Smart Charge Leader · 1 September 2026
Europe should fill the chargers it has before building more
Operators break even around 20 to 23 percent utilisation and average 8 to 10. Issam Tidjani argues the lever is price per station and per hour, not plug count, and the AFIR revision will decide whether they are allowed to pull it.
By RiDERgy editorial
Issam Tidjani has queued at chargers in Italy in summer while, he says, a free station at full power sat a kilometre further on. The co-founder and chief executive of the Berlin charging platform Cariqa puts the average operator's utilisation at 8 to 10 percent. Break-even, on his figures, sits around 20 to 23 percent. The gap is the whole problem, and Europe's instinct is to close it by building more plugs.
Public charging should be priced to fill the capacity that already stands before the industry adds to it. The distribution is more lopsided than the average suggests: roughly 10 percent of stations do the real work, while a long tail sometimes runs near 1 percent. Because more than half of an operator's cost has nothing to do with electricity, every extra kilowatt-hour through an existing plug spreads rent, grid fees and maintenance across a larger base. That is the mechanism by which prices come down. A new plug does the opposite: it adds fixed cost on the day it is commissioned and finds its customers later, if at all.
Yet the public debate still counts plugs. Tidjani reports hearing that Europe needs 5 million charge points by 2028 and asks what for, since the binding moments are a handful of congested days a year. A target denominated in hardware rewards the wrong behaviour, and it is about to meet a regulatory fork: the revision of the EU's Alternative Fuels Infrastructure Regulation, due later this year on his account, will set how much freedom operators have over their own prices.
The useful unit is not the network but the hour at one station. Sites peak at different times: a fast-food car park at lunch and dinner, a supermarket in the early evening, a retail park on Sunday afternoon. A blanket discount gives away margin at the busy sites while doing nothing for the quiet ones. Cariqa's engine instead sets a price for each station and each hour, leaving the workhorses alone and nudging the idle tail. Tidjani is also clear about who should set that price: the operator, as seller, with nobody in the middle. Much of the pricing chaos drivers complain about, on his argument, comes from the reseller chain rather than from operator greed.
Two objections deserve more weight than he gives them. The first is fairness: time-varying prices charge most to the driver with least discretion over when to travel, which is often the commercial one. The second is physics. In a genuine jam the constraint is usually the grid connection rather than the plug count, and Tidjani concedes that few operators can deliver rated power on every plug simultaneously. Price moves demand; it cannot manufacture capacity a connection does not have. He also concedes that Cariqa's model is not yet grid-aware, which means a pricing engine could, in principle, steer drivers towards the weakest part of the network.
Both objections argue for pricing that can see the grid, not against pricing itself. The contrast with Hamburg is instructive. In S2 Ep. 5, Michael Dammann of Hamburger Energienetze argued that rules, not markets, should decide where battery storage goes, because a national price signal says nothing about a local bottleneck. For an asset that sits in one place for fifteen years, he is right. For a charging session lasting half an hour, a price that varies by station and by hour can reallocate demand faster than any rulebook, provided it carries a congestion signal. Grid fees tied to congestion rather than to one annual peak, which Tidjani says are under discussion in Germany and the Nordics, would supply exactly that.
So the sequence matters. Operators should publish a price per station and per hour and own the customer relationship that makes it legible. Regulators revising AFIR should protect the freedom to vary price by time and place rather than flattening it in the name of transparency. Grid operators should tie fees to congestion so that pricing engines inherit the network's constraints instead of ignoring them. Fleets that depend on public charging should start asking providers for hourly prices, because the ones who ask first will shape the products.
The cheapest charge point Europe can build this decade is the one already standing at 1 percent.
RiDERgy Commentary
We find Tidjani's diagnosis more useful than the plug-count consensus, and we would push it further. An 8 to 10 percent utilisation rate against a 20 to 23 percent break-even is not a marketing problem; it is a siting and scheduling problem that pricing can only partly repair. Where we agree completely: the binding constraint behind a depot fence is the same one he is describing on the street, and the first move is always to manage demand against the connection you hold rather than to request a larger one.
Where we would go further than he does: a pricing engine that cannot see the grid is a liability, not merely an incomplete product. Tidjani is candid that Cariqa's is not yet grid-aware, and we think that gap is the whole ballgame. Price signals that ignore local congestion will eventually steer vehicles into the exact feeder that cannot take them, and the resulting reinforcement bill lands on everybody. Our own work runs the other way round: start from the physical limit, then optimise cost inside it. Get that order wrong and a cheaper tariff simply buys a more expensive grid. The AFIR revision should make congestion-aware pricing the expectation rather than a feature some platforms get around to.
5 min read