compared to other MSPs in. So to say that if you say okay, NBW has built their own MSP and then there's others that have built also their own. Or there might be also companies that sell MSP white label apps. I think as a business model. And what is the DevPower's angle to the whole market?

Michael Johanns

Yeah, let's start at the beginning. I think what is really important to understand when you speak about devpr is speaking about the founders, because where they came from. Jakob Van Sonneveld has founded over 10 years ago plugsurfing here in Berlin actually. And he was the first independent with his colleague co founder Adam, the first independent Romos. So they were not OEMs. They were not.

So they were not connected to the cars, they were not connected to the charger and they still, they wanted to get their place in the business. The. Yes. So they opened up a lot of roaming agreements, a lot of closed systems opened up for them and they were the first one on the market saying like, no, we have the customer, but we don't have the car, we don't sell the car and we don't have the infrastructure.

Claudio Geyken

Electron,.

Michael Johanns

We want just access to this infrastructure, which is really a mindset of interoperability, that every charging card should work everywhere and should be invoiceable. And on the other side was Mark Dix, that was back then CIO at Alego, which was kind of the first CPO that was thinking really purely from an infrastructure business and not from the user experience with it.

Like user experience, of course, at the charges, but not the user necessarily following up the user, billing the users and having the users. So they wanted to have an infrastructure business and opening up for roaming.

And so these two came together after a lot of years of experience and founded Devpower with the vision of creating the the biggest virtual EV battery on the market based off this principle that the MSP is the one that NSP in all of its forms, I come later who our customers are or what sort of customer, but that the MSP will hold the customer touch point and that smart charging and optimization only should only be done with the clear consent and the clear guidelines of the user, because the flexibility is owned by the user and not by the hardware provider of the charge point.

And that was a complete different vision until now. I think we are the only party on the market that combines these two business models of smart charging, MSP that thinks them in that regard. So that's one of the major differentiation to the others and also that we came a bit later so through the experience. So we have now the advantage of having, I think one of the most advanced platforms in that regard and what is clear.

And there I think we are as well the only ones we have never like from the start. We are only software as a service. That means we have no own drivers on our platform, we don't have own fleets as customers. Our customers have the complete ownership of the business case they can set the pricing, they own the data of the users and not us. And this is a bit distinctive to most other MSP software players on the market.

They are mostly in competition with their own customers and they are often the business provider. So on the invoice at the end stands this software provider and not the entity that actually gives the brand. For example, in Volkswagen on the, on the Skoda brand stands Volkswagen Group charging and not Skoda. So it's a bit distinct from this regard as well.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah.

Claudio Geyken

So this software as a service approach is a little bit, it has a much more flexibility, so to say. And there is a smart charging combination that is unique. All right then I think, let me just check if we had another point before we dive deeper into. Yeah, maybe before we dive deeper into smart charging. So you wanted to also say what are the customer groups typically that Devpower would service?

Michael Johanns

Yes.

Michael Johanns

So funny enough, our two biggest or two of our biggest customers are not at all in our four customer groups because they are associations. So we have the. Which is the ADSE from the Netherlands with over 100 years experience and customer base. Every second Dutch is actually member of them. And we have the EV association of Norway, Norsk Elbilfreningen.

And so two really disattached entities kind of that really were searching for somebody that does software service for them and not MSP as a service. It's really different because they own the customer data with TV SSH from Norway. They even, we even don't have any customer names. We get some just over token kind of from their CRM system. So they really use us as a roaming platform, as their app and white label app.

But in the background it's their systems, their ownership of the customer and the customer data. And that was the reason why they chose us. Even in at a time when our solution was quite elementary or like. At the beginning. So these are two big customers. Then we have the CPOs. We have a lot of CPOs that want their customer touch points for subscriptions for certain monthly loyalty programs.

Claudio Geyken

The beginning.

Claudio Geyken

Just to be clear, in this case it's not the CPO having a cpms, but rather a CPO having both a CPMS and an msp. They want to add an MSP layer.

Michael Johanns

Yes.

Michael Johanns

And so a lot of them do this in the one stop shop. So they're mostly CPMS systems have as well a certain capability to handle roaming cards. But as it is only a side business, you see that the app ratings, you see that the happiness of the customers. It is not anymore with most of these solutions, not anymore the state of the art what drivers need today.

And so we really lobby a lot to our customers to say take two different distinct solutions for the two businesses. Because on the CPMS side you need to be able to handle roaming that comes in so third party charging cards. And on the MSP business you have only a few percent of the sessions happening on your charge point, but a lot of them happen as well on third party ChargePoint.

And then you need to handle all of these invoices from outside and so on. So these are two complete different businesses and different logics and different IT solutions that you need. And yeah, it is our success at the moment. A lot of people that were in a swansub shop migrate, therefore yeah, CPOs are our business. Also a lot of Stadtwerke for example are interested in getting a good customer solution and customer app then OEMs.

So we had Fisker, unfortunately bankrupt, but we have for example General Motors for the European business we have deep conversations with quite a handful of big worldwide OEMs as well. Then energy utilities. So we have quite a lot of them that are energy suppliers and they want to cross sell through the different product lines. And often especially like in Germany, they have as well some chargers and they are like they have everything in house.

Roaming and interoperability

Michael Johanns

So they need a good touch. Customer touch point.

Claudio Geyken

All right, yeah, I followed but maybe just for the listen in the city, because of the listener, because it might get confusing sometime just to explain it in a very simple way, because I realize also when I talk with non industry professionals that people get confused. So roaming as a concept is a bit like we know it from the telco industry.

When you get with your phone and the SIM card into a grid that is not the one of your original telecommunications provider like Deutsche Telekom would go into Vodafone. In the EV industry we copied a little bit the same wording. And so if there's different charge point operators, there might be different in this case not SIM cards, but rather msps, this is charging cards. And these need to be compatible and interoperable between each other.

And that's why there is this roaming concept.

Michael Johanns

Yeah, so to go a bit deeper into this. So we have at the moment over 2,000 entities throughout Europe connected to our platform with over 900,000 charge points. So some of them have only a few, some of them have 50,000. But there are over 2,000 entities where we are technically connected.

Claudio Geyken

Chargepoint operators.

Michael Johanns

So yeah, ChargePoint operators, some have then let's say as it's the same company but with three entities in different markets, for example, but still there are for all of them different IT connections. And they all need to agree that our cards from our customers work on their chargers. So there's a contract behind it, there's an IT connection behind it.

So the charger wherever in Europe needs to accept, to detect accept this one card or remote start over the app and needs to allow this driver to charge there and need to be able. So it needs to be trusting us and our partners to go in forecast kind of because they allow the charging without getting money for this.

And then at the end of the month we receive from these over 2000 entities invoices from wherever in Europe with different VAT regimes or whatever. And we get as well the charge detail record. So the details of what has been charged, how many kilowatt hours, when, what was the time, how long has the parking been and how much do we owe them?

And yeah, it's quite complex and there have been roaming platforms like Hapcheck that simplify this access in between these players. But still there's a lot of trust needed on that regard that you're really paying the bills and that you, you trust them, that your card is really working there in the south. Italy to North Norway.

