Smart Charge by RiDERgy · 第 14 集
监管如何塑造智能充电与灵活性的未来
Andreas Jahn
RAP 高级专员
18 June 2025 · 50 min · English · 主持人: Claudio Geyken
章节 (9)
节目笔记
监管对能源转型的塑造作用超过技术,RAP 高级专员 Andreas Jahn 手握监管图谱,足以佐证。对话从欧盟的“Fit for 55”一揽子计划谈起:为什么 AFIR 要求公共充电桩为每辆电动车提供 1.3 kW,替代燃料基础设施法规如何迫使成员国做好规划,以及为什么智能充电的灵活性是尚无人采购的最廉价电网资产。Claudio 与 Andreas 梳理了从布鲁塞尔指令到德国落实 §14a 的整条脉络。
从电网费用结构、市场自由化,到双向充电面临的障碍,Andreas 解释了灵活性与成本效率往往是如何由政策决定的。我们还谈到英国、美国与欧盟之间的关键差异,车队作为灵活能源资产的角色演变,以及为什么监管协调对于在全球范围内推广智能充电至关重要。
无论你是能源行业的专业人士,还是好奇的产消者,这期节目都会告诉你规则为何重要,以及你如何参与塑造规则。
提到的资源
嘉宾的公司
- RAP (Regulatory Assistance Project)
Andreas Jahn 所在的独立国际非政府组织,在他结束德国能源监管生涯后致力于推动清洁能源监管政策。
法规与标准
- EU Clean Energy Package / Directive (EU) 2019/944
Andreas 提到的欧盟立法,据他所说自 2021 年起要求推行与批发价格挂钩的动态电价。
- §14a EnWG (German Energy Industry Act)
德国关于电动车充电新的分时动态电网费用的规定,Andreas 称之为“NVG 14A”。
- §19 StromNEV (individual network charges)
德国关于中压等级特殊或个别电网费用安排的条例,Andreas 将其与 §14a 的低压规则作了对比。
公司与工具
- Bundesnetzagentur
德国联邦网络局兼能源监管机构,讨论中被视为最终从政府手中接过电价方法决策的机构。
- ACER (EU Agency for the Cooperation of Energy Regulators)
欧盟监管机构的联合机构,RAP 关于需求响应与消除障碍的报告就是提交给它的。
- DHL
Andreas 指出,凭借规模经济,DHL 规模的车队最容易实现盈利性的电动化。
引用本集
Geyken, C. (host), Jahn, A. (guest). "监管如何塑造智能充电与灵活性的未来." Smart Charge by RiDERgy, Episode 14, 18 June 2025. www.ridergy.com/zh/podcast/ep-14-andreas-jahn-of-rap-how-regulation-shapes-the-future-of-smart-charging-fle
文字记录
6,804 词 · 机器转录
- Claudio Geyken, 主持人
- Andreas Jahn, 嘉宾
由机器转录整理而成。译文为机器翻译,可能存在错误。
文字稿中没有匹配结果。
引言与监管背景
Claudio Geyken
欢迎收听Smart Charge by RiDERgy播客。我是Claudio Geyken,RiDERgy的创始人兼首席执行官。这档节目专注于探讨能源管理及电动汽车与车队智能充电创新领域的一切话题。
欢迎收听新一期Smart Charge。今天我们邀请到了Andreas Jahn,他是监管援助项目(RAP)的高级研究员,是欧洲在智能能源监管、电力市场改革与电网领域的顶尖专家之一。他拥有超过20年的从业经验,先后供职于德国最早的能源零售商之一Lichtblick、政府部委及行业协会,之后加入RAP,在国际上负责多个重要议题。今天他将带我们揭开能源政策的幕后。为什么灵活性资源往往得不到充分利用?
过时的电网收费机制和监管框架如何阻碍了创新?要让需求侧灵活性、储能以及智能电动汽车和车队充电真正实现规模化,又需要哪些改变?我们还将探讨国际最佳实践、德国的监管瓶颈,以及一个真正面向未来的电力系统应该是什么样的。让我们开始吧。
Claudio Geyken + Andreas Jahn
好的,Andreas,很高兴今天有你加入。你最近怎么样?很高兴来到这里,我状态很好,很期待这次播客。太棒了。在我们开始聊那些关于能源系统和法规的专业话题之前,能先向听众介绍一下自己吗,让大家了解一下Andreas Jahn是谁?当然。我在能源行业已经工作超过20年了。我是从一家能源
Andreas Jahn
零售商起步,后来辗转到了监管机构,在德国政府部委待过一段时间,也在行业协会工作过,现在加入了监管援助项目(RAP)。这一切都是因为当时的政策框架还不够完善,需要随着时间推移不断改进,也因此需要人力资源来推动这项工作。这就是我现在在RAP的原因,致力于完善这一框架,因为改善它能让世界各地都受益,
最终惠及消费者,同时让供给侧为系统做出贡献,助力实现清洁的未来。说得很有道理。往前追溯一步,你是怎么进入能源行业的?是什么吸引了你?其实是自由化的市场。当时有很多就业机会,而我完成
Andreas Jahn + Claudio Geyken
学业之后也不太确定下一步该怎么做,就想着不如试试能源行业,然后我就一直在这里了。那显然是一次很好的市场开放机遇。所以我们说的是2000年前后?对,大约是2000年前后。因为1997年欧盟做出了自由化的决定,但之后也许你可以展开说说,
Andreas Jahn
这个决定传导到德国经历了多长时间,或者你是在哪个节点进入这个行业的,当时的形势是怎样的。对,那确实是一个过程。我们今天所拥有的能源市场,其实主要是由英国推动的,因为英国率先实现了自由化,他们的工业因此获得了更低廉的电价。德国工业界对此非常感兴趣,说,我们也想要
竞争性市场,来降低电价。工业界施加了压力,在这一背景下,当时英国还是欧盟成员国,欧洲内部能源市场主要在布鲁塞尔层面推进,形成了我们现在所有的指导方针和法规体系。那确实是在上个世纪的事了。但最初,德国的情况有些不同。
当时德国没有设立专门的机构来监管能源市场,而是通过参与者之间的协议来推进,由电网协会和行业协会之间协商解决,效力相当有限。那时并没有真正的事前监管,只有事后监管,也就是说,如果你不认同他们达成的协议或当时的合同安排,你只能诉诸法律。这种模式运行了
好几年都不太顺畅。后来,欧盟层面的多数方决定:不行,我们需要更严格的监管,需要一个机构事前设定框架。这个框架涵盖电网的第三方准入,以及费用问题,即电网收费的监管及其背后的方法论。大约在2001年或2002年,监管机构,在此之前只负责
Andreas Jahn + Claudio Geyken
电信和铁路的监管机构,被指定同时承担能源监管职能,并由此负责天然气和电力电网的监管。这就是联邦网络局,德语叫Bundesnetzagentur。对。那么你的第一份工作是在一家新兴的电力公司,是哪家?是Lichtblick。我刚加入的时候感觉就像
