Skip to content

Smart Charge by RiDERgy · Season 2, Episode 6

Direct Payments for EV Charging, the End of Price Chaos and Where Smart Charging Fits In

Issam Tidjani

Co-Founder & CEO of Cariqa

1 September 2026 · 1 hr 36 min · English · Host: Claudio Geyken

Chapters (10)

Key takeaways

  • Issam Tidjani puts the average charge point operator's utilisation at 8 to 10 percent, against a break-even of 20 to 23 percent.

  • About 10 percent of stations do the real work; the long tail sometimes runs at about 1 percent.

  • Cariqa's AI model sets a price for every station and every hour, leaving busy sites unchanged and nudging quiet ones.

  • He doubts Europe needs 5 million charge points for the two days a year when infrastructure is congested, and expects dynamic prices and smarter routing to move demand off peaks.

Smart Charge Leader · 1 September 2026

Europe should fill the chargers it has before building more

Operators break even around 20 to 23 percent utilisation and average 8 to 10. Issam Tidjani argues the lever is price per station and per hour, not plug count, and the AFIR revision will decide whether they are allowed to pull it.

By RiDERgy editorial

Issam Tidjani has queued at chargers in Italy in summer while, he says, a free station at full power sat a kilometre further on. The co-founder and chief executive of the Berlin charging platform Cariqa puts the average operator's utilisation at 8 to 10 percent. Break-even, on his figures, sits around 20 to 23 percent. The gap is the whole problem, and Europe's instinct is to close it by building more plugs.

Public charging should be priced to fill the capacity that already stands before the industry adds to it. The distribution is more lopsided than the average suggests: roughly 10 percent of stations do the real work, while a long tail sometimes runs near 1 percent. Because more than half of an operator's cost has nothing to do with electricity, every extra kilowatt-hour through an existing plug spreads rent, grid fees and maintenance across a larger base. That is the mechanism by which prices come down. A new plug does the opposite: it adds fixed cost on the day it is commissioned and finds its customers later, if at all.

Yet the public debate still counts plugs. Tidjani reports hearing that Europe needs 5 million charge points by 2028 and asks what for, since the binding moments are a handful of congested days a year. A target denominated in hardware rewards the wrong behaviour, and it is about to meet a regulatory fork: the revision of the EU's Alternative Fuels Infrastructure Regulation, due later this year on his account, will set how much freedom operators have over their own prices.

5 min read

Show notes

The same charger, at the same location, can carry 50 different prices depending on which card you hold. Issam Tidjani, Co-Founder and CEO of Cariqa, argues the cause is the business model underneath public charging: as long as e-mobility providers buy energy from charge point operators and resell it, the operator becomes a passenger in its own business, priced by someone else and exposed to 80 to 90% of its demand coming from someone else.

The conversation gets concrete about what that costs everyone. The same charger, at the same location, can carry 50 different prices depending on which card you hold, which Issam compares to a supermarket with no price tags where the till asks how you intend to pay. On the operator side the economics are unforgiving: average utilisation runs at 8 to 10% while break even sits around 20 to 23%, roughly 10% of stations do the real work, and more than half of an operator's cost has nothing to do with electricity. Cariqa's answer is a platform where the operator stays the merchant of record, plus a Connect API Issam likens to what Stripe did for online payments, free to integrate and built so a working charging app can be assembled in an afternoon.

They also get into where this collides with the grid. Issam wants grid fees that are congestion based rather than punishing a single annual peak, is sceptical that Europe needs five million charge points to serve two congested days a year, and would rather the market found its own pricing discipline than have AFIR force it. On smart charging and V2G he is deliberately careful: the hard part is not the technology but getting operators, CPMS providers, e-mobility providers and carmakers to cooperate without the grid operator buying the same flexibility twice, and he sees home and office charging as the better fit for V2G because parking a car all day on a public charger fights the utilisation the industry needs.

An episode about the plumbing under EV charging, and about what it takes for a market to fix its own incentives before someone else does it for it.

Topics covered

  • Why the reseller model makes charge point operators passengers
  • Price chaos and the case for one price per station
  • Utilisation economics and why charge point operators are not simply greedy
  • AI driven per station pricing, and a free weekend on negative power prices
  • Grid fees, congestion and the case against building for peak days
  • Where V2G actually fits, and where it does not

Resources mentioned

The guest's company

  • Cariqa

    Issam Tidjani's company: direct payments infrastructure for EV charging, where the operator stays the seller.

  • Cariqa Connect API

    The API compared to Stripe in the episode: OEMs, fleets and apps offer charging at the operator's own price.

  • Cariqa API documentation

    The documentation Issam calls simple to implement.

  • A Better Routeplanner enables charging via Cariqa Connect

    Cariqa's announcement of the route planner Issam names among the mapping providers that integrate fastest.

Regulation and standards

Companies and tools

  • HERE Technologies

    The mapping and location company where Issam worked before founding Cariqa.

  • A Better Routeplanner

    The EV route planner, one of the mapping providers integrating the Connect API.

  • Lovable

    The AI app builder used to build a working charging app on the Connect API in minutes.

  • Monta

    Charging software company Issam names for self-healing charging infrastructure.

  • Stripe

    The payments platform Issam compares the Connect API to.

  • LichtBlick

    The energy provider Issam describes offering free charging during negative power prices.

Cite this episode

Geyken, C. (host), Tidjani, I. (guest). "Direct Payments for EV Charging, the End of Price Chaos and Where Smart Charging Fits In." Smart Charge by RiDERgy, Season 2, Episode 6, 1 September 2026. www.ridergy.com/podcast/s2-ep-6-issam-tidjani-co-founder-ceo-of-cariqa-direct-payments-for-ev-charging-t

Transcript

14,142 words · machine transcript

  • Claudio Geyken, host
  • Issam Tidjani, guest

Cleaned up from a machine transcript. Translations are machine-generated and may contain errors.

Cariqa’s origin and mission

Claudio Geyken

Welcome to the Smart Charge by ridergy.com podcast. This is Claudio Gaikin, founder and CEO of ridergy.com. This is your show to learn about all things energy management and smart charging innovation for electric vehicles and fleets. Europe's public charging infrastructure is a fragmentation nightmare.

Over 3,000 operators, each with their own tariff and the EV driver pays double at the same fast charger depending on which charging card or app they use. Issam, co founder and CEO of Cariqa, knows both sides. He learned how to scale marketplaces at ebay, saw it here technologies how automakers were desperately searching for charging solutions, and then experienced firsthand how frustrating charging outside the Tesla network is.

In 2021 he took the plunge with two former colleagues. Today Cariqa is a 14 person team breaking the reseller chain. CPOs stay the merchant of record, set their own prices directly and the platform charges no onboarding fee, no monthly subscription, just revenue share with those who bring demand. One number stands out.

The average CPO utilizes their chargers at only 8 to 10%, but brake even sits above 20% and over 50% of CPO costs have nothing to do with the electricity price. ESAM explains why dynamic per charging per hour pricing is the lever, why the mass market only flips at a 10 to 20% TCO advantage, and why he sees public charging hitting 50% of all charged energy by 2035. Let's get charging. Hello Wisam, Nice that you're here today. How are you?

Issam Tidjani

Hi, thanks for having me. I'm very good. Just came back from a kind of summer break but it was nice to be by the beach for a few days.

Claudio Geyken

Yes, we also need to relax a bit. As entrepreneurs the day to day is quite unnerving.

Issam Tidjani

Or at least try to. But one does the best that they can.

Claudio Geyken

Very good.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah I heard before you need to also check every day at least so that you make sure that things are going well. But I can confirm for us it's the same. I have difficulties to completely let go. So before we jump into Cariqa and the topics around E Mobility to get an understanding who we are talking to, I like to always know what the background of the guest is. So maybe you can tell us a bit where you're from and what you did before Cariqa.

Issam Tidjani

Absolutely.

Issam Tidjani

So at Cariqa I'm the co founder and CEO, but my background has been working for large tech organizations for the majority of my career. I started my career back in 2006 at eBay, so in consumer marketplaces during their hypergrowth phase and then started Moving still in B2C but more on consumer electronics with Nokia, Microsoft, and then started slowly moving to the B2B world.

First we look at Pakar Enterprise, getting a good understanding of IoT edge computing cloud, which is kind of interesting because it gives you a good perspective on what the public charging infrastructure is in the end and last port of call before starting Cariqa, which is also where I happen to meet my two co founders, Stefan and Tamara, which was HERE Technologies, which is a company that is owned by the large German car manufacturers and other large corporations, which is a mapping and location company.