Why smart charging matters

Claudio Geyken

Right.

Claudio Geyken

All right, nit. Now let's focus on the maybe the most interesting aspect. After having laid this groundwork, I think in LinkedIn you have a self proclaimed smart charging enthusiast. So let's talk smart charging and this podcast also called Smart Charge. So why is smart charging, in your view, so important for the energy systems? What makes it so relevant and why should the listener care so to say?

Michael Johanns

Yeah, I think there are two major reasons. We said before, in the second phase of the energy transition, we need to kind of get rid of the renewals like we need to get. We need to consume them at the right moments because there's just every time when there's sunshine, there's too much solar energy in the grid.

And it makes only sense to decarbonize mobility if we are charging on renewables and not on coal, because at the end, even on coal it's a bit more efficient, but still it makes no sense to shift just the CO2 emissions. And so this first principle of smart charging is we need to charge in the cheapest and in the most frequent CO2 free hours. But on the other side is as well just a necessity.

We cannot just from a system, we cannot accommodate 100% E mobility without doing smart charging. So it's not nice to have. That's what a lot of people don't understand. The grid Operators can claim as much copper that they want to put in the ground. They can. They will not be able. They will not be able to put enough copper in the ground to accommodate 4.45 million EVs in Germany when we don't charge them intelligently.

Because when you see that only 5 million vehicles charging at the same moment, it's more or less the load of the whole energy grid in Germany. So you have a lot of hours in the.

In the year, you have around 50 gigawatts of consumption, which is 50 big power plants and 5 million vehicles charging at the same moment at a 1011 kilowatt charger, which is a normal home charger, is the equivalent of the whole industry, every household, every business in the whole country. And we want to have tenfold of this. We want to have 50 million EVs, not only 5.

So when the 50 million come home in the evening at 6 and they plug in, the chance is really high that 5 million of them are really charging at the moment. It's probably rather 20. And that means the energy system can just not deliver it. There's no power plant that can deliver it, no grid that can transport it. So there's no alternative to do smart charging.

And coming back to the first principle I said of decommodation the ev, we need flexibility as a buzzword, we need flexibility in the consumption. And the EV has just the biggest flexibility of all devices in the market. And they are paid already for the mobility part. So they will get cheaper, they will get cheaper, equivalent to diesel. So they will scale, they will take over the market, but then their consumption is super flexible.

They need to charge only twice a week, more or less, and each time for like one to three hours. So an average one hour per day, they drive one hour per day, they charge one hour per day, they stand 22 hours a day. And this charging capacity is just so big, it's 10 times bigger than average household in the peak hour, that if you push this to the right hours, you have an enormous effect on the energy system.

And you have this natural flexibility, which you don't have with other research. Even heat pumps, when it's cold, you can perhaps stop them for half an hour or an hour, but you cannot stop them for a whole day. An ev, you can just not charge for two days, because on Wednesday there's wind coming, so I just don't charge on Monday, Tuesday. And that's really the special thing why I'm so into why I'm an enthusiast of EV charging.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah, cool.

Claudio Geyken

No I can, I can definitely relate. And just for the sake of definitions as well, before we dig deeper, I've seen a little bit of different definitions of smart charging. Actually when I first started really looking into the topic of smart charging, I even saw some people talking about chargers being smart when they just were actually connected to the Internet, which I think we can agree it's not the smart charging we are talking about.

And I see a lot of distinction between bi directional and V2G and smart charging, which for me I don't know if there is a dictionary definition. Actually my random side fact, my dad is actually leading the German dictionary so should ask him now. Maybe he's listening.

But yeah, what's in definition for you is smart charging going, going, stopping at so to say V1G so only charging in one direction or also bi directional charging including all the flexibility? Yeah. Where does it.

Michael Johanns

Between this V1G, V2G? I don't see that clear. Also because I through my experience at Volkswagen, I put a virtual pause button on V2G for at least three to five years. There are so many hurdles on the ground. And also everybody is focusing on this and every discussion in every universe, in every pilot project, everybody wants to do something with bi directional charging.

But we have at the moment over 95% of the charging sessions of the really kilowatt hours that we are charging are not optimized, are not intelligent. Like it's completely like the discussion of the research and of the of a lot of podcasts as well are completely distinct from the reality in the market.

We don't have like I would say we have less than 0.01% of the charging sessions happening with a vehicle that is bi directional charging ready, with a user that is bi directional charging ready and the charger that is bi directional charging ready.

And when this is the percentage, then yeah, for us as a company, but also for me as from an energy market perspective, it is at this moment in time a theoretical exercise and it is something that needs to be prepared in politics and it needs to be a topic in regulatory workshops and needs to be tackled in grid connection descriptions and it needs to be tackled in how OEMs build their platforms because they have five to seven years development.

But it is not yet an end consumer topic on a scalable level. It is starting now. It's different than two years ago. But still for me, when I speak about smart charging, I don't exclude bi directional charging, but I also don't have it as the first thing in my mind because I always claim that it's just a minus sign in front of the equation.

Claudio Geyken

Makes sense.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah.

Claudio Geyken

No, so good that. Good points. Yeah. And it's actually. Let's maybe dig deeper onto that for a moment. So, starting with the hurdles, what are the big hurdles you see to make first? Starting with the simple. Why are we having such still 95% that you say of the charging sessions not being optimized. What's the hurdle there? Why aren't we actually doing it already? For the things that are possible, what things do you see are possible?

And for the other things, what are the major hurdles for us to be able to, to finally get rocking in all potential?

Michael Johanns

I think it's a natural evolution. So it was the last 10 years, everybody was focused on bringing cars on the market. They were early adopters that had range anxiety. We had only 50, 80 km of range, so they were not really Altax Tauklich in German. And so there were a lot of hurdles everywhere just to get it going. When you heard your previous podcast person, it said in Germany, 2015, I think it was 100 cars a month sold.

Now we are at what was it, 20,000, I think 30,000 or something. So it's just we are now really into the mass markets. The fleet accepted in other markets like Belgium, Netherlands and Denmark. We see in the last three years that we went from 10, 15% market share to now nearly 50% market share. So it's really we are there in the mass market. And therefore it was normal that in the past vehicle grid integration was stopping at the charging works.

Adoption and market incentives

Michael Johanns

So my charging card at this charger, I plug in and the car detects the charger and the electrons flow. That was a hard work of over a decade that this is really working. I see a charger on Google, I go there, I put my card and it's working. At home the same I call my electrician, he knows what he installs and it just charts. So that was the reason.

And it was also fine like this because just on an, on an energy market scale, the EVs had zero significance. Not for the grid, neither for the energy market market. This is now changing. This is changing. As I said, when you have, when you go into the millions in the European system, this is changing. And we have.

Claudio Geyken

Just to put it into perspective because I think I know the numbers at the moment. So 5 million as you said, would be 10% of the overall vehicle fleet in Germany. And now we are around 2%, I think in Germany, right?

Michael Johanns

Yeah, I think we are not even at that 2 million, 1.6 million, 2 million, something like this. So yeah, and I think the whole vehicle fleet is 40 something million. We have something to do. I mean Norway we see new sold cars are nearly 100% and in the fleet as well over 20% or 30 even they surpassed now the diesel cars. Petrol is still a bit ahead, but it's really changing every year. With an average lifetime of 8 to 10 years that will change directly.