Andreas Jahn
跳进了一片未知的水域,但仅仅几周之后,我就已经比所有老牌电网和能源企业都更了解情况了,因为我们想要获得接入机会,而他们从来没有向任何其他供应商提供过接入。那是一段很好的学习经历。过了一段时间,我觉得,好,我可以做这件事了,然后我就有机会来到柏林,加入了
经济部,当时那个部门正在运作,它被称为第三方准入工作组,因为当时还没有监管机构,这也是我后来留在柏林的原因。就在那个时候,如我所说,联邦网络局(BNetzA)正式获得任命。你在部委工作了多长时间?哦,只有一年,但那也是大量的学习,因为那是高度政治性的环境。最后,这个
工作组被解散了,嗯,政治原因吧,就这么说吧。我们被踢出去了,而且不只是我一个人。当时大概有五六个来自行业的人在协助部委做这件事,后来还被调查过,是否属于游说等等,诸如此类。我觉得说实在的,两者都有吧。归根结底是因为德国并没有真正在推动建立一个监管机构。是的,可以说德国
有时候对相关好处很感兴趣,但对于真正建立实现这些好处所需的框架却没那么上心。这大概就是那段需要两三年时间的过渡期。那么在你目前在RAP的职位之前,你还担任过哪些重要职责呢?我在行业协会和零售商那边工作过,后来逐渐转向监管方面,因为在准入和关税监管方面一直存在各种问题,
Andreas Jahn + Claudio Geyken
以及由此衍生出来的种种事务。那段时间我在零售商和协会那边负责监管事务,跟政府部门、监管机构打交道,也参与公开场合的讨论。好的,所以你一直在推动这件事。你从政府部委、行业协会,再到现在的非政府组织,从不同角度审视了监管议题,也就是说,你对
Andreas Jahn
监管这个话题有多元视角,对吗?是的,确实如此。其实这正是我当初思考的出发点,我们只有在框架设计正确、经济激励机制到位的情况下,才能实现系统的高效转型,而那个时候这些条件都不具备。正是在那时,我遇到了现在的同事们。他们说,当然,我们都知道每一项监管都会产生激励,问题在于
Claudio Geyken + Andreas Jahn
这些激励是否真的是你所追求的。好的,我们马上来深入探讨这个问题。在此之前,能否先介绍一下RAP的背景,它的历史、使命,以及你具体负责的工作?当然,感谢你的提问。RAP大约在30年前创立于美国,那时美国的电力市场甚至还没有开放自由化。美国的情况有些特殊,
RAP 的使命与国际视角
Andreas Jahn
那里的监管者是在特定任期内被任命或选举产生的。任期一旦结束,相关知识和经验也随之流失。正因如此,有两位监管者开始思考如何将这些知识留存在整个体系和市场中。于是他们找到了一些资助者,RAP就此以一个项目的形式诞生,这也是我们名称的由来。我们现在的运作方式
在全球各地有所不同。在美国,团队成员更多是前监管委员,而在欧洲,我们团队的背景则更加多元,甚至跨行业,不全是来自电力系统,也不全是监管视角,还涉及交通、供热以及工业领域。我们将工业方向纳入团队,是因为这一切都与电气化息息相关。所以
Andreas Jahn + Claudio Geyken
欧洲的情况确实有所不同。我们也在印度和中国开展工作,但那些体系与欧洲体系差距较大,在我们组织内部,遗憾的是这种差距也同样存在。好的,那外界应该如何理解这样一个组织的角色呢?你们希望实现什么目标?存在的主要意义是什么?我想说,我的目标是
Andreas Jahn
让自己变得多余。我们的核心理念当然是以最低成本实现系统脱碳,也就是推动电气化、建立正确的激励机制,让所有人朝着同一个方向努力。遗憾的是,我们目前还没有做到这一点。这就是我们存在的意义,我们的资金主要来自基金会,有时也来自政府机构的合同委托,但不来自私营部门。当然,我们也与私营
部门、其他非政府组织积极合作,帮助在各个司法管辖区推动议题的公开讨论。我们发现,能源市场乃至监管体系在全球各地高度碎片化,因此借鉴其他地区的经验,了解哪些做法有效,并说明哪些方案可行、哪些已在其他地方得到验证,是非常有价值的。就德国而言,我认为德国人会在改一个句子里的标点之前先做上十项研究,
而其他国家则直接推进试点项目、在实践中摸索,这正是交叉借鉴的意义所在。很有道理。所以你们也在努力将这些不同的最佳实践推广到全球,尤其是在你提到的、你们重点深耕的地区。是的,这也是我特别喜欢做的事情,不断学习,思考如何将这些经验适配到其他司法管辖区。这真的很有意义。现在我们来深入探讨
灵活性与未来电力系统
Andreas Jahn + Claudio Geyken
一些具体案例,或者你认为在这个推动电气化与脱碳的新时代中至关重要的监管议题。你能举一些脑海中浮现的例子吗?当然。我认为首先可以确定的是,脱碳要通过电气化来实现。这大概是过去十年最重要的共识之一,因为在我刚进入这个领域时,这一点并不是不言而喻的。所以这无疑是
Andreas Jahn
一个积极进展,但如何以最低成本实现这一目标,我认为目前还不明朗。举个例子,在深入细节之前,我们需要电网来满足客户的各类需求。这至少是过去百年来能源系统的建设逻辑:服务于用电负荷,因此需要灵活的供给。但这一逻辑已经改变了。随着电气化的推进,随着
供给成本的不断下降,主要是光伏和风电,现在储能和电池也加入其中,这是一个改变系统的巨大机遇。如果我们继续沿用旧有模式,恐怕就难以充分受益。正如大家所知,我们已经拥有灵活性资源,但尚未以最优方式加以利用。嗯。那么释放灵活性的障碍是什么?你又识别出了哪些监管最佳实践?说实话,我们在思路上还没有到位,
我多次探讨过这个问题,许多负责运营或政策监管的人脑子里仍然存在这样一种观念:存在需求,就必须从中央层面来满足这一需求。但未来的系统截然不同,它更加去中心化、更具灵活性,且是双向的,我们可以相互协助,然而无论是实践还是框架,目前都尚未成形。这需要逐步建立;部分工作
在某些司法管辖区确实如此,但首先必须结合当地需求来考量。另一方面,这也正是电力如此特殊的原因:通过跨大区域共享,我们能获得巨大收益。以热能为例,我们不会向千里之外的负荷中心供热,但电力在一定程度上可以做到。在一定程度上,拥有本地资产和
Claudio Geyken + Andreas Jahn
灵活性也很重要,这正是该系统的难点所在,它比旧系统以及其他系统都多了更多维度。也许退一步来看:全球存在不同的监管体系。我们能否划分出不同的区域?有自由化市场,也有非自由化市场。这是否是审视全球各国不同能源监管环境的一个好角度?是的,绝对是,这是个很好的问题,谢谢你提出来。那么,
Andreas Jahn
先从这里说起,以欧洲为例,欧洲内部差异很大,但整体上仍相当同质化。而美国在这方面则大相径庭:既有自由化市场,也有完全受管制的市场。由此我们可以相互学习借鉴。中国当然是完全受管制的,几乎没有任何竞争可言。从全球能源市场来看,我认为有三个阶段。第一阶段,可以
对供给侧进行自由化,并为独立发电商建立第三方准入机制,这通常是第一步。第二步是建立竞争性的批发市场,第三步,也就是"冰淇淋的顶端",是竞争性的零售市场。欧洲已经实现了这一点。但如果你来自一个完全受管制的市场,一开始就不应该直接盯着这个目标看,
国际监管模式
Andreas Jahn + Claudio Geyken
它有其自身的问题,但这三个步骤是清晰的,每一步都需要不同类型的监管框架。可以说英国是在监管框架方面最先进的市场之一吗?其监管框架对新能源世界非常有利?是的,至少在欧洲某些方面是这样,事实上,这也正是