Which is where we started seeing the E mobility transition happening, how this was a challenge for car manufacturers that needed to offer charging services to their customers and allowing their customers to complete successful long distance trips without too much stress and how to find charging stations. It was also the time when we started driving electric cars ourselves, saw the gap and decided to do something about it.

Claudio Geyken

That was back in which year.

Issam Tidjani

We are talking about 2021, 2022.

Claudio Geyken

Okay, and what was your interest in technology or how did you end up doing this journey? Were you like an early geek child or what was the impetus, so to say?

Issam Tidjani

Yeah, I've always been interested in tech. I guess a lot has to do with my father. My father used to work for Olivetti, which the Italian apple of the 80s. So we had personal computers at home for as long as I can remember. I think at around 4, when I was 4, we already had a personal computer at home. And it didn't take long for me to understand how to take them apart and put them back together. And was one of the early users of the Internet.

I think that the first time that I got to see the Internet, I think that there were less than a million users worldwide. And I got really fascinated so. 1994. So it was really fascinating for me the fact that you could access information beyond what was on your local hard drive. And that kind of sparked that interest and enthusiasm that convinced me to pursue a career in tech from the early days.

Claudio Geyken

Oh, wow.

Claudio Geyken

Early 90s,.

Issam Tidjani

Then of course at some point there was a question, do I want to get a degree in computer science or economics? I opted for economics in the end because I figured out that I could keep the, let's say more techie part as a hobby between brackets. But it was interesting for me to get a good understanding also on how things works from the money side, if you want.

Claudio Geyken

Makes sense.

Claudio Geyken

And the different roles you had within these big, large American, especially companies. What type of projects or responsibilities did you have?

Issam Tidjani

I always been sitting in between marketing and product in a way because for example at ebay we were the biggest customer of Google by far. We were investing hundreds of millions of dollars year in Google Ads. But back then there was no martech, no nothing. Everything was manual and Google had an API.

And so ultimately the company decided to put up a big project that would allow us to connect the advertising stack to the internal analytics and start really doing some sophisticated biddings and actually using data to optimize the advertising spend in real time to maximize ROI in the end. And it was a very complex endeavor because was a lot of money involved.

We were operating across a multitude of countries, across basically every single category that you could think of. And therefore that resulted in us having to manage portfolios of millions of keywords and allocating budget accordingly. There is no chance that you can do it manually.

Claudio Geyken

Makes sense.

Issam Tidjani

So and then kind of it progressed because when it came to Nokia, Microsoft, we were at the transition era where digital was becoming more and more important into the consumer journey. But still people would buy the phone or the hardware offline because they wanted to see, they wanted to ask the sales staff.

So for us the challenge there was how do we match digital signals to retail in store performance and building not only models that would rely on correlation, but also try to find the causation of events. And kind of my career continued like that on me being a little bit the bridge between what is marketing and how you drive demand. But also on the other side, what does the product need to do to match this need?

Claudio Geyken

That's a good foundation. Yeah. For the founder journey then?

Issam Tidjani

Yeah, I would say so.

Claudio Geyken

And within here then that were there particular projects around also E mobility that you found quite interesting maybe worth highlighting.

Issam Tidjani

Well, I mean when, when I was there we were starting getting the first data from you know, EV charging points data pois for you know, stations so that we could, you know, place them on a map and tell people here you can charge.

But it was really the beginning and there were a lot of conversations around EV routing which is not exactly the most trivial bit to do because it's not like the general petrol car routing where you don't really worry about consumptions. You need to know this is the fastest route to go there you will arrive at around this time and. It's kind of good. But there is no consumption involved into the calculation of the route.

Claudio Geyken

Right.

Issam Tidjani

While if your routing is heavily more complex because temperature has an effect, the road inclination has affect the road roughness has an effect, the wind direction has an effect, the Car itself, every car behaves differently and then every car charges differently. Every car has different peak powers. Every, every car has a different, you know, charging curve.

And you need to take all of these variables and I'm naming just a few to then compute a route that will effectively tell the person you will arrive by this time and, you know, to stop here and here for your journey to be efficient.

Claudio Geyken

Wow.

Claudio Geyken

Quite a lot of correlations. And this was the impetus as well for Cariqa, or how did you then end up deciding, okay, now Cariqa is worthwhile pursuing as an idea?

Issam Tidjani

Yeah.

Issam Tidjani

I mean, as for. Everything is a mix of things. Right. As I mentioned before, I started driving an electric car myself and I was not particularly impressed by what I saw. Which.

Claudio Geyken

Car was it? Just out of curiosity?

Issam Tidjani

It was.

Issam Tidjani

What car was that? It was a Tesla model. Yeah. And that's where if you wanted to go outside of the Tesla network, that was just not doable, or at least it was not as easy as just get Tesla. You plug into the supercharger and you're good to go, which people feel is magical. But the moment that you need a different charger, the picture changes quite quickly. Quickly. And so it was a little bit of that.

And you could see that the, the market was, was and is, to be honest, still in its infancy. You could see that what we were seeing on the business side, that the, in particular, the car manufacturers had an increasing need because they really needed to put EVs on the road. EVs were a very, very hot topic back then. You could see that the challenge was real.

And at some point, I feel that it's when you find that thing where you feel the timing is right, the opportunity is huge. You know a couple of things about it and it's something that gives you purpose because ultimately I have two small children and I would like them to have the purpose, privilege not to walk around on the streets and inhale against their will all the kind of shit that comes out of exhaust tailpipes.

So it was a bit of a combination of everything that, you know, as for everything. And then, you know, at some point, it takes a little bit of courage to make the jump and leave a cushy corporate job, to make the completely rational choice of starting a company. But that's, that's how it went in the end.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah.

Claudio Geyken

And what was the initial then setup? Were you already having co founders? Was that from the get go, the three of us of you? I think that's the founding team. And the idea, how did it change from back Then,.

Issam Tidjani

Yeah, I started solo for a few months just to kind of get everything put together and started having some kind of initial shape of the company in place. But then quickly after, Stefano and Tamara joined and that's how the core founding team got started. To be honest, at the beginning the idea was more to fix the user experience part of the whole thing, which also was not particularly great.

But as for every startup, the startup that you start with is not the startup that you end up with. It's a journey and you need to, you need to do a bit of experiments and collect a few failures and get across a few realizations to eventually end up with what really matters. And for us, we were acting as a traditional e mobility provider.

And so we're buying energy from the charge point operators and then reselling them to the EV driver with a particular spin because we would say pay us telco style a certain amount of money every month you get a certain amount of energy and then you don't have to worry where you consume this energy. So it was pure subscription models. We were not the first ones doing that. We had relatively good success with that model.

But ultimately what we realized is that there was a deeper problem in the industry and actually we were contributing to creating the problem.

Claudio Geyken

That sounds interesting.

Issam Tidjani

And that's where at some point we decided to kind of, you know, have a good look at the mirror and say, are we really going to the right direction despite maybe the numbers going up, but are we really making something that is meaningful in the long run? And this is where I speaking to customers on both sides of the value chain.

So, so to EV drivers and to charge point operators, you realize that we are kind of solving not exactly the correct problem. And that's where we realized that the market was starting edging towards a new phase. Because until realistically 2024 or 2023, let's say the name of the game for ChargePoint operators was Deploy, deploy, deploy, grab, the good location grab, grab the grid infrastructure. So it was a land grab. Right.

Charging-market economics

Issam Tidjani

And the trajectory of adoption of EVs was probably a little bit dragged by incentives and scarcity that was driven by Covid. And therefore everybody started building towards that curve. That of course we all know what happened in 2024 when the federal government decided to shut down the government overnight. And we saw what happened.

And then also we saw what happened when the residual value of EVs completely hit the ground and therefore the case for EVs kind of toned down a little bit. Thankfully, it was a temporary slowdown and Not a continued one. But this is where charge point operators then all of a sudden realize, okay, we have a lot of capacity on the ground.

At some point the infrastructure deployment was growing faster than the adoption of EVs and therefore you had more chargers for less EVs. And that's where also because of the whole inflation post Covid inflation spike that we had, plus interest rates going up as an attempt to curb disinflation, cheap capital was no longer available.