And you see Norway now in our discussions, one of our biggest customers that they are now in the second phase and in a lot of countries comes as well on top that you need to have to optimize, you need to have an incentive. And most optimizations nowadays are just I want to consume my own electricity self, whatever. But this is not a good incentive because it should be always okay, what does the system need?

Not what is your little household optimizing on. And for this we have a principle in Dev Power that we optimize only on monetary systems. So only when the. When the driver saves money or we can give him rewards for what they are doing. And so the smart charging becomes now more relevant for the market. And what we need to find is price incentives. Price incentives, price incentives, price incentives. And in Germany it's just not possible.

When I got hired, my boss said forget Germany for the next three years. And it has to reason because you have no smart meters when you are not smart metering. And when you have 950 grid operators that are lobbying every week in the BDFE to not go further because it's a cash cow. There is a grid operations without doing it in an intelligent way. It's a little effort for a lot of returns. And they did this for the last 50 years. So Germany just.

Claudio Geyken

On that point, what would be the difference for the grid operators? Why do you think they lobby so much against smart meters?

Michael Johanns

So first of all, because all of these text files, service and servers and so on are these just. They need to change it at one point the whole market communication. Also digital meters are more complex to install more complex. You need to school your people as a Meshtenberg tribe. Or you need to have the IT infrastructure, IT security and everything around which 950 can just not handle. So there in this 950 per person five that can handle it.

And even an eon is struggling enormously with doing it. Also because the regulation is completely absurd in Germany, completely apart from from what is, what is logical. I wish the last three years that somebody would have just said okay, here every, every, let's Say smart meter gateway supplier here is a million euros or 5 million euros. And we now for your losses.

And now we start again and we just take whatever system other countries are using without secure channels, without whatever. We need 15 minutes measurements, best even minute measurements. But we need these values because without these values we cannot create market signals, we cannot create price signals. When public chargers in Germany, even when they're over 100,000 kilowatt hours going through, they are on SLP.

So in synthetic load profiles they get measured once a year. And all of the imbalance, all of the risk of having at 6 o' clock in the hardest, most expensive hours, nobody feels it because it is put in an Auskleis Bilancekreis and then put socialized on the grid fees, which is the only country in Europe that does it that way.

So there's no incentive for the whole chain to optimize something in it, neither at home nor in public, because there's no price in incentive. Because at the end, when you have no measurement over 15 minutes, it doesn't make a difference if I charge at 6 or at 9, because at the end it's just the same measurement end of the year that gets collected.

Claudio Geyken

Right.

Claudio Geyken

Just maybe to explain, because I followed. But some people that are not so familiar might not have followed the last point you made. So the way the electricity grid works is that you need to, as a consumer or producer of electricity, you need to. You nominate. That's the, that's the jargon. But it really means that you predict and, and say how much you will consume and you will produce in a particular time period normally. And if you're.

If this is meant to do to keep the stability of 50 Hz, so that the production consumption needs to be always equal at the same time. And electricity, that's the precondition from the physics. And so if you are not at particular moments as you do, you said you would, you would be penalized. And that's what you were saying that for that you need the measurements to be able to.

Michael Johanns

And you could do this even with SLPs. So countries like Belgium, when I was 10 years ago at the energy supply we had also most of the household head had no smart meters, so only a yearly measurement. But what they did is for a certain area they said here's a consumption of let's say one megawatt. You as a supplier have 10% of the customers. So for every 15 minutes you're responsible of 10% of this megawatt.

So that means you still need a good forecasting you still need a good procurement even in intraday and you. You get hit by imbalance prices if you did something wrong. And the same for solar they got. You have X percent of the solar in that area of that grid area. So you get X percent as well of the imbalance that is created by. By this. And in Germany the system is okay. The grid operator takes it off every day.

They say this is the syntactic loop profile, this denomination. Everybody simply follows it and everything that deviates from it is taken over by the system. And this is of course giving zero incentive. You can be in Germany a supplier with five people. So with five people you can handle the whole operations of an energy supplier, which shouldn't be the case. You should have a portfolio management and that you should have really intraday optimization.

You don't need it. And this of course comes to an end that you have zero price signals. And on top in public charging, we have a complex. We spoke earlier about this roaming. It's already so complex with 2000 players on the one hand and thousands on the other hand to just get the normal billing right, it was x kilowatt hours times y price. I want €30 end of the month for this session. That's already complex.

When you now take the time component in and you would put a lot of time makes it super complex. It makes it complex in the app to compare different charge points. It makes it complex in the billing, it makes it complex in the communication. So also you ask why it hasn't not been done the last 10 years everybody was so focused on getting an invoice correct and getting the session done.

Now taking this time component in is quite complex because there's so many partners involved. And this is where Devpower comes in with.

Claudio Geyken

Makes sense the complexity. Now we come back to the software point in the beginning that this supposedly old system where software didn't have to play such a big role. Now that we talking real time data transfer and control, that becomes much more a software play than before, right?

Michael Johanns

Yes.

Michael Johanns

And we see just. Yeah, we see just that it's needed. We saw the last six months we had two or three Dunkelflauten where the prices at six, seven, eight in the evening exploded. And still not every production was running and still most of the consumption, even Flex was consumption like EVs were still just charging because there was no incentive like the prices where didn't go from A to B.

Claudio Geyken

Right.

Michael Johanns

So we have everything there, the tools are there, but we have not been able to communicate from A to B hey, please stop. And then I give you a reward for this. And on the same time we saw yesterday, no, this weekend was already the first negative prices again throughout Europe because there was a bit of sunshine and we still didn't see an up more sessions in charging happen. So that's the problem that we need to solve.

Claudio Geyken

So considering what you just said, that Germany is a little bit of a tricky market because of the lack of smart meters and the DSOs being so many and some other reasons. So what's your pragmatic approach now to make things happen today?

Market strategy and flexibility

Michael Johanns

So first of all, working in other countries as well, it sounds stupid, but it's really the best learning curve. Do it with the willing, the coalition of the willing, how they called it. So go throughout Europe in markets we always follow the EVs. So in general we are stronger in countries like the Netherlands, Belgium and Norway where the EV market is just fully in the mass market. More mature people have tested the. Unfortunately not yet fully.

Claudio Geyken

Uk,.

Michael Johanns

So we will, we are connected there and so on, but we haven't had big customers yet. We have one or two going live, but it's not something. Yeah, unfortunately not yet. It's a market to look in because the UK I think is the most advanced market in flexibility, in the regulation, in the willingness to take risks and no local utilities with power. So it's a perfect combination actually to do smart training.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah, no, as far as I know as well, the uk from an energy system flexibility standpoint is quite mature. And.

Michael Johanns

Yeah, and you have the uk, the English people, Anglo Saxon people in general focus more on the soup instead of the hair in the soup. And how.

Claudio Geyken

Do you mean that in this context?

Michael Johanns

Yeah, we in Europe, especially in Germany, often first need to go through every edge case and every potential problem and all of them needs to be first solved in theory, then through practical trials and then we go live with a solution and in between is a decade. And the UK has just this ability to say, to listen to, to the market. And it's really interesting how the regulator works there.