Andreas Jahn
英国脱欧令人遗憾的原因。英国一直在推动欧洲的这一发展进程。如今,嗯,地理上他们仍在欧洲,但已不再是监管与政策制定机制的一部分。但是,举例来说,英国是欧洲第一个为电网运营商建立激励性监管机制的国家。目前已推出了第二版或第三版,为电网运营商的行为设定了详细的
Andreas Jahn + Claudio Geyken
激励措施。这无疑是有帮助的,不只是建立一个最终并不付诸实践的激励框架。当然,欧洲其他地方也有做得不错的,世界其他地区同样如此。好的,让我们深入一些细节。我想列举几个我所了解的维度,希望你能就此发表看法,或者
Claudio Geyken
也许再补充一些。监管框架涉及电网、生产侧以及零售部分。在电网方面,例如,引入更具动态性的电网费用将非常有价值。目前我们仍缺乏能够反映电网拥塞状况、可再生能源出力以及电网容量的动态输配电费结构。未来将会
动态电价与智能充电
Claudio Geyken
有一个有趣的话题,如果你能展开说说:第二点是零售电价在多大程度上走向动态化,走向现货电价,也就是电价每15分钟变动一次。有些市场已经实现了,有些还没有。这将如何影响整体格局、又将如何扩展,我们看到,欧盟自2021年《清洁能源包》起,已明确要求动态电价必须推行。但到底是否需要做到每15分钟一变,
各国是否都会落地执行,还是我们仍处于推进实施的过程中?世界其他国家是否也会关注并效仿?这里举两个例子,第三个例子可能是双向充电,我们看到,对车辆电池的充放电存在电网费用或税收问题,而这往往是释放其价值的根本障碍。那么
Andreas Jahn
还有没有其他你想重点强调的方面,或者你能就我提到的这些做些评论?当然,我很乐意。关于第一点:过去电网是按照负荷来建设的,而非根据电网使用时间来收费,在很多地方这一情况至今仍然如此。这意味着资产所有者,实际上这就是
建设资产的激励所在,也就是扩大资产规模,最终,监管往往提供的激励是去铺一块"铜板"。但我们知道,需求侧是有灵活性可以利用的,如果没有激励,我们也许就不会去利用它,而如果我们都在傍晚下班回家后同时给汽车充电,那就意味着没有人愿意为建设这些电网买单。
最终我们根本负担不起。这就是为什么我们必须考虑灵活性。最初,灵活性是通过批发市场价格引入的,因为我们知道太阳晚上不会发光,这是显而易见的。风能也是波动的,这些都需要体现在电价中,以引导需求跟随负荷调整。但由于能源行业,我认为,过去一直对其原有的收入来源
和"摇钱树"相当满足,加之监管层面缺乏创新动力,这就是为什么欧盟建立了相应框架,并规定,通过这一义务要求,必须提供基于批发市场价格的动态电价,而批发市场价格越来越多地由可再生能源驱动。因此,现在欧洲范围内都有了这一机制,这是好事,但那只是在发电侧。电网方面仍在讨论中,或者说正在推进中。其中一些
欧洲各国已经实行了这种定价机制,或者说大多数国家已经实行了:22个成员国中约有20个已经推行了随时间变化的网络费用。德国今年刚刚对部分用户引入了这一机制,确实如此,而且并非强制性的。所以我们在这方面有些落后,然后我们在德国又面临这样的讨论:如果无法计量、无法测量、无法收费,该如何应对这个系统。希望我们能加快步伐。当然,我们需要智能电表,
Claudio Geyken + Andreas Jahn
以及数字化。我认为我们可以向其他国家学习很多。那么,那些不如英国或其他自由化市场先进的国家,是否在做出调整?全球范围内是否存在监管环境趋于一致的趋势,比如发展中国家?如果从全球来看,我觉得可能存在这样的趋势,但并不那么明显。先从欧盟层面来说,我认为
Andreas Jahn
答案是肯定的。我们可以看到,欧盟层面出台了很多指导方针和法规,但比如网络监管或电价设计方法,这些都由各成员国自行决定。幸运的是,德国现在已将这一职能移交给了BNetzA,即监管机构,而之前只由政府负责,这是向前迈出的一步。而现在我们发现,欧洲因传统不同仍然存在巨大差异:有些国家的做法或者
他们给出的理由,其他国家甚至从未解释过,诸如此类。我们需要更多的协调统一。我们有一个相互联动的批发市场,而且我认为在大多数地方运作良好,但欧洲各地的零售市场差异巨大,这正是企业面临困难的原因。因为你在英国建立了业务,然后进入德国市场,却不知道这里是怎么运作的:我需要了解什么才能开展业务?哪里
有盈利空间?怎样才能从中学习?英国是一个例子,但即便从丹麦到法国也存在巨大差异,这正是欧盟委员会现在推动协调统一的原因。例如,他们预计本月会发布相关指导方针,我想他们已经承诺过,关于网络电价的指导方针。很有意思。是的,SMARD也有很好的概览,我认为他们在不同国家网络电价监管框架方面也有很好的
电网投资与电网容量
Claudio Geyken + Andreas Jahn
概览。是的,确实如此。还有一点补充:这并不是欧盟委员会的官方指导方针,目前只是一项建议,但他们公开表示:如果没有人理会这个建议,我们可能会进一步考虑。有道理。说到电网电价,对于电动汽车来说,是否也存在充电容量不够高的障碍?在
Claudio Geyken
不同站点,以及接入电网所涉及的高额电网费用。您认为这种情况会改变吗?从监管角度来看,是否有相关举措正在推进?您认为,让更多企业转向电动车辆、同时避免支付这些巨额电网扩容费用,最佳路径是什么?是的,在这方面德国走在前列。德国有大量研究
Andreas Jahn
分析了如果要实现能源转型目标,电网投资方面可能面临的挑战。研究显示,未来20年仅在电网方面就需要投入约7000亿欧元。我认为这个数字太高了。但问题在于:这些数字从何而来?我认为完全有机会将实际投入压缩到远低于这个水平。但我们必须思考
如何更智慧地利用现有资源。例如,有些地方已经出台了相关法规,将电网利用率纳入对运营商的激励机制。我认为这是一个很好的做法,电网运营商可以说,在投资新变电站之前,也许可以通过激励用户避开用电高峰来规避投资。通过这种方式,
Claudio Geyken
我们或许可以大幅削减这些预测中的投资需求。您也提到了电网费用的动态化趋势,德国的§14a EnWG正在推进这一方向,这主要适用于低压层面,而非中压。德国还有所谓的"atypische Netznutzung"(非典型电网使用)以及StromNEV §19。中压层面是否也会迎来大量变革?我们谈的是车队,越来越多的电动卡车也将从这些激励政策中受益。
Andreas Jahn
是的,肯定会。关于您之前提到的系统接入成本问题,比如德国的Baukostenzuschuss(建设成本分摊),我认为这些都源自旧有体系,即向用户收取接入费用。但在我看来,这并不是核心问题;关键在于我们如何使用这个系统。
我们应该按照实际接入成本为所有希望接入的用户提供接入,但其他费用应基于对系统的使用方式来收取。如果我想在用电高峰期使用系统,当然应该为此付费。最终,如果你能避免欧洲或德国冬季傍晚时段通常出现的用电需求,你就能真正获得价值。而
Claudio Geyken + Andreas Jahn
在阳光充足的正午使用电网成本很低,我们不应该在那个时段向用电需求收取高额费用来加以限制。有道理。所以您也是在指这样一种费用结构,它根据您产生的峰值用电来收费,但并不区分时间段,不管您在哪个时间产生峰值都无差别。但我们应该关注峰值是在什么时间产生的:
Andreas Jahn
如果当时电网并不拥堵,那问题不大;但如果正值拥堵,问题就严重多了,对吧?对。关键在于,监管机制应该提前提供相应的激励信号。这就是为什么我们需要提前定价,如果等到第二天才告诉用户,昨天充电因为赶上用电高峰,花掉了他们全年的度假预算,这对用户毫无帮助。他们应该提前获得某种激励或者
双向充电与市场设计
Andreas Jahn
提示,以便提前做出调整。这才是我们真正需要的。未来的电力系统主要由天气条件驱动,风能、太阳能和气温,当然也受我们的行为影响,比如是节假日还是工作日,这些因素同样重要,而且都可以提前24小时预知。正是这样。我看到你和RAP联合发布了几份很有意思的案例研究,一份叫做《欧洲电动汽车和卡车smart charging的节省效益》,以法国为案例,另一份是《释放灵活性:消除demand response壁垒的无悔行动》,面向欧洲各国监管机构NRA。我记得你还参加了一场双向充电活动,在那里见到了Habeck,那是一段时间前的事了。在这所有工作中,有哪些亮点是你想和听众分享的?你有什么感悟?我觉得最大的亮点是:我们
Claudio Geyken
正走在正确的轨道上。听到例如Habeck已经意识到这不仅仅是充电,而是双向充电,这是一个巨大的机遇,我们应该为此铺上红地毯,这让人感到振奋。虽然目前还没有完全实现,至少并非所有地方都做到了,但我仍然看到我们在向前推进。我们谈论双向充电已经有相当长一段时间了,所以也许
Andreas Jahn
像你所看到的那次与Habeck的会面,一位非常有影响力的政治人物,至少是身处要职的人,将这个议题列为重要日程,是很有意义的。但我们仍然没有看到进展像我们期望的那样快。你怎么看待为什么这需要这么长时间?我认为我们仍然被旧有思维所束缚,电网运营商也好,
Claudio Geyken
公用事业公司也好,他们的经营模式和收入来源都是这样建立起来的,而这在一定程度上也是由监管机制驱动的。所以他们首先关注的是受其监管的对象,而没有考虑未来的系统可以是什么样的、应该是什么样的,以及我们如何实现最低成本。这种前瞻性思维并不总是存在的。回到双向充电这个话题,它确实非常复杂,因为我们在整个系统中承担着相应的责任。
Andreas Jahn
我们不希望遭遇停电,就像最近西班牙和葡萄牙发生的那样。因此,我们需要对接入系统的所有这些小型资产负责,让它们汇聚成规模,发挥出有益于所有人的价值。但我们至少需要部分掌握你什么时候给车充电的信息。为此我们需要相应的IT架构,需要协调机制,需要信息共享和透明度,所有这些都缺一不可。我认为目前,当
我们不想经历停电,就像最近西班牙和葡萄牙发生的那样。因此,我们需要对系统中所有这些接入的微小资产负责,将它们整合成规模庞大、对所有人都有价值有益的整体。但我们至少需要在一定程度上掌握你什么时候给车充电的信息。我们需要相应的IT架构,需要协调机制,需要信息共享和透明度,所有这些都是必不可少的。我认为现在仍然,当
Claudio Geyken + Andreas Jahn
我开始工作时也是如此,放眼海外是有帮助的。这在能源行业如此,对我们的整个生活也是如此,看看自己习以为常的事物之外,总是有益的。是的,这让我想起了我喜欢用的一个概念。有"软件定义汽车"这个说法,我认为能源领域也是"软件定义能源"。正如你在开头也提到的,软件世界在过去并没有像今天这样深度融入能源系统的运作方式,这要求传统参与者采用全新的运营方式。比如,电网运营商在想:好,电动汽车有巨大的潜力,这些电池储能我们可以用来平衡系统。他们的想法是:我想调度这些资源,让我的系统成本更低,但他们没有去问消费者。我不是说我们
Andreas Jahn
必须先问消费者,但我们必须制定合理的价格机制。如果我们说,好,现在成本很高,那么市场上就会出现供应商、聚合商、零售商,他们会向消费者提供产品,他们必须说服消费者接受这些产品。然后他们就能帮助系统、帮助电网运营商找到最低成本的解决方案。但这样一来,主动权就在消费者
和市场手中了。所以有时候,当价格机制到位时,市场的表现还是让我感到惊喜,这很好。当有人问我这会是什么样子时,我说:我手机上有各种app,我不知道它们是怎么运作的,但如果它们能告诉我正确的信息,我就可以做出决定,或者调整设置让它们自动做出正确的事,而不需要我每5分钟看一次手机。这就是我们所需要的,
而且我不需要自己来搭建这一切。我唯一知道的是,我们必须把价格定对。如果我们给出错误的价格激励,人们就不会做出最优的选择。是的,换句话说,我们需要电网运营商和能源公司制定合理的价格结构,然后让市场完成其余的事,没错,从我的角度来看就是这样。但德国
有将近900家配电网运营商。我不会说他们已经真正实现数字化了。他们还没有部署智能电表,你要跟他们谈电网的时变电价,他们会说:哦哇,这听起来很高端。那动态电价呢?天哪。
所以这方面我们可以加快步伐。是的,我同意。那么对于电动车队来说,因为这也涉及很多电动车队和smart charging,你预见在未来几年车队电动化会面临哪些挑战?你建议用什么方式来应对这些挑战?首先,我认为车队比私家车在私人住宅中的场景要容易得多。车队容易得多,因为你知道
车队充电与电动卡车
Claudio Geyken + Andreas Jahn
我从事这份工作时也是如此,放眼海外是很有帮助的。这不仅适用于能源行业,对我们整个生活都适用,看看自己习以为常的事物之外的东西,总是有益的。是的,这让我想起了我喜欢用的一个概念。有"软件定义汽车"这个说法,我认为能源领域也是"软件定义能源"。正如你在开头也提到的,软件世界在过去并没有像今天这样深度融入能源系统的运作方式,这要求传统参与者采用全新的运营模式。比如,电网运营商在想:好,电动汽车有巨大潜力,这些电池储能可以用来平衡系统。他们的想法是:我想调度这些资源,让我的系统成本更低,但他们没有去问消费者。我不是说我们
Andreas Jahn
通常,他们在何时何地驾驶是有规律可循的。你有一些固定的充电地点,可以先对充电基础设施进行优化调整,再结合批发或零售市场以及电网进行价格优化。因此,这里存在巨大的潜力,而且双向充电在这里也更容易起步。电网接入系统的连接通常是灵活性投资中成本最高的部分,这也是为什么很多人
对安装更大容量的系统连接犹豫不决。但我的观点是:尽量把容量做大,同时配套制定合理的运营价格。在此基础上,车队的双向充电是第一步,之后再逐步推广到私人家庭,或者说公寓楼和路边停车充电场景。有道理。那么,你在不同类型的车队之间是否有所区分,觉得某些类型的车队
潜力更大?我认为这取决于规模经济。规模越大,越容易起步。如果你运营的是DHL这样体量的企业,那当然和我家附近那种只有3辆车的小型配送业务完全不同。这也和你拥有多少场站充电能力密切相关。如果你能至少部分依赖夜间充电,
那么你的灵活性就比那些长途运营、依赖快充的车队要强得多。我们看到,一辆卡车在高速公路上全速行驶四五个小时后再用35分钟快速补电,这种充电方式成本更高,而且灵活性很低。但两者结合起来,才是企业真正受益的所在。
Claudio Geyken
有道理。说到当下,电动卡车是一个非常热门的话题,它们发展越来越快,势头强劲,尽管过去几年起步时份额还很小,但现在真的在快速提速。我认为到2030年,欧洲新售卡车中有三分之一将是电动卡车,这是目标。你对电动卡车未来面临的挑战和机遇有什么看法?