And all of a sudden you have capital intensive companies that needs hundreds of millions to deploy this infrastructure and operate this infrastructure that at some point had to face the reality that now it's time to get this infrastructure to make money. And this is where you ask yourself the question, okay, what is it that you can do as a chargepoint operator once you have selected the location?

So it's a real estate business, so location matters, matters a lot. But it's a one off. You cannot say, oops, we got it wrong, let's move everything somewhere else. I mean you can, but it's expensive, it's incredibly expensive. And therefore you need to go kind of then try to figure out what else can you do. And ultimately utilization becomes the name of the game. And despite sometimes people don't want to think that that's the case.

But the majority of researchers show that in the top two, price is always showing up as one of the key deciding factors on whether to go and charge at a location or another. And this is where it becomes the crux of the problem. Because up to now a lot of operators were operating on a B2B fashion. So they were reselling their energy to the E mobility provider. And then this E mobility provider would then sell it downstream to the EV driver.

And the problem in this model is that you all of a sudden as a cpo become a passenger. Why a passenger? Because as a reseller, the E mobility provider has pricing power. They can decide how much margin to add to the to the wholesale price that is provided by the CPO and then set it downstream.

The problem is that this market has been proven to be extremely elastic and therefore even a few cents on top of the kilowatt hour can make a huge difference in terms of utilization. And this is where you start seeing the limit of the model.

Because if you are not in control of your own commercial strategy at scale, which means beyond what you can do at the station with a payment terminal or what you can do in your own app, that requires a lot of energy and marketing dollar to get it to take off and not all CPOs can afford that because they either don't have the capital or they don't have enough installed infrastructure to justify users downloading yet another app.

All of a sudden you see where the problem is going. You are a passenger for 80%, 90% of your demand.

And it's a double trap because on one side you get price higher than you would like to and on the other side, the moment that these E mobility providers are representing a large amount of your demand, it's also the risk of margin extraction because then the immobility provider can come to you and say, well Now I represent 20% of your traffic, I want 30% discount. And what choice do you have at that point?

Claudio Geyken

Makes sense.

Claudio Geyken

So summarizing or getting to the core of the problem is that you think the E mobility service providers could be replaced and the market would be more efficient if the CPOs were to directly be able to set a price to the EV driver, right?

Issam Tidjani

Well, in a way it's not the actor itself that maybe needs replacement, is more the underlying business model. Because that's what we are doing differently. Right? These immobility providers were born out of the need of convenience. Because in Europe you have more than 3,000 ChargePoint operators and probably more by now because I've been using this 3,000 for a year.

I guess that by now the number has grown and therefore it's highly impractical for an end customer to not have an aggregation layer that can bring the infrastructure together that is needed. Like roaming hubs will always be needed. There is no discussion about it. But then the question is how do you provide this layer of aggregation?

Because historically there was an attempt to mimic two things and taking inspiration from two industries, one is the fuel cars and the other one is the telco business. And somehow the industry decided to take the bad traits of both.

Claudio Geyken

Okay, elaborate on that.

Issam Tidjani

So ultimately you have a lot of in transparency and rigidity that are endemic of the early days of both models. And somehow this is, as I said, and I repeat that this is an extremely young age industry because I think that and you can look at it even just by the numbers of the total percentage of cars that are electric or plug in that are representing the installed base of the total amount of cars that you have in Europe.

And this number is oscillating, depending on the country, between 3 and 5%. So you can see how you cannot expect this to be a mature market where 95% of your customers at best are not yet into the market. So I would Say it's normal that the market needed something and needed something that worked, that was simple. And therefore you look, you get specific frames of reference and you took them.

Claudio Geyken

Right.

Issam Tidjani

And then of course, you haven't gone through these cycles of sometimes regulation, sometimes just, you know, the market adjusting itself. And therefore, that's why I say that there is still a lot of downsides into the current model. But that's exactly to the point, right? Is that is reseller chain the only model that allows this layer of aggregation?

And the answer is really no, because you have a lot of other industries, other industries where we have the same problem. And it has been solved by a platform model, which means that you do not take away the role of merchant of record from the infrastructure provider. So the CPO can stay as the seller, can market their infrastructure freely and independently to the end customer without having somebody interfering in the middle.

Cariqa’s platform model

Issam Tidjani

But you can do it without getting the end customer to lose the convenience of accessing everything into one single place. And that's what we do, that's what we do differently, is that for the end customer, it doesn't change anything. You go, you find all your station on a map, wherever you are, and you can start charging like a normal charging app. That doesn't change and it shouldn't change.

But at the same time, the underlying business model and economics are completely different. Different.

Claudio Geyken

And what other industries operate similarly like the Cariqa model? And maybe you took also inspirations from.

Issam Tidjani

Well, I mean, I'm coming from marketplaces, right. I worked at eBay. EBay works exactly that way. If you look at Amazon, Amazon has a dual role. You can either buy from Amazon, but Amazon has also a marketplace where its prices are decided by the sellers. And so same goes for ride hailing apps. The same goes for the hoteling industry. Hoteling industry was born as an ote. So online travel agency.

You can imagine the expedias of the awards or everything that they would buy capacity from hotels or from airlines and then sell it downstream at the price that they wanted. But you can clearly see that now this model has become obsolete with the rise of booking.com or booking.com, the hotel pushes the property at their own price and then that's how the industry works. So as I said, we're not reinventing the wheel here.

We are taking proven business models that have proven to be better for industries that are incredibly fragmented and make it to work for the EV charging industry.

Claudio Geyken

Got it.

Claudio Geyken

And what was this moment of realization where you said you realize you are the problem with the old business model,.

Issam Tidjani

It's by talking to customers, talking to customers on both sides of the aisle. Because we haven't spoken yet about the EV driver, but this is not exactly easy for the EV drivers themselves. If you think about it. We always like to make the parallel. But public charging industry today, the world way that it's priced, it would be the equivalent of you entering your local supermarket today and you want to buy a kilo of oranges.

There is no price tag on the shelf and you get your kilo of oranges and you go to pay. And then at the till the cashier will ask you, okay, how would you intend to pay? And then depending on your answer, which could be, I have my MasterCard from N26, I have my Visa from Revolut, I have my MasterCard from Deutsche Bank, I want to pay cash, doesn't matter.

And then depending on your answer, the price that you pay could be one and a half, two times more. So how would you feel about it?

Claudio Geyken

Yeah, not great, yet creates anxiety, right?

Issam Tidjani

Yeah.

Issam Tidjani

And yet this is how the public charging market works today. So for the same station, at the same location, same service, same everything, you can have 50 different prices depending on who you, who is your charging provider. And this price can be, if you are not careful, you can easily pay double.

Claudio Geyken

And so with Cariqa, this price is from the upfront basically of the kilo of orange is one price.

Issam Tidjani

We have this philosophy that we believe that the base price should be the same for everyone and you should not be penalized by the way that you decide to charge. Which in a way kind of aligns also with what the European regulators have been attempting to do with afir, where they are trying to put in place some pretty strict anti discrimination rules, where they say that any price difference must be justified. And is the.

Has the regulation solved the problem yet? No, not at all. Will it solve it? To be seen. I mean, there is a revision of the regulation coming out later this year. We will see what the European Commission has decided to do about it. But clearly, of course, the problem solves itself the moment that the seller is always the one that operates the infrastructure and not somebody else in the middle.

Claudio Geyken

And roaming platforms you already mentioned, what is the role of roaming platform if the platform itself is provided by Cariqa?

Issam Tidjani

Well, we need to make a distinction between connectivity of EV charging protocols and the underlying business model of how then the commercial transaction happens. Right. So it's two separate trails. Roaming hubs are really good at offering connectivity and I think that they are there to stay. Because sometimes it doesn't make sense to do a one on one connection with everyone.

Because I guess it's fair to say that despite EV charging protocols being as standard and operating under a standard, there are a lot of dialects out there. And of course doing a direct connection with everyone puts a strain on the tech teams of the respective companies. While sometimes roaming up that abstracts this complexity into one single place. Makes perfect sense to have.

Claudio Geyken

But when you say connection between parties, I mean if there's only CPOs and EV drivers, you need to.

Issam Tidjani

Have a layer of aggregation that this is what the. That's why I said that the EMP role does not disappear itself in the schema of the EV charging connectivity protocols. We act as an immobility protocol provider ourselves. That's why I said that we think that we need to make a separation between how the connectivity is established and how can you access the the charging infrastructure across Europe in a consistent way.