For example, now in December they launch again this crazy concept where we lobby already since years, that flexibility providers can themselves access directly the intraday markets, the energy markets. And even without any collaboration with the supplier of this site, they can trade and they can optimize and this is something really revolutionary. Sounds. Yeah.

Claudio Geyken

Like it,.

Michael Johanns

And we speak about it since years and they just implemented it, they did some trials, they did listenings and it took I think now two, three years. And it's live. It's running and they are just faster and more risk embracing because they see, okay, we have a problem, this problem needs to be solved and here's a solution, let's do it. Instead of yeah.

Being too technology open and which means at the end, okay, we do whatever we have done in the past, they really embrace. Okay, new solution. Okay, let's.

Claudio Geyken

Go.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah, yeah.

Claudio Geyken

This pragmatism, I hear you, it's.

Michael Johanns

Pragmatism.

Michael Johanns

Yes.

Michael Johanns

That's a good.

Claudio Geyken

Successful innovation is crucial into startups.

Michael Johanns

Yeah.

Michael Johanns

And also we need to, we need to see always okay, what effect do we have now and what do we have in 10, 15 years and we cannot wait with our solutions until the problem escalates. So now it's a possibility actually to create a regulation to let it just run. Some people are happy, some people are unhappy. You see the results. Okay, what is really the financial effect?

Because in theory on the next sheet a lot of people can claim there are a lot of problems but then in reality you see, okay, what is actually. Are people cheating this whole ink deck gaming discussion and so on? Let us do it. As long as the assets are still not that many. Let us try it. Put then a second regulation 2.0 with some penalties and put then 3.0 with another adaption.

But then we learn way more than if some professors do some, some, some, some calculations based on theory. And this is a bit our approach here to change the regulation. And also in the EU of course. But I see the English out there just. Yeah, pragmatics is a run.

Claudio Geyken

Interesting.

Claudio Geyken

But not only the English. I think you also mentioned earlier the Dutch.

Michael Johanns

Yes, the Dutch are a bit more, bit less in the English and yeah, here it is a bit more difficult.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah, I don't know if you follow the Chinese market because it's a lot on my mind lately and I mean they are also known for China speed. Do you follow at all what's happening there? And especially to smart charging?

Michael Johanns

No, especially to smart charging. Not so in general I follow as, as one follows Chinese politics and the effect of the world, especially with regards on renewables and car productions and battery science advances and stuff like this, but unfortunately not in the charging business. I've never really got deep into it. It's a pity.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah, okay.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah, then just a lot of people are confused in terms of the energy system grids and, and markets. Maybe just a quick anti explainer. And then following the question is. So there's the, the. The production of energy and then the demand of energy. On the other hand that make up the markets. And so there's market pricing then based on like Economics 101, where it's, it's a result of demand and production.

So when there's lots of renewables, that's what we're talking earlier. Prices are usually low in markets or even negative, which is a phenomenon we will not maybe go deeper into for now, but. And then vice versa. Then there's the Gritsky side of the equation, which kind of, if you take the metaphor of water, you have how much water can, can, can flow into these pipes.

And then, and the same, in the same analogy, electricity cannot flow endlessly into these pipes. So there is a constraint, natural constraint based on the copper cables that are there. So as Michael said earlier, we either have the option of expanding these, these cables or deciding how to best utilize these cables in time. Now this is a prelude.

So there is opportunities in this arbitrage of electricity prices in the energy markets that can be captured with smart charging. And then there's reduced grid fees from these grid operators. And then I think every market is a bit. And every country has a slightly different flavor of it. But in, in Europe, luckily, at least in the mark in the first in the markets, not the grids, it's quite harmonized now with this, this being the setting the scene.

So what, what's the, your approach now of is it better to go through the energy markets first and then going to the grids, or is it country by country, like the Netherlands I know is very constrained by electricity grids. So that might be more attractive to focus on that area. How do you view these values.

Michael Johanns

From business or from a regulatory point of.

Claudio Geyken

View?

Claudio Geyken

Yeah, first from a business and then maybe you can say what regulatory barriers, if there are any.

Michael Johanns

So from a business, I would say the easiest is always focusing on the energy markets. If you have smart meters and real allocation and real balancing, because you have clear responsibilities that are there clear rules and immediate benefits. Because it's just, it's two independent systems. There's the one, the measurement of a household or site or whatever that anyways works for how the system works to bill.

And on the other side you have the optimization. And when you optimize immediately, the procurement costs will lower. So you have immediate effect of somebody that profits from it. And therefore the whole system is easier because you don't need to communicate to somebody. You don't need to integrate. You. You can just say, okay, I optimize for you here it's your savings. Give me a chunk of this.

Whereas on the, on the grid part, of course they are regulatory regulated businesses and they are just not allowed to give me money. So they need to have the regulation on place to pay people. That gives the flexibility, which in most countries is not the case.

So most grid operators in most countries only get money if they build new stuff and then they have X years where they get X percent of it, which is ridiculous because then they say of course I need to build more stuff because that's how they, how they get more money. And if you don't have smart meters and sensors in the system, you even don't know if you need more because you don't know how the utilization of it is.

And you can just claim I need more. You put in the easiest places were more cables and you, you get more money. And there is a lot of money. There are billions and billions and billions in this system. I mean at the moment it's ridiculous. We go into over 10 cents per kilowatt hour of grid fees. That's a lot of money. That's more money than the energy value of it.

And so what we claim and what we lobby for, but as a business of course not the first attractive market because there's so much regulation, so many rules, so many stuff. And until you can access this and in a lot of countries it's just not there like in Germany, there is no dso like distribution system operator money that you could collect.

Now they started with some flexible tariffs, but unfortunately again not global but every little entity somewhere published a PDF on their website with certain rules behind it with a lot of more conditions and this effect and like this it is not really interesting to scale and neither to use it actually.

So yes we are in favor of dynamic grid tariffs, but even more in favor of flexibility markets like the nodes platform in Norway where the grid of will say in this area, in this city, I need people to not consume or I need people now to consume and people like us can say we actually can do it for you.

Claudio Geyken

Right.

Claudio Geyken

I think in the Netherlands forgot now the tip of my tongue they also have that system. Gopex, exactly. That would be similar and are you not? That's not. I heard good things about it, but I'm not as familiar with and as you are in the Netherlands, I guess is that you're not. Are you okay? Do you think it should be changed?

Michael Johanns

Gopex.

Michael Johanns

It should be upgraded? I think the principle of it is good. The problem is that like always in the energy market it's easier to make a contract with somebody that has a megawatt of flexibility and has one local place that you can measure with a more expensive meter and so on. Than if you have it really distributed in household level where you have multiple assets.

Claudio Geyken

Distributed.

Michael Johanns

I say like a car with a PV with heating interfering and it's more difficult to really see okay, what was the effect of what I ordered? And there again it is not really on a granular level. So for big parties and big companies it is easy to access and it is a super good system. But it is not yet used enough by dso.