Andreas Jahn
电动卡车?我认为这一领域的发展会比私家车市场更顺畅。我们在私家车领域看到了太多的起伏波折,但卡车是纯商业用途,所以关键在于TCO,也就是总拥有成本。这也是我们从制造商那里听到的声音:卡车会有的,会被卖出去,会被使用,没有人愿意因为缺少充电设施,让科隆的草莓
没法配送到慕尼黑。这是我们可以预见的未来走向。但另一方面,我们也看到,按照过去几十年的老路子建设电网连接,一个需要接入高压线路的快充站,建设周期几乎长达十年。而汽车或卡车制造商的速度要快得多。是的,所以高
压线路的建设需要加速推进,才能承载所有这些新增容量,对吧?对,没错。而且市场即便在基础设施有限、存在拥塞的情况下也能运转,但关键是要建立正确的激励机制:让人们把充电基础设施建在合适的地方,在容量充足或电价低廉的时候使用电力。总之,就是充分利用现有资源,避免不必要或可以规避的投资。有道理。
消费者参与与结束语
Andreas Jahn + Claudio Geyken
你还有什么想对播客听众说的,有没有什么重要的观点,是你觉得在我们今天触及的这些广泛话题中特别值得关注的?我想说的是:积极参与这个系统,因为它和过去不同了,过去消费者只是被动用电,现在消费者可以主动行动。不管是从阳台光伏板开始,还是用你的车、热泵、储能电池,随便什么方式。我认为
Claudio Geyken + Andreas Jahn
这首先带来的是更强的独立性和系统韧性,对有些人来说可能纯粹是兴趣爱好,不管是哪种动机,都值得去尝试。很好,确实如此,所谓"产消者",也是一个常见说法,和过去相比,它可以发挥更大的作用,过去这个角色可能相当单调。挑战有,机遇也很多。确实。最后,人们如何能进一步了解你或你的工作,或者有问题时如何联系你?当然,我在社交
Andreas Jahn + Claudio Geyken
媒体上都有,比如LinkedIn或Bluesky,可以在那里找到我,或者访问raponline.org,上面有我们在全球和本地所做工作的所有信息,包括行业侧、脱碳,以及供热等方面,它们也各有各的挑战。非常好。感谢Andreas,祝你今天余下的时间也愉快。谢谢,很高兴来到这里。今天这期节目邀请到了来自RAP(即监管援助项目)的Andreas Jahn,非常精彩。我的几点主要收获是:
Claudio Geyken
不同市场和地区之间存在若干差异。我们看到有自由化市场和非自由化市场,英国走在最前沿,美国是混合体系,欧盟相对统一协调,但各市场的监管质量参差不齐。电网费用是一个非常重要的议题,其结构方式,或者说税费和电网费的结构方式,正在阻碍双向充电的发展。传统市场参与者普遍缺乏软件能力,难以支撑这类商业模式的落地。我们还看到
世界正在变得越来越协调统一,变化速度也越来越快,要知道,25年前欧洲几乎没有自由化电力市场,而市场自由化带来的成本优势推动了这一转变。"灵活性"这个关键词在很大程度上也受到监管的塑造,这也正是RAP从创立之初的核心目标:通过完善的监管框架,确保能源转型以具有成本效益的方式推进。而他们在全球范围内推动这一工作,令人着迷,因为他们
他可能是为数不多的几个对监管框架有如此深刻理解、并致力于在不同市场间分享最佳实践的机构之一。他还将车队定性为一种可规划的灵活性资源,既可用于单向smart charging,也可用于双向充电。他最后的建议是:无论作为prosumer还是主动参与者,都应积极投身其中,努力改善这个系统。感谢您的收听,请为我们留下评价,关注我们,给我们五星好评,那就太棒了,
也请把这期节目分享给可能感兴趣的朋友。我们下期再见。
引言与监管背景
Claudio Geyken
Welcome to the Smart Charge by RiDERgy podcast. This is Claudio Gaikin, founder and CEO of RiDERgy. This is your show to learn about all things energy management and smart charging, innovation for electric vehicles and fleets. Welcome to a new episode of Smart Charge.
Today we're joined by Andreas Jan, senior associate at the Regulatory Assistance Project, one of Europe's leading experts when it comes to smart energy regulation in power market reform and grids. He has over 20 years of experience joining Licht Blick, one of the first utilities in Germany, then the government, the ministries and associations, and then with the RAP being responsible for several topics internationally.
He takes us behind the curtain of energy policy. Why does flexibility often remain untapped? How do outdated network tariffs and regulatory frameworks stand in the way of innovation? And what needs to change so that demand side flexibility, storage and smart EV and fleet charging can truly scale? We also take a look at international best practices, Germany's regulatory bottlenecks, and what a truly future proof electricity system could look like.
Let's dive in. All right, Andreas, nice to have you today. How are you doing?
Andreas Jahn
Hi, great to be here. So, yeah, I'm doing well and looking forward to that interview or to that podcast.
Claudio Geyken
Awesome.
Claudio Geyken
Yeah.
Claudio Geyken
Before we start talking about geeky energy systems topics and regulations, etc. For the listeners, can you introduce yourself so that they know who Andreas Jan is?
Andreas Jahn
Yeah, sure.
Andreas Jahn
So actually I'm in the energy business since, what is that, more than 20 years now. I started with an energy retailer in the first and ended up with regulatory authorities. So with the ministry in Germany, I've been for a while with associations and now with a regulatory assistant project.
And actually that all of that happened because the framework wasn't set proper by then and developed over time and obviously resources or human resources has been required to add to that. And that's why I'm now with the regulatory system project or called Rep, to improve that because there are benefits across the world to improve the framework and at the end the benefits consumers and supply can contribute to the system and to the future.
Actually to a clean future in this regard.
Claudio Geyken
Makes sense.
Claudio Geyken
And one step back, how did you get into the energy system? What drew you to that?
Andreas Jahn
Well, actually the first was it was liberalized the market and there has been plenty of jobs offered and I did not know by detail what to do with my finalization of my studies and I said let's try the energy business and that's where I'm still. So obviously it was a good market opening by then,.
Claudio Geyken
So we're talking before 1997, right?
Andreas Jahn
No, not that long. That was about 2000. So that was.
Claudio Geyken
Because in 1997 that's when I think in the EU the decision for the liberalization was done. But then maybe you can elaborate a bit on how long it took then for it to arrive in Germany, or at which point you exactly entered and what the situation was.
Andreas Jahn
Right.
Andreas Jahn
So there was actually indeed a process and why we have energy markets today that was actually driven in Europe mostly by the UK because they liberalized in the first and the industry got cheaper electricity prices. And the German industry was keen about that and said, well, we want to have competitive markets as well if we can get the prices down. So and that was why there was pressure from the industry.
And with that, by then, when the UK was still part of the eu, then they developed in Brussels mostly then the energy market, the internal energy market for Europe, with all these guidelines and regulations we have in place now, that was indeed in the last millennium, but in the first it was in Germany, let's say a bit different. There wasn't an authority pointed out to regulate the energy market.
It was driven by agreements of the participants of the associations, actually of network associations, of industry associations. And that was quite weak. It wasn't really any ex ante regulation, it was only ex post.
So what means you can go to court if you don't agree to what they figured out and what the contract situation is or was by then, and it didn't work out well for a couple of years and then the majority on the EU level decided, no, we need a stricter regulation, we need an authority. What is setting up ex ante the framework. And the framework is the access, third party access to the network and the other is the costs.
So the regulation of network fees and the methodology in behind. And that was then by 2001 or 2002, I think the regulator until then it was only the Telecommunication and Railway Authority has been appointed to become the energy regulator as well. And with that they are responsible now for the grids of gas and electricity. So since, and that is a bit more than 20 years,.
Claudio Geyken
The federal Network Agency or Bundesnetzagentur in German. Right,. All right. And so you started with the first job was at a new electric utility called. Which one was it?
Andreas Jahn
Right.
Andreas Jahn
It was Lichtplik by then, when I started. And well, it was like jumping into what is this unknown water. But after just a few weeks I've been ahead of all the established network or energy utilities, because we wanted to get access and they never Provided access to any kind of other supplier. So that was, yeah, great learning. And after a while I said, yeah, okay, so I can do that.
And then I got the opportunity to come to Berlin with the Ministry of Economics, which had been operating by then. It has been called a task force for third party access because there wasn't a regulatory authority. And that's why I'm in Berlin still. And that was the time, as I said, when the BNHR has been appointed.
Claudio Geyken
And for how long did you work at the ministry then after that?
Andreas Jahn
Oh yeah, yeah, that was only a year. But that was much more learning as well because it was highly political. At the end, this task force has been quit because, well, political issues, let's say, and we've been kicked out. So it wasn't just me, there had been five or six from the industry helping the ministry with that and there has been investigations on that later, even if that has been lobbying etc and all that. So I would say it was in between.
It was because Germany wasn't really driving that forward to have an authority. It was, yeah, let's say Germany is sometimes keen about the benefits, but not that keen about really to establish the framework to achieve. And that was probably the two or three year time period that has been required.
Claudio Geyken
And what were the other key responsibilities you had before now, the current one with era?
Andreas Jahn
Well, I've been with associations and retailers and then it became more to be on the regulatory side because there has been always issues on the excess and on the regulation of the tariffs and what came with all of that and that it has been with them on, with retailers and with the associations on the regulatory side. So to talk with the ministry with a regulator in the public as well.
Claudio Geyken
Okay, so you.
Andreas Jahn
Drive that forward.
Claudio Geyken
You saw the topic of regulations both from a ministry, then from an association and then now as an ngo one could say. So you have different viewpoints on the topic of regulations, right?
Andreas Jahn
Yes.