But then how the money flows underneath and how bidding happens underneath is a completely separate topic. You need to separate these two layers that are both needed for a charging session to be happening and to be priced and to be built. But the two things are not tied together. Today there are two parts of two completely separate protocols.

On one side you have the closed loop EV charging protocol like the OCPI or oicp and on the other side you have what is open loop payments like you know, MasterCard or Visa or you name it. And then all the billing, invoicing and accounting streams that are, you know, they go together with them. So that's why to me roaming hubs are there to stay, they are needed, they're useful. I don't think that they are going anywhere.

Claudio Geyken

Makes sense.

Claudio Geyken

Makes sense.

Claudio Geyken

So these, for these two layers we will need roaming hubs and these platforms like Cariqa is, that has also this EMP role and there will probably be more than you, but not necessarily the MSP as we know it today.

Issam Tidjani

Yeah, I think my take is that the EMSP as a reseller is for multiple reasons, not a business model that I believe will last for a long time, namely because margins are going to become tighter and tighter. There is very little point of having two financial transactions to complete one charging session, which is one is the invoice from the CPO to the MP and then is all the invoicing from the MP to the end customer. Why not just do it once?

It's simpler, it's faster. On the other side, right now the market is relatively small, so the volumes are still Manageable from a credit risk perspective, when these volumes will start becoming tens of millions, if not hundreds of millions on a monthly basis. The fact that you as an EMP can have potentially tens of millions of invoices from a CPO puts a CPO in a really not so good position when it comes to credit risk.

Because if the EMP goes bankrupt on that month, that tens of millions of energy that you have already delivered on which you would have to pay your bills from the grid provider, from the electricity provider, there is no guarantee that you will see them because you are an unsecured creditor.

Future energy integration

Issam Tidjani

And I believe that at some point also, if anything, I believe that also the financial regulator will start having a closer look at the industry, because right now it's small, it's manageable. But I don't think that this is going to be the case forever.

Claudio Geyken

And is there any other like this is quite a disruptive view, which is also quite cool to have people looking at an industry and rethinking it completely. Is there another role like that that you think could be different in the future, modus operandi that we know in the E mobility industry so far?

Issam Tidjani

Well, that's a good question. I would need to think about it closer. But I feel that in general we know that there is a lot of, there are a lot of discussions about what's coming next. Right, Right. So, okay, let's assume that EV charging protocols work, payment flows work, reliability gets somehow where the error rates stop being like, still, what are the 14% today?

And get more into the zero point something percent today we have a situation where now by law, ISO 15118, so everything that enables plug and charge charge and V2G is mandatory for newly installed stations. So of course that opens the realm of new possibilities both on the authentication side. So plug and charge becoming a little bit more accessible and widespread, which should make it easier for the end customer.

But of course then there is a whole discussion on how EV charging becomes more of an active participant into the energy market and how can we help the whole grid stability to become better and how can we avoid having to put too many stationary batteries because we have a lot of kilowatt hours that are not moving for 80% of the time and how can we get them to contribute to stabilizing the grid, stabilizing the pricing of the electricity throughout the day?

Because interestingly, sometimes there is a bit of a nice matching between when cars are not used and when energy is more requested. So I guess that that's going to be the next big topic and how EV charging will become part of the overall energy ecosystem in a more integrated way.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah, I will come to that. As you know this podcast called Smart Charge so definitely can't wait to go and deep dive into that. But before we do that, just to get a full round understanding of Cariqa, what's the size of the company right now, things that you can say can share with us.

Issam Tidjani

Well, we are growing quite nicely. We have been going through. We are a VC backed startups so we operate on milestones. We to date raised around 5 million between our precedency financing rounds. We are a small team and we want to stay a small team for as long as we can. Right now we are a team of 14. We are distributed across Germany, the UK, Ukraine. So we are quite a diverse bunch of people and yeah, so.

And the reason why we want to stay small is because it gives you agility,. Of course it means that you there is a lot to do and there is nobody coming to the rescue if something is not done. But at the same time I feel that there is a beauty in having a small scrappy team that can really react quick to market needs or to customer needs and get them together.

Claudio Geyken

Right?

Issam Tidjani

Of course we are very picky on how do we hire people and we want to make sure that we have a very cohesive team that have diverse perspectives, diverse skill sets. But yeah, in general we want to stay, as I said, as small as possible for as long as we can until our hands are bleeding in a way.

Claudio Geyken

And you're based here in Berlin, right?

Issam Tidjani

The headquarters is here in Berlin.

Claudio Geyken

And the operations right now is only in brackets Germany and. Or do you have also other markets that you already operate or that you want to operate in?

Issam Tidjani

So historically we have been operating out of Germany and Austria. These are been historically our core markets. We recently opened Italy a couple of weeks ago. Yeah, I mean it was being the team home turf. Yeah, exactly. Being the team heavily Italian.

Claudio Geyken

Nice.

Issam Tidjani

I guess that that was a just a matter of time and it was for us also a good way of testing a different kind of market which has a different stage of maturity and different market penetration of EVs to understand if there is any differences that we need to be aware of before we start going pan European. But the plan is to go pan European by the end of the year.

We have some pretty nice announcements in the pipeline between now and the end of the year. But the platform per se, it's globally scalable. If we wanted to, we could go to The US tomorrow. But then it becomes a matter of focus.

That's why we were quite diligent in saying we want to start getting the platform up and running in Germany and Austria, learn, make sure that we have an extremely robust platform and then we open to partners beyond these geographies.

Claudio Geyken

And are there any geography that doesn't make sense for Cariqa, for example, the number of CPOs that are there or how the market is structured in other.

Issam Tidjani

Ways?

Issam Tidjani

Of course the platform makes a ton of sense the more fragmented the market is. But that said, even if you have 10 different CPOs it still makes sense because you would need anyway a layer of aggregation to support Companies like automotive OEMs or rental car companies, ride hailing companies that need to offer charging to their fleets. They prefer to have it into one single, single aggregated layer. Right.

Founder experience and team

Issam Tidjani

So ultimately, unless there is only one CPO or two, it still makes sense.

Claudio Geyken

Makes sense.

Claudio Geyken

And when you started the company said you worked before in corporates a lot. Was there a moment or was it a big shock now to be a founder compared to these previous corporate roles,.

Issam Tidjani

It's different.

Issam Tidjani

I mean, I would be lying to say otherwise. At the same time, for everything is a trade off, right? So you corporate job, you, salary gets at the end of the month and you know that you have a support structure and you know that, you know, there is always the cavalry, you know, around the corner.

At the same time, I feel that the learning curve the you get when you found a startup is geometrically steeper than compared to, you know, the learning curve that you have in corporate. I always say that despite founding a startup is a completely irrational thing to do from an economical perspective because the odds are stacked heavily against you.

But at the same time, I think feel that the journey and the learning is something that they have no value irrespective of the outcome. I still believe that Cariqa is going to be extremely successful and it has all the hallmarks of being a very successful company.

But at the same time, I know that for the learning itself and for the journey and the fact that you have to look at so many things that typically would not be of your own business in a corporate world that just pays off for everything else.

Claudio Geyken

If you had to just mention one key learning that you already can say this will stay with you thanks to Cariqa.

Issam Tidjani

In a way it's clarity, because in a way is the ability to find clarity relatively quickly and then, and then act upon it. Because I think that of course, you know, you have the typical reasons why a Startup die, which is typically you run out of money, the founders fall out. But to me there is another one that is maybe less known, which is having too many good ideas and trying to chase everything.

And at some point, you know, you are so much deep into it that if everything is important, you have a problem. And that's where having the ability to make a step back despite having to swim for your life in the meanwhile, and have a clear understanding of what you need to do to be successful down the line, it's something that the corporate world really would struggle to teach you. The same way.

Claudio Geyken

Makes sense.

Claudio Geyken

And you said there are three founders. How did you then choose your two other founders and how do you split their responsibilities?

Issam Tidjani

So we, we chose each other in a way. I mean, it's not something that you, it's not me doing the casting like X Factor.

It's really that you talk to people and then you kind of, you know, share the idea and then, and then ultimately, if you have worked together, you risk a lot the decision making process because you kind of already know a little bit the other person, you know, the positive sides, the negative sides, you know, the biases and everything. And you know that you can work with this person on the long run.

And you have already proved that you can, can work with this person. Right. And the way that we divide the task for us is relatively straightforward because we are basically 100% complementary. We have very little overlap between the three of us and the four of us. If you had Mario right now, that joined us a year later. But we all know that we have different backgrounds.