So it's really often used for re dispatcher of tenant level and not yet really on local level and on top not enough on small asset classes where it's easy really to say, okay, I have here 10,000 vehicles in that region. Make me an easy process. Here's your red button. Give me some money. You know, so it's. They will go there. It's a good start, but it's not yet usable for us.

Claudio Geyken

One thing that I found interesting in the in this new energy world is that there's all sorts of different players and I'd love to hear your opinion on the following question, which is so there's like people optimizing heat pumps, there's people producing batteries and optimizing stationary batteries that are up and coming. Then there's chargers oem. So people optimizing for from the charger angle, others coming from the EVs.

Yeah, so there's all sorts of dimensions if you want on optimizing. And how do you see this relationship between the different assets or players in sync in the future on trends there is it gonna. I used recently the analogy, is it gonna be a cacophony of signals trying to somehow make it work or is it going to be a nice concert of beautiful APIs that are going to work in sync to create. Yeah,.

Michael Johanns

I like your analogy because I just had a great idea for an answer. So if you take hobby musicians and you put them together and say make a concert, it will be a cacophony. This is what we are doing now. We have amateur players on the market that are only optimizing their own systems. Didn't think of interoperability and then they try to play together and it doesn't work.

Interoperable flexible assets

Michael Johanns

But if you take professional musicians, you can take them together in the evenings, they have never seen each other, you give them the chords and you say now we play together. They can play in a synthetic. So I had friends that play in this. They didn't train for it just before. This is the Music and then they tested it shortly and they go there and they can play in huge concerts. And I think this is where we need to.

This is exactly the analogy where I want to go. If you have players, professional players in the market with good solutions that are open to collaborate, because this is the first condition you need to be open to collaborate. You don't need to want to build your new closed one stop shop solution where you want everything of the customer.

But if you are open to collaborate and I think there's not one way to go to Rome to the answer and a lot of regional players, a lot of solutions for different. Every household is different, every user makes different choices and they should do so. And so for us what is really important is when we come into a household there are other players that we've.

Or on a site where you would be then working, for example with RiDERgy that we find the best way of optimizing for the user. And the end goal is always lowering the total cost of ownership because with lower costs we get more EV participation. And this we only get if we collaborate. So as we do it now with thousands of CPOs, we also want to do it with thousands of local controllers. Not with the controller itself, with the back ends.

With OEMs we have already 40 OEMs now integrated where we can see how full the battery is and so on and the same. Then on this complex site throughout Europe there's somebody that's better than us. Okay. Then we deliver just the user interface and some data and they do the job. On other places there is nobody. So then we do the job somebody, there's a utility supplying that site that has already programs running.

Then we need to integrate into them and deliver them the best forecast or ability that we can. So we really come from this. We are experts of EVs and the user and we have the interface of as many and hopefully at one point millions of users throughout Europe. And then our cars, our cards, our apps of our customers are used at certain places and in that place then if there are many of these places, then we will integrate and try to help locally.

We have nodded all this total control, one stop shop ambition.

Claudio Geyken

No, that resonates with me. Yesterday I listened to a podcast from the founder of One5. I feel is a bit more closed approach is not the way forward.

Michael Johanns

I mean I would be happy when Philipp calls us and wants as well a good charging solution for the street because I think they have a great branding. But yes, I don't agree with their philosophy of saying you need to have the full control in one system to get to the 100%.

Because I really believe in a complete, fully interpreted way and in a way they do it because in every market they have as well different back end helpers, let's say, to bring the solution into the energy market. But still I wished we could, for example, in place like this, where our car comes to their heartbeat, where we would send them, for example, state of charge data.

When the charge is not steerable because it's already there, don't replace it by one from Eins Kung Fu, just let us steer over the car, let us deliver you the data and we can work together. So I really believe rather in this way that sometimes you touch, sometimes you don't. And our strong belief is then wherever the car comes and the driver comes, there should be a possibility to lower the costs and to help the system.

Claudio Geyken

Right.

Claudio Geyken

And you mentioned in one blog post, I think you wrote together with Jakob as well, that the MSP or dev power in particular would be very well positioned as a market position, so to say, to leverage most of the flexibility. Maybe you want to highlight some of the main points you wrote there for the listeners here.

Michael Johanns

Yeah, nice scene to do so. Nice opportunity. So where we come from is really from this public charging and in public charging there is no smart charging era happening right now. So and most people that speak about smart charging speak about just at home, as I said, doing some solar optimization. But where we come from is rather we have this MSP solution. We have millions of sessions, charging sessions that are happening wherever.

Claudio Geyken

Right.

Michael Johanns

And we think that because we are so close to the driver and to the car, that we can predict where the car will be at what point and needs to leave again. That we can predict, okay, how much flexibility is there and this in public and in private and in semi public, for example, on sites where you guys are.

And therefore we believe that the MSP is eccentric because they have the ability to bring this flexibility to the public charging and to bill it, to invoice it and to treat the data with the user. To take for example an opt in or an opt out, the user needs to be in control. And this is not possible if you do it just through the charger. And yeah, and we believe that the MSP is there, the one that have these millions of user touch points.

ANWB smart-charging programme

Michael Johanns

And yeah, we showed this next week, Wednesday, it was a pity. We were supposed to go this week live, but we postponed it by a week because like always with launches, some little app issues, the app gets Released I think now to the app stores and it's our biggest customers. ANVB in the Netherlands goes next Wednesday live on one of the big CPOs in the Netherlands on over 2000 chargers in Amsterdam with over 200,000 users having access to this.

And when they arrive at this charger they are not fully informed before but when they arrive they will get a push notification and have to put a possibility to tell us when they depart and when there is potential to make savings on the energy markets. We will optimize in the name or for the grid CPO and the end of the month we will give the drivers a cashback to help us and we will invoice the CPO for the service that we deliver.

And this is in my opinion or in my knowledge, one of the first fully interoperable smart charging. You cannot poke all it pilot because it's in, in full production, full life and it's fully scalable. So every CPO that listens to this can, can, can write me an email. We can do this in, in, in minutes.

We can put your charger as well in the program and then we can optimize the sessions on, on discharges and this is something where we really strongly believe and hopefully at one point we are able to, to optimize I don't know, 50, 60, 70% of the sessions that a user does in whatever environment with every time different partners that are locally the best ones to save money.

Claudio Geyken

It sounds very cool. Yeah. I'm excited to then see the results and then maybe have another recording to learn more.

Michael Johanns

It would be nice. The big press release will come or the press, how to say action will be the 27th. So it will take. We make a silent lounge. Well now it's not that silent anymore. Now I said it. But the big official lounge is on the 27th that it gets announced in the press and we hope that a lot of CPOs starting in Netherlands, but hopefully as well beyond will join our path and will believe in this interoperable smart charging ecosystem system.

Claudio Geyken

Nice.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah.

Claudio Geyken

And then what's your view on how fast will we be able to do bi directional charging at scale? I mean you said indeed that there's like. I think you said 0.01% what was it? Combinations of of cases where it's actually feasible. I think Chademo from, from.

From Japan that were leading the way with that standard making it possible with some particular Japanese car cars in the, in the beginning I think Octopus Energy has, is in England launched one of the first or if not the first bi directional OV2G tariff where I think it's only compatible with the, with that type of vehicles and chargers.