Andreas Jahn
Yes, indeed.
Andreas Jahn
And actually that was the initial point when I've been thinking about, well, we can only achieve an efficient transformation of the system if the framework is setting right, if the incentives for the economy are there. And that wasn't by then. And that was when I met Michael, today's colleagues. They said, yeah, of course we do need. We know that every regulation is setting incentives. The other question is if these are the incentives you are up for.
Claudio Geyken
Okay, yeah, we'll dive into that question in a second before doing that. What's the. Maybe you can give some background on the rap. What's the background? The history behind it, the mission and your then concrete responsibilities.
RAP 的使命与国际视角
Andreas Jahn
Sure.
Andreas Jahn
Thanks.
Andreas Jahn
Rep has been founded already 30 years ago, I think. Yeah. In the U.S. that was even before the markets in the U.S. has been liberalized. In the U.S. it's a bit different in that way that the regulators are appointed or elected for a period of time only. And when the time end the knowledge is gone with the person. And that's why two regulators had been thinking about by then how to keep the knowledge in the system, in the market.
And that's when they found some other guys to finance that. And that's when REP became a project. And that's what we are still named for. And we are operating in a bit different way globally. So in the US it's more that they are former commissioner working while it is in Europe for example. It is more that there are other experience in our team as well. And even cross sectoral more.
It's not all from the power system and not all from the regulatory perspective. It is as well from transport perspective perspective, from a heat perspectives and industry what we added to the team because it's all on the electrification side. So that is why Europe is a bit different. We're working and we are as well in India and China.
But I would say these systems are much further away than the US from at least from the European system and within our organization unfortunately too.
Claudio Geyken
Okay, and how can one imagine the role of such an organization? What do you aim to achieve? What are the main goals and reasons to exist, so to say?
Andreas Jahn
Well, actually I would say to make myself useless. Well, the idea is of course to decarbonize the system by lowest costs. And that means to electrify, setting the right incentives that all folks running into the same direction. But unfortunately we are not doing yet. So that is what we are financed for by foundations mostly, sometimes by contracts from authorities, but not from the private sector.
How we are engaging, but of course we are engaging as well with the private sector, with other NGOs and helping to making things public in one jurisdiction. But what we found out that the energy markets and even the regulation is very fragmented across the world. And that it is very helpful to have examples from elsewhere how things do work and to explain what we can do and what has been proved elsewhere.
And I would say yeah, mostly in the German context it is that Germany is running 10 studies before they are changing a dot in the sentence while others are just running pilot projects and figuring things out. And that's why it is cross fertilization of that.
Claudio Geyken
Makes sense.
Claudio Geyken
So you try to spread these different best practices across the world as well in the regions you named and operate especially.
灵活性与未来电力系统
Andreas Jahn
Yes, yes.
Andreas Jahn
And actually this is what I like to do. It is to learn and to think about how this can be adapted to another jurisdictions. That is actually great.
Claudio Geyken
And let's dive into some examples or also topics of regulations that you think are key in this new world to enable electrification and decarbonization. Maybe you can give some examples that come to mind.
Andreas Jahn
Sure.
Andreas Jahn
So yeah, I think the first it is that we know that decarbonization works through electrification. This is one probably of the biggest achievements over the last decade, because that wasn't clear on the 1st when I started in that field. So that is definitely good. But that means how to achieve that by lowest cost. That is, I would say unclear. And for example, it is still. And then we're diving much more into the details.
It is, yeah, we need grids to serve the customers for all the needs they do have. That is at least how the energy system has been built over the last century to serve the load. So we need flexible supply. But that has been changed with the electrification, with the decreasing costs of supply, mostly of PV and of wind and now of storage as well of the batteries. So that is a huge change chance to change the system.
If we continue in the old fashioned, it is probably not that beneficial. So as we all know, we have flexibility, but we are using not the flexibility in the best manner yet.
Claudio Geyken
So what are the hurdles for unleashing flexibility and regulatory best practices that you have identified.
Andreas Jahn
The thinking?
Andreas Jahn
Actually we are not there yet. So I explored that a couple of times that quite a lot of people, their responsibility for operations, for even policies on regulation, they all still have in mind. There's a need and we have to serve the need from a central perspective. But the system of the future is so different. It is much more decentralized. It is flexible and bi directional and we can help each other with that. But that isn't there nor the framework.
It has to be developed partially. It is in some jurisdictions, but it has been combined for the needs of local needs in the first. But on the other hand, that is why electricity is so special. We have a huge benefit by sharing across huge regions. So let's say for heat we don't supply, let's say a load pocket what is 1,000 miles away. But on electricity that might make sense to some extent.
To some extent it is good to have local assets and flexibility as well. And that is the difficulty of the system that has more dimensions than the Old system and other systems as well.
Claudio Geyken
And maybe one step back, there is different regulatory systems across the world. Can we create pockets? There's liberalized markets and non liberalized markets. Is that a good way to look at the different energy regulatory environments, own countries in the world?
Andreas Jahn
Yes, definitely.
Andreas Jahn
That is very good question. Thanks for that. So that is. Yeah. And to start with that, Europe for example, it has huge differences, but it is still very homogeneous. So let's say the US for example is very different in this regard. They have liberalized markets, but they have fully regulated markets as well. And with that we can learn from that. While of course China is totally regulated, there is more or less no competition at all.
And looking at energy markets globally, we have I would say three steps. So in the first you can liberalize the supply side, you can set up a third party access by independent power producers. So that is usually the first step. Then as the second you can set up wholesale markets, competitive wholesale markets. And the third is the top of the ice cream is then the competitive retail market. We do have that in Europe.
But I would say if you're coming from a totally regulated market market, you shouldn't look up at that in the first. So it has its issues. But let's say these are the three steps and for each of that you need different kind of framework of regulation. What you do and how.
国际监管模式
Claudio Geyken
Is it fair to say that the UK is among the most advanced systems in terms of a regulatory framework that is very favorable to the new energy world?
Andreas Jahn
Yeah, at least in Europe it has in some regards. And actually that's why it's a pity that the UK left the eu. They have been driving that development in Europe now. Well, they are still in Europe, but not of the regulatory and policy making machine anymore. But yeah, that was of the prices and of the regulation. And let's say for example in Europe the UK was the first state they established an incentive based regulation for the network operators.
It's the second or third edition what they established now setting detailed incentives that the network operators doing X, Y and Z. That is definitely helpful, not just having a framework. What is providing incentives you are not up for in the end. But there are other places as well. They have things done well in Europe, but of course elsewhere in the world too.
Claudio Geyken
Right, let's get a bit more in the details. So just to name a few of the dimensions that I am aware of that I would love to have you comment or maybe compliment on them. So there's the grids, then there's the production and there's the retail part in the regulatory frameworks, in the grids part, for example, having more dynamic grid fees would be very fruitful for that.
动态电价与智能充电
Claudio Geyken
We have a lack still of dynamic tariffs in the grid fee structure that reflects the availability of congestion in the grids or the availability of renewables and so the capacity of these grids. There will be one interesting topic if you, if you can elaborate. Then the second is to what extent the retail tariffs dynamic going to the spot spot tariffs where you have 15 minutes changes of electricity tariff. But some markets have them, some don't. Yeah.
So how that impacts and how it will spread. And we see that the EU has with a clean energy package since 2021 mandated that dynamic terrorists need to come to what extent do they have to be every 15 minutes and everybody will implement them. We're still in the process of implementing them. And other countries would take take notice as well in the world and copy that.
So just to give two examples and then a third one maybe is bi directional charging where we see that there is grid fees or taxes involved with charging and discharging a battery in a vehicle. And then oftentimes this is a fundamental hurdle for that value to be unleashed. So are there others that you would highlight or would you comment on the ones I mentioned?
Andreas Jahn
Yeah, sure, I'd like to definitely. So in the first it is the networks. In the past they had been built for the load and not charged on the time when the networks has been used. And that is in quite a lot of places still the truth. What means that they are asset owners. And actually that is the incentives to build assets. So to extend the asset base at the end, that is what regulation provides quite often is building a copper plate.