Stefano is highly technical, you know, nga, computer science background with an academic profile in artificial intelligence. Tamara is an exceptionally skilled salesperson and people person. I am more on kind of, you know, the product side, strategy side and you know, just trying to find creative solutions to problems.

And Mario, if you want, is the one that is, you know, investment banking background and so very rigorous, very organized that can keep us, you know, running like a Swiss clock. So for us it was very natural to not to step on each other's toes.

Connect API and commercial model

Claudio Geyken

Sounds good.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah.

Claudio Geyken

And you likened your Connect API to what stripe does for payments. Is it a fair comparison or in which way do you think there are also differences.

Issam Tidjani

In my opinion is a fair comparison. Then I'll let you decide about it.

But in a way, I think that to bring the substance to that claim, you need to imagine going back into the early 2000s and if you wanted to start your e commerce website, you had to go to your bank get an acquiring bank account, and then you had to go and negotiate, you know, connections with Visa, with MasterCard, with Amex, and then do a connection to PayPal, because that's the way the market was, was, was structured.

And Stripe was not the first one that created an abstraction layer that would simplify the whole thing. But they were not exactly developer friendly and they were quite clumsy.

And that's where then all of a sudden Stripe decided to build something for developers for which something that would have taken like three months of work before you could do it in an afterim, because all of a sudden you had all the complexity that you had to deal with was already taken care of by Stripe. And all you needed was an API that you could connect to your checkout system to process payments, right?

So that's how Stripe became what it is today. And if you look at the EV charging world, if today, let's say I'm a German, I keep on saying German manufacturer, but any oem, any car manufacturer around the world, or, you know, fleet solution provider or rental car company, you name it, and I need to offer charging to my customers. So today I have different choices, right? I become an E mobility provider myself.

Meaning that you need to build all the connectivity with roaming hubs, with ChargePoint operations, indirect, where it makes sense. So you need to stand up a team for that. You need to stand up a commercial team that negotiates deals with the different ChargePoint operators and with the roaming hubs and so on and so forth.

You would need the operations to deal with all the influx of in invoices, checking the invoices, checking that they match the charging transactions and so on and so forth. And all of these, to make it work properly, would take you nine to 12 months, right? The other option that you have realistically is to buy an API service from one of the established E mobility providers. But at that point, you pay a SaaS fee to offer charging to your customers.

You're not making any money. You probably are gonna offer to your customers inflated prices, because these are the prices that the EMP's need to make to make a living. Or I mean, it can be any combination. But ultimately what you realize is charging will never be a profit center for you, is going to be a cost center. So each charging session that happens via these APIs, each user that is using this API is going to be a cost for you.

And this is where we come in, right? Because I guess you can start seeing the parallel. This is where our API is free to use or connect because it can be also easier than just a full fledged API integration, which is an easy on ramp solution that is maybe more targeted to mapping providers. But in both cases there is no cost to use the service, there is no onboarding fee, no monthly fee whatsoever.

And actually we help you monetize your user base when it comes to charging because one of the beauty of the platform model is that it allows you to make those that have these large fleets that need charging to become affiliates to the CPO and to us. Meaning that we recognize part of our revenue to them in exchange for them bringing the customers to the cpo. And all of a sudden you can see how making a step back from the Stripe analogy.

But this is where you can see how all of a sudden you have the three key players into the value chain that all of a sudden have aligned incentives because the CPO can actually and actively promote their own infrastructure on their own terms. You have those that have access to these pools of demand that can monetize the user without trying to make money out of the end customer.

And you have the end customer that has a fair and transparent price that is coming directly from the ChargePoint operator. And this is in our perspective the only way that this market can flourish and scale.

Claudio Geyken

Interesting.

Claudio Geyken

And the apps then, to take the analogy of Stripe, Stripe is not providing an app, it's just an API that then the developers need to integrate within their app. Yeah. So you are suggesting that the fleets and so on, the OEMs would have then their own app, Right?

Issam Tidjani

They already do. It's just that it's a white label built by somebody else or an API built by somebody else where this somebody else is typically the seller.

Claudio Geyken

Makes sense.

Claudio Geyken

Okay, so that's. Yeah, I think it's a fair comparison. And the payment methods as well is coming then through this API.

Issam Tidjani

Everything is managed.

Claudio Geyken

Similarly to Stripe.

Issam Tidjani

There is literally no complexity for you to offer charging services.

Claudio Geyken

Maybe a random question that just comes up like why couldn't Stripe enter the industry and do the same? Is it a risk you're considering even?

Issam Tidjani

I mean it's the typical question that some VCs do that is if I have to say, a little bit irritating. What if Google comes in and say yeah, sure, but the reality is that there is a lot of complexity. Charging world. And I don't believe that the market is mature enough for a company like Stripe to come in and build it themselves. I think that it's going to be a market that is going to be looked more and more.

Claudio Geyken

Yes.

Issam Tidjani

But typically this is the situation where it's more of a partnership exercise for these companies rather than entering into the arena themselves.

Claudio Geyken

Makes sense.

Claudio Geyken

And for the integration that these players need to do with you, who is typically the fastest, is it more the CPOs or more on the other side, the flexibility?

Issam Tidjani

Well, on the supply side, I guess that by now we have a very well established onboarding process and it can go relatively quick. Then of course, it depends. Sometimes you can ignore the fact that some of the CPOs are part of ginormous companies that have their own internal processes and we need to respect that and go with their own timelines.

But I say that from a Lyft perspective, it's actually quite easy to do and there is no development needed on their side. Therefore things go relatively quickly on the demand side. It depends. I would say that our experience so far is that mapping providers are the quickest.

Claudio Geyken

So like the likes of here? Yeah,.

Issam Tidjani

The likes of here. The likes of Better Route Planner, you name it. Not yet, soon. And then I think that the others, we are exploring partnerships right now and we are in pretty advanced discussions, but we know that the moment that you start touching a utility application or an automotive product, things become a little bit more complicated.

Claudio Geyken

Google,.

Issam Tidjani

And the integration migration cycles probably can go to timelines of six to nine months, but that's just the reality.

Claudio Geyken

And are the small ones even able to do it or do they maybe lack development resources or they need to just buy it from a third party then?

Issam Tidjani

No, I think that in general we see that also we have young startups that are implementing our API, so it's really, really easy. I mean, it's. If you want to, in one week you are up and running. I mean, the day that we launched the API, we demonstrated how. And this was not staged, we showed up at the charging station. I'm not a coder. I mean, I understand code, but I cannot code. Right.

And on purpose, we showed up at the station with absolutely nothing and just the keys for, for the production environment of the API. And Lovable, which is this white coding app. And in 15 minutes we built functioning charging app that allowed me to physically charge in a real work station. So documentation is very well done, it's simple to implement. So yeah, I would say that everybody can do it.

AI and platform architecture

Claudio Geyken

Yeah, yeah.

Claudio Geyken

Especially now in the age of AI. I'm also quite excited these days about the potential of AI. Is it actually something, how do you look at now AI development and how does it help Cariqa or how does it change also the offering in the market?

Issam Tidjani

Well, so for our Internal development. That would be a question for Stefano, to be honest, because I'm not completely involved into that. I know that it's being used, but we are not vibe coding the hell out of everything because also. It's risky in particular when it's mission critical infrastructure because it needs to work. Right.

Claudio Geyken

Risky.

Issam Tidjani

You cannot have something that has been wipe coded on which oops, doesn't work and then all of a sudden you have somebody stranded with 2% of battery at the charger that doesn't work. Right. So. So we just cannot do that. But of course, can we use it responsibly? Absolutely. And that's what we do.

We are using already AI for different purposes like our smart pricing which is the world's first dynamic pricing engine that is based on AI that looked at multiple variables that can help determine what is the best price for each and single location of the chargepoint operator. And this is done programmatically so you don't have to go and change prices at every single station. We do it in an automated fashion.

Claudio Geyken

Cool.

Claudio Geyken

Cool.

Issam Tidjani

I see some nice progress when it comes to AI customer support, which is also pretty nice. I have my own ideas how this could progress. But to be seen, I think it you can see companies like Montanao for example started getting into self healing charging infrastructure where the errors are surfaced before a user notices which is also actually quite nice.

So I think that definitely AI has a place into the business and then of course when we will move into the grid part and predicting how the grid is going to behave and how to compensate for that. Clearly you need a more real time agentic way of doing it rather than having the grid operator at the DSO level saying hey, I need more energy or something like that. So there is definitely a place for it.