And I think also Mobility House with Renault recently announced something in France and that was quite, quite interesting as well. But yeah, indeed there are very few cases here and there.

Michael Johanns

Cases especially the volumes. So I would like to know how many vehicles are until now on the pilot because you need to have the right charger from Renault with the right car from Renault with the right energy tariff from Renault or from the Mobility House and then you need to want to work with them. So there's a lot of ifs and compared to the global or the European car sales, that's still little.

Still this, especially this Renault case I like a lot because I was the biggest ambassador, let's say inside the Volkswagen Group to do AC bidirectional charging. I'm a strong believer that when you do it the AC path and we finally in a few years get the European Union to force grid operator to have one global or one European aggregation so that you can say okay, whatever the rules are, they can be as tough as possible.

It's not a problem for the power electronics. The problem is if you have every charge in every street and every grid operator different rules which are always the same but just a bit different. The problem is it makes them just tough what you want from these inverters, but makes them the same throughout Europe. And when we have this same throughout Europe plus we have. Because if they are that tough, we don't need any regulation anymore.

Bidirectional charging outlook

Michael Johanns

Nothing actually on the charger. So the charger doesn't need to be a bi directional charger, it can be just a normal charger. If the vehicle takes over all the job of the regulation. And it's the same regulation throughout Europe. And if we have this really bi directional charging, it comes from cases actually that have nothing to do with to grid.

It's really cool to clean your car with vacuum cleaner in your plug or you have your laptop charging in the plug. So it comes really from this. You saw it last year or two years ago, Ford was making an advertisement of the F150 only about barbecue. It had nothing to do with the car actually. So I really believe in this vehicle to home emergency power in a lot of countries.

I really believe in this vehicle to load thing and people are willing to pay €200 more for a vehicle if you have a plug inside. It's really cool to have 50 kilowatt hours or 100 kilowatt hours. You can have A whole festival with this for a whole weekend. And like the people in the Altal would have been happy when they would have had for these three months or two months without electricity, a car standing.

I mean, not the people that had no houses anymore, but all the people around that had no electricity for weeks. For them, having a 70, 80 kilowatt hour battery in housing, just plugging in your lamps and so on would have been a super big effect. So I really believe from that effect comes that the cost is taken over. And when the regulation is there and the cost is taken over, you have this exactly what we do with smartshard.

You have a free asset and then we can concentrate on the first cases. I don't believe on the short term, on the full arbitrage business, because the OEMs have a huge battery quality problem. And the problem is not that. Yes, it's the guarantee, it's not the problem that they cannot build them. But you have always these four points. It's weight, it's charging speed, its cost and its durability. And you can never have all four at the same time.

Claudio Geyken

Lifetime guarantee.

Michael Johanns

So you always, when you go rather in fast charging, you have a bit less of durability or a bit less in cost, but for a bit. So all of the Chemex that they have is always, when you go more in one direction, you have a bit less of the other and they get always all of them bit better. But still you have always this arbitrage to say okay, what do I want from my vehicle model?

And on top they have the problem that they have three, four, five suppliers which bring out every three, four months a new cell model. So they have in the same ID3, I don't know, a thousand different battery cells over 10 years. So and all of them they need to guarantee full 160,000 km 8 years. And it's easy to do so for 90% or 80%. But unfortunately with guarantees Pareto doesn't work guarantees.

You need to have 99.9 or something or 99, otherwise you lose money. Because recruit faction like taking the cars back and replacing batteries and so on is super expensive. So there is this cautiousness, and I can understand this, that destroy a lot of business cases, let's say on the arbitrage models.

But where BI direction charging can be super powerful is for example afr it says, for example helping grid operators for the people that are not deep in the market. You can sell capacity of your like to put the possibility of getting activated to grid operator. And you get paid for not doing anything. So you get paid for just being available. And this availability has a huge value for the energy system.

And if we have a lot of bi directional chargers, cars connected to system that get paid for just being available if the system needs them. We don't need backup power plants anymore. We have at the moment, I don't know, 3, 4, 10 gigawatts or something in German notre serve. All of this you don't need anymore if you have all of these cars connected to it.

Claudio Geyken

Right.

Michael Johanns

So I believe rather in this, I don't know, 100 activations maximum a year, perhaps even only 20, something like this, like really for the peak of the peak, six in the evening, ten times a year. That's a perfect case for the next years of bi directional charging.

Claudio Geyken

And just for the listeners, again, there's like this bi directional often in the jargon this is AC or dc. What it really means is that the inverters in the car that basically converts or inverts rather the, the. The DC battery into AC usable from the grid. And that can happen either in the car or at the charger level. And if it's in the car, it's called AC for some reason. And then if it's, if it's in the charger, it's called dc.

Michael Johanns

Well, because it's through the cable runs either AC or dc,. Either the, the AC comes into the car. What you do with slow chargers, you have always in the car. And this is also the reason why I really believe it should be in the car. Because you have already power electronics, it's diodes. So they are not bi directional yet. But still you have already this onboard charger, it costs something like €300.

Claudio Geyken

Right?

Michael Johanns

And for making it bi directional it costs something like €350. So the cost on top are really not that big. The problem is when you need to make this decision. Of course for 30 million cars on the platform, that becomes significant these 50 years. And car manufacturers are calculating on the cents per screw because it's really every little cost times X million times. It's big.

But still if you pay the 30, 50, €80, whatever it is in your onboard charger through as a business model like vehicle to load like emergency power and you have it inside, then you have nearly no additional cost anymore in the chain. And you have this people like us could just access it through digital solutions. The problem is if you do it the D.C. road. Yes. You have zero additional cost in the car. Just some software developments, they have done it.

So it Works they have no additional costs anymore. But then you need a quite expensive wall box and a charger. An AC charger is nothing more like a plug with a bit of security and software in it. So it's a little microchip with a certain it's a plug. But a DC is completely different. It's more like a solar inverter. But in complex solar inverter is way easier to build or. Well, you have certain other aspects. But in vehicle you have this.

You need to disconnect the vehicle from the and it makes it directly because you don't get into the units. It's more expensive. The same hardware that costs in the car €300 to €500 cost you €3,000 to €5,000 because you don't have the volumes. And on top, what is not to forget is you need special people again to install them. Electricians are super expensive. Grid operators want different certificates, which is the process super expensive.

So for me it's really crucial which side we go to. I know China goes a completely different way. They even don't have an onboard charger. In a lot of cars they go completely dc. That's another situation when you go down that road. But in Europe, as we have everywhere AC chargers and we will have always onboard chargers in next years in the car. I really pledge to say like they did it with Renault, put the bi directionality in the car.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah.

Claudio Geyken

The issue I see is that indeed the trend is not yet certain. Like there's even more still work on DC than ac.

Michael Johanns

Because as an OEM is way easier. It's just a software upgrade.

Claudio Geyken

And especially the grid codes as far as I understand are problematic. You need to, as you said to all these different grid operators,.

Michael Johanns

The commission would see this as their most important problem. They could solve this in months. And then we could backwards looking. We could with a software upgrade do it through all the chargers.