But we now at the end with flexibility we do have on the demand side and we can use or if we are not incentivized, maybe we are not using. And if we are all plugging in our car in the evening by returning back home from work, that means to build these networks no one is up for we can't afford at the end. So that is why we have to think about the flexibility.
And in the first, the flexibility came into play by the wholesale market prices because we know the sun is not shining in the night. Obviously wind is fluctuating as well. And that need to be reflected in tariffs to adjust the demand for the first time to the load. But since the industry, the energy industry, I would say has been quite comfortable with the former revenue streams with their cash cows and the regulation there was not much Innovation.
And that's why the EU set up the framework with this obligation you have to offer and dynamic tariff based on the wholesale market price. What is driven more from the renewables. So that is good at the end that we do have that now across Europe, but that is only then on the generation side and the networks that is still in the discussion or in the making. Let's say that some of the European countries do have that pricing already.
Or let's say it's a majority. What has that about 20, 22 member states do have time varying network fees in place. Germany just introduced this year. For some customers. Indeed, indeed. And it is not mandatory. So that is we are a bit behind. And then we have the discussion in Germany. How can you deal with the system if you can't meter, if you can't measure, if you can't charge? Well, hopefully we're speeding up.
Claudio Geyken
Right.
Andreas Jahn
Of course we need smart meters, digitalization. Well, I would say we can learn a lot from others.
Claudio Geyken
And are the countries that are not as advanced as other countries in terms of like the UK or other liberalized markets, are they adjusting? Is there a trend to. For the world to harmonize regulatory environments, say developing countries, for example?
Andreas Jahn
If it's globally, I would say there's a. Yeah, maybe a trend, but it is not so obvious. Let's say in the first to the eu I would say yes. So we have seen for example that there are a lot of guidelines on the EU level and regulation. But for example the network regulation or the methodologies of the tariff design, they are all with the member states. Luckily Germany moved that now to the bnhr, to the regulator. What was before with the government only.
So that is a step forward. And now we are figuring out that Europe is still so diverse by tradition. Somehow what the countries did or what they explained, why they are doing, others didn't even explain or whatever that we need more harmonization. So we have a wholesale market. What is interacting, I would say in most places in a good way. But the retail markets across Europe are so different. And that is why businesses are struggling with that.
Because you establish in the UK and then you're stepping into the German market and wondering about how is that working out? What do I have to know to establish a business? Where is a revenue stream within that ama? How can I learn from that? So that is the uk, but that is even, let's say from Denmark to France. There are huge differences. And that is why the commission is pushing for that now. For example, they will come up this month.
电网投资与电网容量
Andreas Jahn
I Think they promised to do with guidelines on the network tariffs.
Claudio Geyken
Interesting.
Claudio Geyken
Yeah.
Claudio Geyken
There is also a good overview by Smart and I think they also have good overviews on the regulatory frameworks of different countries with network tariffs.
Andreas Jahn
Yeah, indeed.
Andreas Jahn
And sorry one is not an official guideline by the commission. It is a suggestion and the first but they said in public. Well if no one is listening to a suggestion we are providing we might think further. So.
Claudio Geyken
Makes sense.
Claudio Geyken
And talking about the grid tariffs is there also one hurdle for electric vehicles in particular is also having higher enough capacity to charge at different sites. And there's a huge also grid fees related to connecting to the grid.
Is that something that you see will change or is there something in the making as well from a regulatory standpoint, what's your view on what should be the best way to enable as well more companies to move to electric vehicles without being forced to pay this massive amount of grid reinforcement fees?
Andreas Jahn
Yes, so that is. And in this regard Germany is in the forefront. Germany has a lot of studies what we might face of grid investments if we want to fulfill our transitional targets. And we learned this might or it should be about 700 billion euros in the next 20 years. What we have to invest in the networks only.
Claudio Geyken
It's a lot.
Andreas Jahn
And yeah I would say it is too much even. But the question is where these numbers coming from. And I would say there's a huge chance to deal with much less than that. But we have to make that to think about how can we be smarter and to use what we have in a better way. And for example some places do have regulations in place where the utilization of of the network is part of the incentive given to the operators.
And I think this is a very good thing that the network operator can say yeah, before I'm investing into a new substation maybe I can give an incentive to the users to avoid the peak hours to avoid the investments and by doing so that is probably that we can cut off a lot of these predicted investments.
Claudio Geyken
Right.
Claudio Geyken
And you see you mentioned already the grid fees being more dynamic and coming in in Germany with the NVG14A that's more for the very, very low voltage then for the medium voltage. There's in Germany at least there's a so called 19 is is there going to be a lot of changes related also to medium voltages. We're talking fluid fleets. It's going to be more and more electric trucks that will have also that incentive.
Andreas Jahn
Yeah, definitely.
Andreas Jahn
And to your previous question you asked because of the cost to build up for the interconnection to the system and baukos and for example, what is what we have in Germany. And I would say this is all still from the old system. We are charging the people to connect. But from my perspective that is not the crucial issue. It is how we use the system. Yeah, we should connect everyone who want to be connected by the costs, what the interconnection is.
Claudio Geyken
Operational.
Andreas Jahn
But everything else is for the use of the system. If I want to use the system at peak times, of course I have to be charged for. And at the end I would say a candlelight dinner. Get a real value by doing so. If you avoid the demand, what is usually in Europe and Germany in the winter evenings, while it is quite cheap to use a network by noon when the sun is shining. And we shouldn't penalize the demand by charging a car in that moment of time.
Claudio Geyken
Makes sense.
Claudio Geyken
Yeah, yeah.
Claudio Geyken
So that's.
Claudio Geyken
You're referring as well to the fee structure. Now that penalizes based on the peak you generate, but not. You don't determine which time. It doesn't matter which time you generate the peak. But we should measure which time it was that you generated the peak when if the network is not congested at that time, it's not a big problem. Whereas if it was congested, it's a bigger problem. Right,.
Andreas Jahn
Right.
Andreas Jahn
And the point is regulation is or should provide the incentives ahead. That is why we need the pricing ahead. It's not helpful for a customer as us if we informed the day after that the charging I did yesterday is instead of my annual vacation because it was a peak time, I should get a kind of incentive or information ahead of that to avoid that. And that's actually what we need.
双向充电与市场设计
Andreas Jahn
And since the future system is driven mostly by the weather conditions, so of wind, of sun and of temperatures and of course of our behavior. Is it a holiday or is this a weekday? That matters as well. And that is known 24 hours ahead.
Claudio Geyken
Exactly.
Claudio Geyken
I've seen you published a few interesting case studies with rap. One is called the savings from smart charging electric cars and trucks in Europe. A case study for France or another one is unlocking flexibility. No regret actions to remove barriers to demand response addressed to Asser. So the regulators in Europe and I think you also met Habeck at the bidirectional event. That was a while back out of all these work.
Is there a few highlights you would like to share as well with the audience or takeaways from your side?
Andreas Jahn
I would say that the highlight is we on the right track and it is good to hear for example what you mentioned that Harbig has been aware about that it's not just charging, it is bi directional charging. That is a huge chance and we should roll out the red carpet for that. It isn't there yet, at least not in all places. But this is what I still. Yeah seeing we are moving forward.
Claudio Geyken
We have been talking about bi directional charging also quite some time. So from also maybe a meeting like, like the one you, you saw with Harbeck that was very much a powerful politician, at least in a powerful role, taking that topic in his agenda, very higher up in the agenda but still we are not seeing as fast progress as we would like to have. What's your take on why does it take so long?
Andreas Jahn
I would say we are still locked in the old thinking. That is I would say with network operators, with utilities, how they have been established and what their revenue streams are and that is even partially with the regulation. So they are looking at the ones they are regulating and the first and not having in mind how a future system could look like or should look like and how we can achieve police costs. So that is not always there yet.
And to come back to that, the bi directional charging that is definitely. It is complex because we have responsibilities in the system. We don't want to face a blackout as it happened recently in, in Spain and Portugal. And therefore we need responsibility for all these tiny assets connected to the system and making it big and useful and beneficial to all.