Claudio Geyken

Definitely.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah.

Claudio Geyken

There's room for improvement and talking from. We've talked already with a few but maybe there's anything we missed in terms of product integration or system architecture. So you have definitely a connectivity towards the CPOs. You have a connectivity towards then the fleets or the OEMs having the end customer contact. Is there any other interconnection that we have missed in your product?

Utilisation and dynamic pricing

Issam Tidjani

No, I would say no. I don't think that we need to make it look more complicated than it already is. So no, I think that for us is really connecting people in a way. Just to name the motto of the company that I used to work for. In a way for us it's just we want to create a healthier value chain that can scale together with the market.

Claudio Geyken

Okay.

Claudio Geyken

And connecting vehicles. That is part of the.

Issam Tidjani

We have been playing with vehicle connectivity for a few years now, but for us it's not necessarily the core of our business. For the time being, this might change, that's why we continue playing with it. But it's not something that we are actively using beyond giving the convenience to the end customer to. To see the state of charge on their own on the Caric app.

So we know that the potential is much bigger than that and that at some point then to be seen where this data point is going to come from. Is it going to come from the API of the automotive OEM? Is it going to come from the ISO 15118 power line communication? That is to be seen. But yeah, that's definitely something that in particular when it comes to V2G and smart charging use cases is going to be crucial to have the knowledge of this data point.

Claudio Geyken

Right.

Claudio Geyken

Coming back to the price transparency you had already touched upon affirmation. Do you think it will come as a regulatory push or more will the market decide or will it be a mix of both in your view?

Issam Tidjani

My hope is that it's not going to come as per regulation because this is my belief is that if a market fails to regulate itself and forces the regulator to intervene, typically the outcome is suboptimal because it creates situations that are not necessarily what the market needs and not what the company companies need to thrive.

Because typically regulator mandated, you know, in particular when it comes to pricing policies, they tend to be extremely rigid and they tend to favor certain players more than others. So my hope is that the market will adjust itself and learn how to self regulate itself rather than getting into a situation where we force the hand of the regulator to intervene more than they already have.

Claudio Geyken

And there is lots of criticisms by EV drivers that I myself as well have experienced. Or that is, I think you're spot on that the market as it is right now is having some issues with price transparency and high prices, in particular public charters. What do you think we could get if Cariqa was to be successful in terms of not only the price transparency but also price reduction at public charge points?

Issam Tidjani

Well, price reduction can only come from one single place, or maybe two. One is something that we can certainly contribute to the other one a little bit less.

So the one where we can contribute less is that I believe that the way that the grid fees are structured today is not something that is designed for the EV charging world where you know you will have the random day where you reach a peak capacity in terms of, you know, what you draw from the grid. But if this is a one off and then you keep on paying an exorbitant amount for the rest of the time where your stationary, they're sitting idle.

Of course CPOs need to pass this cost to the end customer. So this is something that I know there are discussions about making grid fees congestion based and also a little bit more dynamic, which would something that would be definitely contribute to lower the fixed cost of chargepoint operators. The other one realistically is utilization.

Claudio Geyken

I agree.

Issam Tidjani

Because the reality is that more than 50% of the cost of CPO are coming from something else that is not the cost of electricity. And in that situation, the more kilowatt hours are delivered by the plug, the more you can spread those fixed costs that are beyond what is the dynamic cost of energy. And that's where prices can go down, then how will this happen? Is of course we need to have more EVs per charging point.

So I think that there has to be a bit more thoughtful deployment of the infrastructure and maximizing what we have where we can and eventually build where we need. And that would contribute to, to improve utilization. Of course then we need to avoid getting ourselves into nightmare scenarios for which the day of, you know, peak traffic stations are slammed.

And that's not a good experience either because I was hearing stories from fellow EV drivers traveling during the summer where you have certain locations that are completely jammed where, you know, borderline, you block the traffic because you have people queuing to charge.

Claudio Geyken

Really?

Claudio Geyken

For example, where was that? In Italy or something.

Issam Tidjani

I mean,.

Issam Tidjani

I saw this myself in Italy. I got an account from another person this morning in France where actually you had people that had to direct the traffic because the queue was becoming so long that it was also jamming the entrance to the service area of people that just wanted to go to the restaurant. So of course these are exceptions.

Claudio Geyken

Wow.

Issam Tidjani

But at the same time by, and this is maybe anecdotal, but by driving a few thousand kilometers a year, even long distance, with an electric car, this is sometimes also driven by the fact that people tend to stall all at the same location.

And then sometimes you find yourself with one location in a specific area that is completely jammed and then you drive 1km more and it's a completely free station with full power capacity, meaning that you can also drive away quicker. But this is where I feel that using, among other strategies, price as a way to redistribute the capacity across the infrastructure would allow really the infrastructure to be optimized.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah, just yesterday actually. I think it doesn't apply only for EV chargers. I was in a train and I had to get back to Berlin from the outskirts and I took it. I want to take a train at 7pm and I think that's prime time. Sunday 7pm, regional train back to Berlin. So it was packed and I didn't manage to enter the train. Yeah. Whereas the train one hour later was perfectly. So much space.

So I guess also we cannot design the whole charging infrastructure for this one moment at the year where it's 2 gen. But we of course need to have smarter mechanisms. But.

Issam Tidjani

That's exactly the problem, right? Is that when you hear those claims, we will need 5 million charging points by 2028. Sure. For what? For that two days a year where the infrastructure incongruested on specific places. I think that we are smarter than that. And I think there is going to be a combination of dynamic pricing that will discourage if you want peak times, if you want to travel, because you need to. Sure.

But eventually you would need to pay more. It's going to become about routing engines in cars and in apps becoming smarter and telling you, well, you know what, maybe you should travel a little bit earlier or a little bit later because you're going to incur into risk of congestion which will extend your journey significantly. Because not only you have to wait to charge, it's a double whammy. So you have to wait.

But also when the station is jammed, it delivers not the power rating that is on the. Because very few operators have grid connections that can support the rated power of each plug because grid fees are expensive. And all of a sudden you find yourself charging a big ass 100 kilowatt hour battery at 60 kilowatt, then what? You lose an hour?

Claudio Geyken

Connectors.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah, yeah, no, very good point. And talking about grid fees and load management and so on, so you're seeing dynamic grid fees. I agree. That could be a very good way to especially deal with congestions at the grid level and reduce costs. Is it a topic that you're following a lot? Do you see it coming already? Do you follow some countries where it's done better?

Issam Tidjani

Well, I'm not closely following because I need to pick my bottles, but we're keeping an eye on it. I know that there are some good intentions in Germany. I know that the Nordics are already looking at something like that. Typically that's how the grid maturity tend to. To south. But to me that's. It has to happen. You cannot have the situations that we have Today.

Claudio Geyken

Travel north.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah.

Claudio Geyken

And in terms of your AI price forecast, so you said it takes into account a variety of factors and how do you weigh those factors in so that ultimately it must be quite complicated. Especially given the example we just talked about with, with drivers in the summertime. You need to consider their needs, you need to consider the grids, you need to consider probably local grids and so on.

Issam Tidjani

So right now the model is not grid aware because again we needed to pick our bottles and we need to have a model that works because you need to start simple. Right? And what we are looking at right now is that if you look at an average chargepoint operator, by average, I mean with an average utilization rate of their own infrastructure of you know, 8 to 10%, what you will notice is that this 8 to 10% is not even in distribute.

Claudio Geyken

Right.

Issam Tidjani

You have 10% max of the infrastructure that is really a workhorse that really slammed. Works really well because location was spot on because it's in a hotspot of ev adopt you name it, can be everything. And then you have typically 90% long tail of charging infrastructure that is not exactly being used with situations where sometimes we see utilization rates of like, you know, 1%. And keep in mind that break even sweet spot is around 20 to 23%.

Claudio Geyken

Oh really?

Issam Tidjani

So we are still far away from a charge point operator business being profitable outright. And that's why sometimes the claim of, you know, CPOs are greedy and they want to hoard as much money as possible. It's a little bit unfair if I have to say. It's easy to use them as the scapegoats, but sometimes if you look at realistically the economics of EV charging, it's a bet on the future. It's not something that you are doing today.

But nevertheless, cheap capital is over. So therefore you need to do something to stay afloat. And then also just going back to the topic, so you have 10% that works really well, 90% that could do better. But crucially also the stations that work well, they do not work well, well throughout the day. They have their own peak moments.