You know, when the physical charger that is built now in the car has capabilities of going with the most severe grid code on the European market, which is not way more cost than a lower capability because they are in microseconds they can or milliseconds they can can react. It's far enough for everything that the grid needs.

So if you have the physical built in in the car there, then even when the regulation comes only in three years, you do software upgrade and then it's interoperable throughout Europe. But when you go the D.C. way you have still always this expensive. You have nothing in the car. So then you have this expensive charger and you need to hope that a user pays so much money. But there is no business case.

I haven't seen seen a business case really on a paper that says okay, I built now €5,000 bi directional charger and I have a full vehicle to create a positive business case.

Claudio Geyken

And there's still also the hurdle software wise ISO 1511, 8, 20 that's the standard communication protocol between chargers and vehicles. Right. For being able to use then should we have then the AC setup that we just discussed? This also is a requirement for bi directional charging, right?

Michael Johanns

Well, it's a requirement because we want to make it a requirement. If we wouldn't have different grid connection codes and we would just say this is the European grid connection code and this car is in Europe because they are just different cars for security reasons. Cars are different in Europe, in America and in China. So you know that the car is in Europe, it's produced for the European market. So you could hard code in this car.

This is the European grid code. And as soon as you get connected to the grid, this is what you need to follow. So then in this, when we would put the regulation in that way, we would not need any communication in this ISO 15118 which combines how is. The. Yeah. Which grid code curves you need to follow? Because it is just in the car and this is just from the setup. And therefore we are stuck always in the same discussions. And in Germany it cannot be.

It will never be scalable. If 950 players put on a PDF somewhere on the Internet, a different cosiness phi, all of them have 09 but you are not sure. So you need to go and search it and then you need to program it as an electrician locally. But if we just say it's 085, which is more severe, but it's just applicable for whole Europe. And this is the curve that needs to follow first.

Even not 0.85, but a curve from 1 to 05 whatever, depending on what the grid does. And you measure it in the onboard charger, which it anyways needs to do to make vehicle to load. In a vehicle to load scenario, the onboard charger needs to measure all of these flows. So it has the capabilities of doing. So we don't need any capabilities in the in the charger if we want to. But credit operators are lobbying against it.

The regulation is not set up, but it would be nice to see some OEMs. And Renault is starting it now to say no, we go in front, we put it in the chargers. Here's one Scenario with our wall works in one country where it works. But see we put it in every car because they put it even in the car that is sold to Germany. Even when they know the next three years. It's no business to make a joke.

And this is brave and I would love to see all of them going that a brave movement and then we would get.

Claudio Geyken

Let's be optimistic when assuming that many take the brave move. What's your most optimistic timeline for for these things to be done?

Michael Johanns

Well done is always a question, right? We have seen it now it works, it is applicable. I think it will grow, it will grow exponentially. But coming from a really low, low, low point. And we know how slow these platform developments are and how long they want to keep them in the market. And we in that one regard, we will not see a lot of innovation coming from China because they have completely different, different technical setup there.

And the OEMs cannot play a big role in the energy market in Europe. And therefore I'm not that optimistic. But I really believe in 2030 that bi directional charging every car has it. At least the D.C. road. But even I think ac wise a lot of cars will have have it built in.

Fraud and charging security

Claudio Geyken

And then yeah, finalizing a little bit on a completely different note. But I find it entertaining and maybe that also could be an interesting topic. So I'm also you know, James Bond or these type of movies where you always have some interesting intrigues. I saw recently that I think, I think it was Jacob or your, your Devpower page you post about theft being an issue right now in EV charging.

So maybe you can share some insights of who these people, what type of gangs are trying to game the system and what needs to be done. What are the MSP is doing to prevent this type of things from happening?

Michael Johanns

Yeah, I can of course not go into full details because it's also the problem with fraud is that if you put your solutions too open, people will find the loophole or the hole and will then continue doing so. So fraud is a big issue in the, in the whole industry. The problem is that you have really low margins on the MSP business. And most of the business cases are just positive or most of them actually negative and they do it for other purpose.

So they don't. They cannot afford to lose even more money. And what is happening is that there are two major different ways of doing fraud. The one is we have unfortunately 15 years ago chosen a really weak technology with the RFID cards which is just a simple identifier saved on it and it's also saved on the charger. And as soon as they detect it, they allow charging.

It's really a pity that we have not gone more into NFC or other protocols that are used in the banking industry, because these cards are super easy to copy. You can buy on Amazon system and you can really copy the code and you can even do this over long distance.

So at one point somebody finds a code, sends it over and unfortunately I without wanting to be racist, but it was a lot in Bulgaria and Romania, a lot of cases that they then use for certain hours or days, a lot of people use the same code on their local devices that mimic a card. And then they do as many charging sessions as possible with a stolen token. And then the token gets blocked and they buy a new one.

And there is apparently a black market where you can buy for some euros a token and you can use it for certain sessions. That was the one direction where we have quite a lot of measures of like some clients just shut down certain countries, Some clients don't allow virtual tokens anymore. For example, you need to have a physical address in your country to be able to chart. And especially for this copying, we detect is it physically possible?

Is it possible, for example, when you have two sessions at the same time, we block them if you have 1,000km in between, we block them if you have. So there are certain measurements that you can say, or if you're charging way more kilowatt hours than you have said you have as a vehicle. So there are certain measures that we detect automatically.

And we are putting every few weeks a new measurement in it to detect the fraud and to block the tokens as fast as possible. And the second is, unfortunately, a lot of our clients don't use physical tokens anymore. They allow as well virtual tokens. So you can just through the app, create an account and then you can start sessions through the app. And it is of course easier to create fake accounts.

You have Revolut that gives now credit cards where everybody thinks a credit card. And banks with European law have certain know your customer rules. But apparently with five clicks you can have now a virtual credit card on the Revolut. And you can use this virtual credit card to create a virtual user on an msp. And you start with a virtual token a session, and you put €1 on this account. And so the whole know your customer or whatever.

First checks work because it is an official account, but there's just no money in. And then you do fast some sessions. And when you have a lot of MSPs that charge only once a month. You have done a thousand euros of charging and then the account is there and you create a new account.

So this is the second kind of big fraud issue where we go now way more like a lot of customers go now with prioritization, taking at the beginning for the first X sessions, I don't know, blocking 50 heroes on your account. Then they realize, okay, it is not there.

But we still as the industry is quite immature, we have still a lot of chargers, for example with physical tokens that are saved locally on the charger, the huge token list and then they accept the charging and they send. Only a day later they send us, oh, there was a charging session, so we don't know about it, so we cannot block it. So of course then we can send to all of them, please don't allow this token anymore.

But still it could be that and already a future. So we have these both places. We have legacy system systems, quite a lot of them, but also we have groups, apparently organized groups that really choose the weakest. And for us as a platform it's of course as they always search the lowest resistance like fraud always goes to the weak players. And there are a lot of weak players in this industry.

So what we need to ensure as a platform is that our customers are not the weak so player and that somebody else is weaker. And as they go to this, it has a double positive effect. Our customers don't have fraud, but also our competitors customers search for new solutions. I know it's bad, but it's how the market works. And we want to stand apart with, in collaboration, really close collaboration with our clients to solve this fraud issues.