But we have to know when you charge your car at least partially and we need IT structures for that. We need coordination, we need information transparency for example, all of that. And that is I think it is still when I started my job with Web, it's still the same. Looking across borders is helpful. It is in the energy business, but it is for our entire life. It is helpful to see something else than the things you are used to.
Claudio Geyken
Yeah, that goes back to one of the the things other words concepts I like to use. There's software defined vehicles and I think the energy sector is also software defined energy. And the as you also highlighted in the beginning, the software world was not ingrained in the way the energy system operated in the past as much as it today. And this requires a complete new way of operating right from traditional players.
Andreas Jahn
Right.
Andreas Jahn
And it is when let's say network operators thinking about well there's a huge potential of the EVs, of all this battery huge storage we can use to balance the system, they're thinking is I want to operate these resources to make my system cheaper. But they are not asking the customers for. I wouldn't say that we have to ask the customers for in the first, but we have to put the right places in place.
So if we say yeah, if it costs a lot right now, then there will be market providers, aggregators, suppliers, they will come up with offers to the customers and they have to convince the customers to their products and then they can help the system, the network operators to come up with the cheapest and solution we opt for. But with that it is up to the customer and to the market.
So sometimes I'm surprised still by learning what markets are doing if they are the right prices. And that is great. So when I've been asked how can that look like, I say, well, I have apps on my phone, I don't know how they do work, but if they are telling me the right things I can decide on or I can adjust that they are doing the right things instead of looking every five minutes on my phone. And that's what we need as well.
And I don't have to set that up by myself. This is the only thing what I know, we have to set the prices right. If we are coming up with the wrong price incentives, the people will do not the best what they could do.
Claudio Geyken
So in other words we need the grid operators and utilities setting a certain price structure and then let the market do the rest. Right?
Andreas Jahn
Right, exactly.
Andreas Jahn
That's the truth from my perspective. But Germany has almost 900 distribution network operators in place and well, I wouldn't say that they are really digitalized yet they don't have smart meters implemented. And asking them how about is it time varying pricing of networks, say oh wow, that sounds fancy. How about dynamic pricing? Oh my God. So we can speed up a bit on that end.
车队充电与电动卡车
Claudio Geyken
Yeah, no, I agree. And then for the electric fleets, as this is also a lot about electric fleets and smart charging, is there any challenge you foresee in the upcoming years to electrify our fleets and what would you suggest are like ways to tackle those challenges?
Andreas Jahn
So in the first I think fleets are much easier than a private car in a private household only fleets are much easier because you know usually when and where they're driving you have certain points where you can charge and you can adjust first the infrastructure for charging and then the price optimization with a wholesale or retail market and the networks. So there is a huge potential.
And then even there it is much easier to start with bi directional charging. So in the first it is that the interconnection to the System is usually the most cost incentive investment for the flexibility. And that's why quite a lot are hesitating to install a bigger connection to the system. But I said I'm up for to make the big as possible, but to put the prices for the operation in place.
And with that then bidirectional charging of fleets, that is I would say the initial step to do that. Then at the end, even with private households or let's say apartments and car charging on the streets.
Claudio Geyken
Makes sense.
Claudio Geyken
Do you distinguish between the types of fleets where you see more potential than other types of fleets?
Andreas Jahn
Well, I would say it's economy of scale. The biggest are easiest to start with if you're operating DHL or someone by that size. Of course that's something else than having three cars for whatever kind of delivery in my neighborhood that is. And it is connected to that how much of depot charging I have in place.
If I can rely partially at least on nighttime charging means I'm more flexible than if I have a fleet what is operating on long distances and rely on fast charging. So that's what we see that will be much more expensive to charge a truck after four or five hours of running full speed on a highway to recharge then in another 35 minutes. That is more expensive. And that doesn't have a lot of flexibility.
But the combination of both of that, that is I think where the benefits even for businesses are.
Claudio Geyken
Makes sense.
Claudio Geyken
And for now there's a big hot topic nowadays is the electric trucks that are coming more and more and growing very fast. Even though they started very the share was very small in the last few years, but they're really picking up momentum. I think the goal is in 2030 to have a third of the new sold trucks to be electric in Europe. Do you have any views there on the challenges ahead or the opportunities as well ahead for electric trucks?
Andreas Jahn
Yeah, and I think the development will be more straightforward than the private car sector. We have seen so many ups and downs with it. But trucks, that is a commercial business. So it depends on the TCO cost of total ownership. And that's what we heard from the manufacturers.
The trucks will be there, the they will be sold to the market, they will be used and no one is up for if my strawberries do end up in Cologne because of lack of charging and can't be delivered to Munich, for example. So that is what we can predict for the future. But what we can see on the other hand is that the network connection how we did for the last decades, it requires Almost a decade to implement a fast charging point.
What has to be connected to the high voltage level? And I would say the car manufacturers or truck manufacturers are a bit faster.
Claudio Geyken
Yes.
Claudio Geyken
Yeah.
Claudio Geyken
So there will be the high voltage lines need to be sped up to be able to cope with all that capacity. Right,.
Andreas Jahn
Right, right.
Andreas Jahn
And the markets can deal even with limited infrastructures, with congestion. But it is so important having these incentives in place that they are building at the right spot, that they are using when it's available or when it's cheap and making the most of it. What we do have and to avoid unuseless or avoidable investments.
消费者参与与结束语
Claudio Geyken
Makes sense.
Claudio Geyken
Is there any other last messages you would like to leave here in the podcast for the listeners that you feel are important to consider in all the topics, in the wide array of topics that we touched?
Andreas Jahn
Well, what is it? Participate in the system because it is different from the past when the consumer has to be supplied. Now it is that the consumer can act. If it starts with the balcony, solar with your car, with a heat pump, with a battery, whatever I think it is in the first, it is more independency resilience to the system. To some it might make fun. Only whatever it is, check it out.
Claudio Geyken
Yeah, nice.
Claudio Geyken
Yeah, definitely the prosumer as it's also called. And we can have a big role compared to the past, where it was maybe boring. There are challenges, but also great opportunities. And finally, how can people learn more about you or about your work or connect in case they have questions?
Andreas Jahn
Sure.
Andreas Jahn
So I'm on social media for example on LinkedIn or blue sky you can find myself or. Or on reponline.org there all the information, what we are doing globally, locally, et cetera. Even on the industry side, on the decarbonization, what has its own challenges as well, on the heat side, et cetera.
Claudio Geyken
Excellent.
Claudio Geyken
Thanks Andreas and wish you still a great day.
Andreas Jahn
Yeah, thanks a lot. Pleasure to being here.
Claudio Geyken
And this was a great episode with Andreas Jan from the rap, the Regulatory Assistant project. My key takeaways are that there are several differences between markets and regions. We see liberalized markets and unliberalized markets. The UK being at the forefront, the US having a mixed system and the EU being quite harmonized. But some markets having more or less great regulatory aspects.
We see grid fees being a very important issue and how that's structured or bi directional charging being impeded by also how tax and grid fees are being structured. There's like traditional players that lack software skills as well to enable these type of business models.
We see that the world gets more and more harmonized and it's also changing fast considering that 25 years ago there was nearly no liberalized markets in Europe and it changed due to the cost advantages that are coming from that and that the keyword flexibility is also very much shaped by regulations.
And that was the key objective of the RAP from the get go as well, to make sure that we have a cost effective transition through great regulatory frameworks. And they do this globally, which is fascinating as they might be one of the very few organizations having such a deep understanding of regulatory frameworks and trying to share best practice across different markets.
He also identified fleets as a planable source of flexibility for both smart charging in one direction or bi directional charging. And really his final take was to be engaged and try to improve this system as a prosumer or as an active participant. Thanks for tuning in and please leave a review or follow Follow us. Give us five stars. That would be great and share this with somebody who could enjoy listening to this episode. See you soon.
Ep. 14 · Andreas Jahn
正在播放: · 0:00 / 50:07