And typically what you see is that you have the charging point or the charging location that is in a parking of a fast food chain that would work really well between, you know, at lunchtime, at dinner time and on Sunday afternoon. And then you have the supermarket that would work really well between 5pm and 7, 8pm so, so it really varies. And that's what we are optimizing for right now.

Claudio Geyken

Makes sense.

Issam Tidjani

We are looking at multiple variables that go from what is the historical performance year over year, 30 days average. Plus we layer on top social demographics, market penetration, quite a few variables. I mean Stefano has a better picture of everything. And that allows us to define what is the optimal pricing profile at an hourly basis, on a daily basis for every single charging station into your own network.

Which means that as a CPO you can avoid dropping the price on everything in an attempt to increase utilization. But that means also cannibalizing the the profitability of the stations that are working well.

While maybe for the others you could have done more using smart pricing, which is our AI based pricing, you can keep the profitability of the over utilized stations because the model is going to say no need to change price there, but maybe to those that might require a little bit of a kick to get more drivers there. And why not also incentivize people that are considering buying an electric car.

They can say, oh, nearby media, I have some good options to charge conveniently and a fair price even if I cannot have a wall box at home. So that's what we're looking at. I think that the topic of great capacity and ultimately spot market pricing, it's something that we are looking at. We did some experiments with Blik Blick that were largely successful.

Claudio Geyken

Cool.

Issam Tidjani

But it's just a matter of deciding, you know, what to prioritize and will it come absolutely when. It depends also on when ChargePoint operators will adjust their procurement strategy more towards, you know, spot market pricing rather than working on fetch procurement to avoid, for example, the winter spikes in pricing. They prefer predictability rather than dynamic pricing.

Claudio Geyken

Got it.

Claudio Geyken

In which way was it successful with Licht Bleak or what was the scope?

Issam Tidjani

So with Licht Bleak, at some point you remember that it was that weak where that weekend where prices went down to like minus €500.

Claudio Geyken

In May sometime.

Issam Tidjani

And at that point LichtBlick decided yeah, we were gonna offer charging for free. And ultimately because the prices are negative, you can still make money as a CPO despite giving the product away for free to drivers. And.

Claudio Geyken

The drivers reacted.

Issam Tidjani

Driver reacted really, really well.

Claudio Geyken

Very cool.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah.

Claudio Geyken

And talking about, I think as you said, a lot of EV drivers feel like CPOs are taking advantage and taking more an optimistic look and realistic maybe also based on your data, you said 23% is the utilization needed to what is the price we can achieve?

EV adoption and public charging

Claudio Geyken

So if as an EV driver or somebody who was skeptical about EV driving because he sees these high prices at the, at the public charging, what can we achieve eventually or where will we get Once utilization goes up, prices that are of course not near the household prices. But what, what is achievable?

Issam Tidjani

I think that it's not necessarily a target price that we should look at, but it's more of a calculation on what is more convenient. Right. Or what is more economically effective. Because there are multiple factors when it comes to adopting a new technology that would make it successful or not. So right now we need to take as a frame of reference what people use today, which is a petrol car or a diesel car.

So you need to factor a comparison because basically ultimately it's about the total cost of ownership. And is this total cost of ownership greater or lower than owning a petrol car? If it's lower, people will adopt if it's greater. In my economic studies I have hardly seen a case of a technology that is more expensive for doing the same job taking over.

So that's why to me it's not about a price per sale of the kilowatt hour is going to be more, our cars going to become cheaper than the petrol cars. So the initial capex that you put down to buy an EV gonna become lower than a petrol car? Yes. Great. What about the residual value? Am I buying something that then is gonna worth nothing in four years? Or is it? Or can I, can I sell it in four years and still have decent residual value?

And that's important also for fleet cars and leasing companies. And then is it going to be cheaper to run it? And of course there you have maintenance where we know that EVs have lower maintenance costs than petrol cars because there are less moving parts. And then you have the cost of energy.

Of course right now if you are relying exclusively on public charging, depending on where you live, but not necessarily, I guess you go on par, considering now the oil shock that brought prices from 1.6 to €2 per liter in Germany, just to take a reference at that point, I feel that we and electric cars are getting lower. So we are somehow at parity right now.

But the reality is that you need to factor in also the switching costs and the perceived advantage needs to be at least 10 to 20% cheaper in terms of TCO perspective for somebody to make the jump. So that's what we are looking at is what is the cost per kilowatt hour that would contribute to this perceived saving of minus 20, minus 15% that would convince people to making the switch.

And this number is going to become lower and lower because the more people adopt, the more they see evs out there, pardon me, the more they feel that this is normal and that they are not being guinea pigs, they're not taking a risk because they are seeing everybody doing it. And therefore you can probably get away with, you know, parity or minus 5%.

But that's, that's the way you need to look at the problem is ultimately for the average person that is not the typical EV early adopter that tends to be a geek working in it, that buys an EV for the technology and for in a way it's an environmental qualifications. But when you go to the mass market, it becomes an economics problem no longer attack or let's say environmental concern problem.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah, I completely agree. That's why I was willing to pinpoint you to a specific kilowatt hour price where I think it would be attractive enough because now if you talk to the common person as exactly as you say, they will give the objection. No, it's too expensive for me. But once the capex of the acquisition, that is we are imminently there, the EV is actually cheaper. But if the operations don't follow, I mean, of course the diesel price goes up.

But ideally you would also have a cheaper.

Issam Tidjani

There are multiple researchers that point that a price that is considered fair and interesting for the average EV driver Today it's around 39 cents in AC and 49 cents in DC. That's what is considered an okay price. And people can live with that. But then again you can have this aspirational price. But of course, if your economics as CPO cannot support them, you cannot realistically ask the CPO just to completely blindly go for it.

I mean, it has to be better orchestrated in a way.

Claudio Geyken

And that's a good segue to the topic of smart charging in V2G. You already did a very cool project with Licht Blick. Do you think that we will be able also to have smart charging, V2G and public charging, thereby even getting lower than that? Like as you said, like you were able to offer something for free even. How cool is that? How if people these type of stories start accumulating, we will definitely get the mass masses.

You can either pay 2 liters, €2 per liter, or you can even drive for free in certain times of the day. How cool is that? Or even get paid?

Issam Tidjani

Yeah, I mean, that's. It depends on the way you look at it, right? Because to me there are a few things that are not completely clear to me. Because for example, when it comes to smart charging, and of course now I'm taking a bit more an eye on public charging because that's where. The problem that we're talking about today. And in a way the real question is who is selling smart charging services to the grid? Right? Because you have multiple actors.

Claudio Geyken

The focus,.

Issam Tidjani

You have the CPO that could do that, you have the, pardon me, you have the CPMS provider that could do that. You have the. Some EMPs are trying to position themselves to be the ones that are orchestrating that. And then you have the car manufacturer, because the car manufacturer is the one that has access to the car and can modulate how much energy the car draws, if any.

So to me, what I am still not clear on is how do you make sure that these 3, 4, 5 actors can really cooperate for the greater good? Plus and on top of that you have the end customer that needs to get something out of it. So how do you do that? How do you keep all these players in sync and remunerated and how do you make sure that the grid operator doesn't buy the same product twice? So to me that's. Is there value in it?

Yes, probably more in certain countries than others because we know that for example the Netherlands have a completely overloaded grid and EV charging is a real problem there because everybody is charging on these AC wall boxes on the streets. That's creating the problem. Does the problem has the same magnitude everywhere? Probably not. And then it becomes more on the, it becomes more of a procurement topic of CPOs that are buying on dynamic pricing.

Because of course, if you can say look, plug in your car at 8, but then please let me not draw any energy between, you know, eight or six in the evening and midnight, I will let you keep the car plugged until the morning after and you will get your car full by the time you need to go then. Yes, then, then it has, then it makes sense. And the same goes for, for V2G. Right.

So first question is, I think the V2G is gonna become faster first the trust topic because we need to convince drivers that yeah, we're gonna draw energy from your car, but don't worry, we're gonna give it back to you and then you can make a nice arbitrage on the delta on the transaction.

Then whether this is gonna be a use case that is gonna be as attractive or on public charging than on home charging is to be seen because of course, you know, I can see home and office charging a better use case for V2G because car is there, is clearly connected, is clearly connected on the entire day non stop and you're not hogging charging facility that somebody might need to use to effectively charge. So we need to consider that aspect as.

Claudio Geyken

Well.