But it must be said as well, like in every business there is a certain percentage of unpaid bills. I think even if you have the best customers, you have always some people that you need to do some debt collections and some process and some reminders and. But it's not real fraud, it's more like unpaid bills. But this, what we just spoke about is especially in 2024, it erased throughout the whole industry and it needs to be solved.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah, no good that you are tackling that and quite challenging times. And then lastly to end on a positive note, there's a lot of challenges also macro challenges.

See the US where strangely the electric mobility is being attacked if you want from from the very high ups there, including Elon Musk, which I'm very surprised that he would support then a government that is obviously against immobility and not only there, but also also governments like Here in the IFD or otherwise. So there's challenges here and there like the fleet emissions standard in Europe.

Energy-transition outlook

Claudio Geyken

I think just yesterday or the day before was reduced the ambitions it feels like E mobility and sustainability and renewables and energy transition. The topic of this podcast and we have deep dive is being a little bit attacked from different. What gives you hope and what. What's your biggest hope for the next. Let's say year or three years that you can, that you can achieve.

Michael Johanns

Yeah, my hope come from a bit of pragmatism, I would say when you look in what we have done the last 20 years, since 2008 when the PV boom started, kind of. And since 2015, it's less than 10 years that the evidence boom started. Nobody like humans are always good in forgetting the standpoint of the past. And it's really. It is bad, but it is way better than we expected 15, 20 years ago.

And with this bad but better than we thought argument, I would like to end the podcast because we have put this artificial 100% decarbonization target for 2050. I'm a Pareto principal person. So we should not focus on the last 20 30% now we should focus on the other 80% and if it's then at the end 2025, but we have a really sustainable solution that's also fine. What is important now? And this is what makes me really hope.

It doesn't matter who is President of the United States. It doesn't matter who is the Bundeskanzenz in Germany. Because we have seen with footwell tag that countries like Pakistan, Nigeria and so on decentralized, they see just it's the cheapest way of producing energy. It's booming in all third world countries. They will not go the coal way anymore. They will just go directly to decentralized solar and wind. Exactly.

Claudio Geyken

Telecommunication leapfrogging.

Michael Johanns

And the same happens at the moment with batteries. Batteries are so incredibly cheap. Therefore also here, please grid operators stop putting these big 500600 billion euros plants to build more grids. Put batteries. Let us put batteries everywhere. They will solve so many problems in our system and they get cheaper every day. And we have never thought five years ago that they could ever be so cheap. And in five years it will be even, even more cheap.

And so with this, just about this. And they're thanks to China. Actually, it's not thanks to the German solar industry that we have this boom. It's thanks to China taking over on scales that we would have never thought that somebody can produce 200 gigawatts or 300 gigawatts of solar and now going the same way now with batteries. And thanks to these incredible manufacturing capabilities of China, there's no go way back.

You saw it under the first Trump era. There were never four years where America has more decarbonized than these four years. There's never been more coal plants being closed because they can just not compete anymore with the other solutions. And this will be the same on E mobility. It's a bit harder because especially in a country like Germany where it nearly like a religion to drive with 250 on the autobahn.

But for the normal population it makes at one point sense. People who are negative about E mobility have mostly not driven one. Once. You drive once and you drive it for some days you are like okay, that's incredibly nice to drive. I can charge at home if I have a garage. I for example, don't have a garage. I only charge in public. But I have free parking in the city center. It's amazing. We drive to the city center.

I see beforehand if the parking is free mostly sometimes there are bad people blocking it, but mostly I see okay, two places free. So I have my parking. I don't pay parking, I charge. In the meantime, it's not stoppable. That wave is not stoppable. And if we are two years later than we thought, it doesn't matter in exponential curves. The result is it's just unbelievably fast how it's growing. And that makes me super positive.

We are on in the middle of an of an incredibly exponential curve on both solar, wind and batteries and E mobility. And this will will change the world of energy in the next 10 years.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah, very cool. Yeah. And just on a side note to end as well. Yeah. I'm also very enthusiastic about this, this huge investment that China has been doing with all these solar especially systems and batteries and then EVs now. And instead of criticizing that all the time and saying hey, why are they investing so much in the technologies and we have to compete against this big investment, let's also invest in doubling down on the effort here in Europe.

If as I and you definitely do agree that that's the future, then let's invest in the future instead of criticizing those that do.

Michael Johanns

Yes.

Michael Johanns

And also why are we picking out the solar industry when the clothes industry, the phones, all the televisions, all our most of even our machines at home, everything comes from China or from Southeast Asia? Because they are just way better in manufacturing cheaper, better quality and really in big, big, big volumes. And we have lost all of these industries from here. And it was okay because it just got better and cheaper.

And therefore for us all as consumers, that was fantastic. But then just in. And we import 100% of our oil and nowadays all of the hard coal as well and all of the gas. But then on the solar cells we really look critical to China. I'm like, why there's even no natural dependency when they make the prices higher then somebody else put a mass production because the technology is available throughout the world. We know how to build these.

So if they increase the prices, we stop selling them for a year. And then it's another country puts a huge production. What India for example is to. And then we still have it. It's not that they sit on rare earth, for example, whereas there's a problem. But in solar manufacturing they bring the costs so down they are competing with each other. And even if they put subsidies in it, it's great.

Let them put subsidies on the manufacturing and give us super cheap electricity for the whole world. To the last desert place in Africa that can now afford to have to have light and electricity. That's a good thing. We should focus on the good thing, not on the, on the negative part of this.

Claudio Geyken

Well, with that last in famous few words, thanks a lot Michael for joining the podcast and best of luck with the upcoming projects.

Michael Johanns

Thank you very much. Thanks Claudio for letting me come here and speak.

Claudio Geyken

Sure.

Claudio Geyken

Wow, that was fascinating. With Michael. I learned a ton, I hope. Also for the first time we had a deep dive in the smart charging dimensions were a bit longer than the usual, but I think we really got a lot of it from his background and how an OEM like one of the second largest in the world thinks and how these type of players are in the charging market. Alongside the breakdown with the CPOs, the MSPs and CPMSS and all this jargon.

We covered a lot of ground to understand as well the differences between different countries and opportunities today and in the future, especially in bidirectional charging, considering grid codes, technological differences and then all the way as well to practical examples and what makes Devpower unique. Yeah, I had a blast learning all of that.

And then yeah, the tremendous fraud going on and all the creative ways people manage to always think of how to deceive and then you need to play the cat and mouse game and all the good ways as well to block and circumvent these frauds happening today. And then especially ending on a positive and cool optimistic note hopeful. I love Michael's optimism.

And I also double down on even if some people try to challenge the future and don't see all the benefits of less pollution and in tackling the climate, global warming, that will have tremendous consequences. And already, most people already faced with these consequences and not only doing it for avoiding all these negative consequences, but also seeing the opportunities of so much cheaper mobility and energy that is yet to come in this transition.

Coming from a, from the challenges of this transition, getting there will, will be amazing. And this is, this is, we're in the middle of it. And let's remember all that we have achieved already and the best is yet to come. And on that note, stay tuned for the next episode and thanks for listening. Sam.

Ep. 6 · Michael Johanns

0:00 / 1:43:56