Claudio Geyken

Exactly.

Claudio Geyken

The utilization that we were just talking about is a bit of a conflict, right? Yeah. There's an opportunity cost if you have a car plugged in longer than it should, just to charge as fast as possible.

Issam Tidjani

I think that I can see the window between 6pm and the day after 6pm and 6am where you have 12 hours, where realistically at night you don't have a lot of turnover of cars. So that makes total sense. But during the day I struggle to see how you can fit utilization targets in terms of delivery of energy with the expectation of having somebody leaving the cars there all day with the battery at the service of the grid.

I don't think that this is a viable way of doing V2G.

Claudio Geyken

And what's your vision towards getting, like you said, around 5% now in absolute numbers of adoption of EVs in the total car fleet or vehicle fleet once we really get rid of fossil fuels. What's the vision you are working towards? What do you envision?

Issam Tidjani

Well, I mean getting completely rid of fossil fuel is going to take a while. I don't think that there is any point in us taking ourselves for a ride. I believe that it's increasing quite aggressively and we see price of new cars dropping, becoming better charging faster. So by all means we are going to the right direction.

I can totally see in five years electric cars being like 50% plus of the new registered cars, but then the replacement cycles of old cars is going to take a little bit longer. So I don't think that we will achieve a full fleet replacement until probably the late2030s, 35, something like that.

Claudio Geyken

And do you think it will be mostly public charging, like all these cars that we see in Berlin, for example, in other cities, in the street, where will they charge?

Issam Tidjani

That's an interesting question, because historically, my point is, historically there was always this statement, 80% of charging happens at home. But to me that was the result of a reverse correlation which was as a driver, the topic was can I have a wall box at home? If yes, I would buy an electric car, otherwise I would wait. These times are over, right?

And already today EV charging, public charging represents around 30% of the overall energy charged. There are multiple researches pointing to the fact that this number is going to become more 50% in the long run by 2035 or something like that. And you can see that happening. As you said, you have a lot of people, particularly living in large and dense populated areas in like Hamburg, Berlin.

So Large urban centers that cannot park in off street parking. Therefore there are naturally disqualified from having access to a private charger or simply the building does not allow for it for multiple reasons. And at that point of course you need to make sure that the infrastructure is capable of dealing with this amount of people in needing for charging.

And of course this is going to be a nice problem for the different governments of the local municipalities to see what can be done there. But also honestly, the more people get confidence in traveling long distance. Long distance, you do it in public, you have no choice. And therefore I am quite bullish that public charging is going to represent 50% easily of the total amount of energy delivered to electric cars.

Claudio Geyken

And will there be more AC or DC within cities for example?

Issam Tidjani

That's a good question. I think that this becomes a bit of an opinion based conversation because there are different camps. I see the value of D.C. and you could not live without it in during long distance trips and so on and so forth. So I guess that's the need that's been demonstrated.

I can see a place for these large DC chargers if you really need to charge quickly in for example supermarket chains, the parking of supermarket chains, or pardon me, or in petrol stations that are going to be reconverted eventually. But personally I still see a lot of value in AC charging.

I tend to do all my urban charging on AC chargers not because I don't have a DC charger nearby, but just simply because if I'm not in a rush, I don't care and I'm happy to kind of, you know, go plug my car and then pick it up when it's ready. And it's absolutely of no problem to me. I have enough options around me where I live and it just works. And honestly it puts less of a strain on the grid capacity than the big ass 400 kilowatt charger.

Claudio Geyken

We've talked a lot about today. Now as we are getting to the. We're already the visionary. So what is the vision for you for Cariqa, if you were also to think long term?

Strategic vision and closing

Issam Tidjani

Well, for us we really want to become this a commercial interoperability layer of the industry. And that's what we are focused on. We want to make sure that we create a healthy and vibrant ecosystem where chargepoint operators can sell their energy directly across wherever their customers are and they can actively drive their commercial strategy at scale with one single input. That's what we are looking at.

And we know that if you make the parallel on, you know, when fuel is going to be phased out and electricity is going to be the, the main fuel again to go around. We see that even without counting China. This is a trillion dollar market. So we don't need to get obsessed about finding new revenue streams or anything. We just need to be focused on making it great for ChargePoint operators to sell their energy for us.

We need to make it great for the developers on the connect side to make sure that they have a reliable and robust product. And yeah, I think that that's our job.

Claudio Geyken

So you arrived here with an EV. Yeah. Usually you drive EVs. That's good. When you have like 20 minutes on a charge, what do you usually like to spend your time on?

Issam Tidjani

I wish I had a lot of choices but typically that results in getting my kids to the toilet before the car is ready. And fun fact, the car is ready before the family is ready to move on. So for me this construct of ah, yeah, you lose a lot of time driving an ev. I don't see that because I can promise you that I always try to be a good citizen and be char and leave the plug when it's 80%. I don't need more.

But let's say that realistically is more 85% because yeah, it takes longer for the kids to have done their toilet run and stretch their legs and eat something rather than the car being ready.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah.

Claudio Geyken

And you have done long trips to Italy as well from Berlin all. Time. So it's possible like a lot of Germans like to go. And. It.

Issam Tidjani

The.

Issam Tidjani

I do.

Issam Tidjani

All the time. I, I'm used to it. There are plenty of options to charge along the road. It's honestly, I brought it to a point where I have also no problem into arriving in turtle mode with like, you know, five kilometers of range left in the, in the battery. Because I know that even if one charger doesn't work work, I somehow have an alternative somewhere. I still have this anecdote where I was, it was last summer.

I was coming back with, alone with my two kids on the, on the back seats. And when I drive From Italy it's 1100 kilometers. I come from nearby Milan, so from Berlin is 1100 kilometers and I do it in one go. And I remember that it was like 11 at night, so we were getting closer but still had a couple of hours to go and I had like 5%. And I asked myself, let's hope that this charger works. I knew that I had options.

Claudio Geyken

Oh yeah.

Issam Tidjani

But you ask yourself the question, what am I gonna do if all of them fail? I guess that. But nevertheless I think that right now you can travel way more relaxed than and you can see the evolution. I mean.

Claudio Geyken

Yeah, it's crazy.

Issam Tidjani

I did my first long distance trip in 2021 and you do it today. It's completely different ball game. You know, chargers are faster, are done before you're ready and you have so many options. That range anxiety in my opinion is a thing of the past or is a thing of somebody that has never driven ev. Then it becomes more kind of charging anxiety. So meaning will I get ripped off or will the charger work?

But that's a different story and which requires different solutions.

Claudio Geyken

And to be fair, the first EV models I've myself also bought a Nissan Leaf where indeed the kilometer range was very very limited. Nowadays it's just a complete different ball game. And indeed I would say it's maybe it's a legacy thinking and we're just getting started also even to improve still range and to improve charging speed. So I think and as you said, solutions like yours and others will keep on improving.

And which solution do you use to pay and to navigate yourself?

Issam Tidjani

Try make a guess.

Claudio Geyken

Very good.

Claudio Geyken

Well Issam, thanks a lot for your time and energy and best of luck with Cariqa.

Issam Tidjani

And thanks a lot of having me. It was a pleasure. And best of luck with RiDERgy.

Claudio Geyken

Thanks a lot. Three things stick from the conversation. First, the price transparency problem won't be solved by regulation alone, but by making the operator the seller again. Cariqa leaves pricing power with the cpo, charges no fees on the demand side and instead shares revenue with those who bring drivers like OEMs and fleets. Second, the economics live or die with utilization 8 to 10% a day break even above 20%.

And the lever isn't blanket discount, but smarter pricing. I loved the Lift Lake example with free charging when there was negative prices in May. So hour by hour, side by side AI driven without cannibalization of the profitable chargers. That's smart charging pricing. Third, charging is no longer just an energy business. When prices go negative, charging can be free. And with V2G you can even get paid with your EV in public chargers.

And the operator still makes money by selling grid services. Issam's supermarket without price tag orange analogy hits the mark. As long as the price depends on which card you pull out, the mass market stays on the sidelines. The platform that changes this doesn't need to reinvent the wheel. Just apply proven marketplace models to the chargepoint. Want to see what that looks like in practice?

Watch the Connect API launch 15 minutes from zero to working charging app at a real charger. Incredible. And if you ever suck at a charger In Italy with two kids and 5%, just remember the car is usually ready before the family is. See you next time. Sa.

S2 Ep. 6 · Issam Tidjani

0:00 / 1:36:16